69 million page views

you have to change your name from ali kalaf ...to someone john patrick or some thing else

Reader comment on item: Documentary Exposes Radical Muslim Rhetoric
in response to reader comment: Muslims have killed muslims since islam originated

Submitted by syed mohammad ali (India), Feb 11, 2007 at 06:01

ali kalaf, i have read that in prophet of doom and the mr craig winn lost the debate anyway .....you are the most hypocrite person i have ever seen after ali sina ...who has a muslim name speak against the islam .well there are war and the booty of war are property ....and widows ...you have to read since from old testament ...anyway .... you have written

Bukhari, Vol4 Chapter 88

Narrated Ibn 'Umar: The Prophet said, "MY LIVELIHOOD IS UNDER THE SHADE OF MY SPEAR, FROM WAR BOOTY, AND HE WHO DISOBEYS MY ORDERS WILL BE HUMILIATED BY PAYING JIZYA TAX."lol it makes laugh tell me how many countries who didnt accept taxes from their people ...and jizya is for ...non muslims who didnt paid the zakat as the part of islamic beliefs....you have also said about bassher al asad who have killed the people of muslim brother hood he was a pure communist...saddam was american stooge so was king abdullah ....who sell their soul for$ ........again your question about kyber war ...Fajr prayer is DAWN prayer; Prayer of fear is SALAT AL KHAWF. Prophet Muhammad's attack on Khaybar is completely justified; go read the history of what those Jews did for them to deserve that. In the United Kingdom the only crime punishable by death is TREASON. In America, spies convicted of treason are executed. If that is justifiable, then the order of the Prophet for the killing of the Jews of Khaybar is more than justifiable, for their betrayal of the Prophet and their breaking of the peace treaty can absolutely not go unpunished.

Narrated By Anas: The Prophet offered the Fajr Prayer near Khaibar when it was still dark and then said, "Allahu-Akbar! Khaibar is destroyed, for whenever we approach a (hostile) nation (to fight), then evil will be the morning for those who have been warned." Then the inhabitants of Khaibar came out running on the roads. The Prophet had their warriors killed, their offspring and woman taken as captives. Safiya was amongst the captives, She first came in the share of Dahya Alkali but later on she belonged to the Prophet. The Prophet made her manumission as her 'Mahr'. ...!!!! Because the word warriors show that those men being killed were FIGHTING AGAINST THE MUSLIMS. But when you just put the word "men", like Craig Winn, it seems like innocent people are being killed. HOW DECEPTIVE CAN A MAN GET?There are many possible meanings for this Hadith. I was kind of surprised when I read it at first. But we don't know the EXACT situation or what the Prophet truly meant. Maybe, maybe THOSE particular women and children were planning to fight against the Muslims with the enemy.

Maybe the Muslim army just could not have blown this chance to attack the enemy that they still had to attack them no matter at what cost in order to stop the risk of more blood shed (do a little bad for the greater good). I SERIOUSLY DOUBT THIS IS CORRECT but I am just guessing. Or the hadith is false. Because this is only ONE hadith and we have so many other authentic hadith where the Prophet clearly prohibited the killing of innocent women and children during time of war.Narrated By 'Abdullah : During some of the Ghazawat of the Prophet a woman was found killed. Allah's Apostle disapproved the killing of women and children. Narrated By Ibn 'Umar : During some of the Ghazawat of Allah's Apostle a woman was found killed, so Allah's Apostle forbade the killing of women and children.

THE PROPHET DIDN'T SAY that only MUSLIM WOMEN AND CHILDREN couldn't be killed during time of war (WOULDN'T MAKE SENSE, WHY WOULD THEY FIGHT THEIR OWN WOMEN AND CHILDREN).

IT IS OBVIOUSLY TALKING ABOUT WOMEN AND CHILDREN OF THE DISBELIEVERS

  • Even during the state of actual war, the Prophet (peace be upon him) gave very definite instructions on protecting the rights and lives of the innocent. Buradah (R) said: "Whenever the Prophet of Allah briefed one of his army commanders, he reminded him to fear Allah in his actions, Fight and do not exceed your limits, do not transgress and do not kill a child." (Muslim, Abu Dawood and At-Tirmidhi)
  • Umar (R) said: "During one of the Prophet's battles, I found a woman that had been killed. In response to this the Prophet prohibited the killing of women and children during war." (Bukhari, Muslim and others)
  • Similarly, Abu Bakr (R), the first Khalifa of Muslims, commanded Usama (R) with the following words of warning, before sending him off on a military expedition: "Do not deceive, do not dishonour a treaty, do not mutilate the dead; nor should you kill a child, an old man or a woman. Do not destroy palm trees nor burn them, neither are you to cut a fruitful tree, do not kill a lamb, a cow or a camel except for purposes of food. You will come across a people who have devoted themselves to the monasteries; leave them, and what they do." ......................
  • The Banu Mustaliq, a branch of Banu Khuza'a occupied the territory of Qadid on the Red Sea shore between Jeddah and Rabigh. In 527 C.E. news was brought to Madina that the Banu Mustaliq in alliance with some other tribes were gathering to make a raid on Madina. The policy of the Holy Prophet was that the Muslims should not lose the initiative in such cases, and should take such tribes by surprise. Another aspect of the policy was that action against individual tribes should be taken before they could effect an alliance.

    Narrated Anas bin Malik: We reached Khaibar early in the morning and the inhabitants of Khaibar came out carrying their spades, and when they saw the Prophet they said, "Muhammad! By Allah! Muhammad and his army!" The Prophet said, "Allahu-Akbar! Khaibar is destroyed, for whenever we approach a (hostile) nation (to fight) then evil will be the morning for those who have been warned." We then got the meat of donkeys (and intended to eat it), but an announcement was made by the announcer of the Prophet, "Allah and His Apostle forbid you to eat the meat of donkeys, as it is an impure thing."

    He read this hadith before posting it, why didn't he put what is in the brackets? This is what the early commentators of this hadith and the early scholars and the people that knew Prophet Muhammad know what the Prophet meant when he said that.

    HE DOES NOT ACCEPT WHAT THOSE PEOPLE PUT IN BRACKETS, BUT CRAIG Winn LIKES TO ADD HIS OWN BRACKETS!! READ THE NEXT RESPONSE TO KNOW WHAT I MEAN. shame shame mr ALI KHALAF YOU DONT KNOW YOUR OWN HISTORY . JUST DROP THIS MUSLIM NAME. YOU SEEM TO BE LIKE OTHER HYPOCRITES ALI SINA, AL DASHTI...AND OTHERS. BY THE WAY YOU QUOTE FROM THE SITE PROPHET OF DOOM ..BY CRAIG WINN WHO LOST BADLY IN DEBATE ...TRY SOMETHING NEW .........LOL

  • Submitting....

    Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

    Submit a comment on this item

    << Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

    Reader comments (126) on this item

    Title Commenter Date Thread
    08 it is called double talk [94 words]Phil GreendJan 28, 2008 17:33119166
    There are peaceful/moderate Muslims... [57 words]MuslimApr 22, 2007 01:1890129
    Shouldnt be shocked [121 words]KatJun 11, 2007 07:4290129
    No Muslim is really interested in peace... [32 words]LarryJul 31, 2007 21:5890129
    Just some additional information [68 words]ChillyFeb 26, 2007 04:1378971
    Oh My! A respected moderate Muslim American businessman caught financing terror. [391 words]gellin&infidellinFeb 20, 2007 09:4978043
    'Stupid American' thats what he is. [73 words]KatFeb 26, 2007 11:0478043
    Kat is right! [52 words]LarryJun 10, 2007 16:0078043
    Encouragement [3 words]KatJun 11, 2007 07:3578043
    1I agree. [37 words]ManalOct 18, 2008 11:2678043
    UN definition of Genocide matches Islamic teachings [225 words]Robert CunninghamFeb 7, 2007 23:3776497
    To Sir Robert [51 words]nna(tchkah)Feb 19, 2007 22:0176497
    UN definition of Genocide [151 words]RobertFeb 20, 2007 17:3976497
    WOW [60 words]ManalOct 18, 2008 11:3776497
    Speak Up! [167 words]Caesar M. ArevaloFeb 7, 2007 21:3576474
    Another Hypothesis, Caesar [240 words]LDCFeb 17, 2007 23:2176474
    easy solution [61 words]HarrakFeb 7, 2007 16:3076420
    666 [107 words]LDCFeb 17, 2007 23:0176420
    Britain Will Soon Surrender followed by Canada and France [159 words]Jeff BurkeFeb 7, 2007 16:0176412
    Neolibs of Canadastan [145 words]JaladhiFeb 7, 2007 20:3076412
    Buck-up, Jeff [94 words]LDCFeb 17, 2007 23:2776412
    I see no reason to NOT be optimistic despite the arsenal of advanced weaponry held by the West [144 words]Jeff BurkeFeb 26, 2007 13:2076412
    Jeff, my man... [119 words]LDCFeb 26, 2007 19:2376412
    You're kidding right ? [58 words]KatJun 11, 2007 07:4676412
    blow ins [66 words]david kennedyJan 6, 2009 17:3776412
    Religion and politics [477 words]jFeb 7, 2007 09:0376377
    Understanding [334 words]TerryFeb 16, 2007 17:5476377
    Rhetoric in British Moslem Mosques [260 words]jFeb 18, 2007 08:4776377
    D'accord [321 words]TerryFeb 19, 2007 17:1776377
    Fear [326 words]jFeb 20, 2007 07:3776377
    they only think to implements islamic laws [129 words]syed mohammad aliFeb 7, 2007 05:3576356
    Muslims have killed muslims since islam originated [461 words]Ali KhalafFeb 7, 2007 18:0576356
    you have to change your name from ali kalaf ...to someone john patrick or some thing else [1169 words]syed mohammad aliFeb 11, 2007 06:0176356
    what a load of nonsense [282 words]Terry CurryFeb 13, 2007 16:2276356
    how many innocents did so called terrorists against those who called themselves a civlized people [288 words]syed mohammad aliFeb 14, 2007 03:5076356
    Our dear syed and the caliphate [32 words]dhimmi no moreFeb 14, 2007 11:5676356
    responding to rubbish [275 words]TerryFeb 14, 2007 16:2776356
    2immorality and porn culture is freedom that is fine...i dont need to understand a sin [258 words]syed mohammad aliFeb 15, 2007 04:0276356
    Insulting comments [194 words]TerryFeb 16, 2007 17:0576356
    Yo, Syed [79 words]LDCFeb 17, 2007 23:4376356
    easier to read [23 words]TerryFeb 18, 2007 18:5376356
    Islam, the religion [169 words]johnFROMjerseyFeb 24, 2007 06:5876356
    syed obsessed with porn... [157 words]susanFeb 25, 2007 15:0676356
    how many dead from Islam itself ?> [62 words]KatJun 11, 2007 07:4876356
    and ?? [251 words]KatJun 11, 2007 07:5876356
    Amen [41 words]KatJun 11, 2007 08:0076356
    re: reply to Kat [115 words]johnFROMjerseyJun 12, 2007 19:2076356
    Okay......... [81 words]KatJun 13, 2007 19:4276356
    how many cases of honor killing [134 words]syed mohammad aliJun 21, 2007 04:3276356
    kat who said maimed genitalia is islamic way [461 words]syed mohammad aliJun 21, 2007 04:4976356
    apostate sites online...... [202 words]KatJun 21, 2007 20:2776356
    You misjudged the argument subject. [482 words]KatJun 21, 2007 20:5676356
    i have gone through all apostate sites [9 words]syed mohammad aliJun 23, 2007 13:4076356
    what do you think? [490 words]syed mohammad aliJun 23, 2007 14:3576356
    Thanks [97 words]KatJun 24, 2007 12:0576356
    that is NOT what happens though. [29 words]KatJun 24, 2007 12:0776356
    agree with you [55 words]syed mohammad aliJun 27, 2007 12:2476356
    find out yourself read these verses [1297 words]syed mohammad aliJun 27, 2007 12:4476356
    truth [58 words]mz. mOct 23, 2014 11:0376356
    'Radical' muslim, as used, a misnomer [127 words]rickzFeb 6, 2007 13:0976273
    Undercover Mosque! [160 words]dhimmi no moreFeb 6, 2007 07:1976247
    and [76 words]KatJun 11, 2007 08:1476247
    There is only One Islam, and it is Radical [580 words]Caesar M. ArevaloFeb 6, 2007 02:5976218
    Islam is all radical [242 words]JaladhiFeb 7, 2007 15:2576218
    Arevalo, I could not agree with you more [107 words]AhmedFeb 7, 2007 17:0976218
    Key words,,,,,,,,,REFUSAL TO ADMIT [29 words]KatJun 11, 2007 08:0276218
    Why The Shallow Learning Curve? [511 words]orange yonasonFeb 6, 2007 01:0876206
    Friends? not !!! [232 words]dfwhite19438Feb 6, 2007 00:1576187
    dfwhite, crack open... [29 words]LDCFeb 6, 2007 17:0776187
    victims of un-bridled greed [147 words]joe danFeb 12, 2007 11:2576187
    50% of British Muslims are Islamist? What about Canadian Muslims [251 words]M.D. AnthonyFeb 5, 2007 23:5376186
    Poll results in USA and Canada will be similar to those in UK [416 words]JaladhiFeb 8, 2007 15:2976186
    its up ?? [92 words]KatJun 11, 2007 08:1076186
    Moderate vs. Radical [64 words]BertFeb 5, 2007 22:2676178
    The Wilderness is Shrinking [35 words]LDCFeb 5, 2007 21:2276171
    A challenge to Tony Blair! [563 words]nick4693Feb 5, 2007 20:4776168
    Nothing to be astonished about [140 words]SanchezFeb 5, 2007 20:2876166
    "Undercover Mosque" [8 words]Michael BenensonFeb 5, 2007 18:5776154
    Under Cover Mosque [12 words]BrandonFeb 8, 2007 12:2976154
    Piggy-backing [150 words]David W. LincolnFeb 5, 2007 18:4276148
    Say What? [11 words]LDCFeb 6, 2007 17:1876148
    Hopefully clearer than mud [421 words]David W. LincolnFeb 7, 2007 23:5476148
    Much Clearer, Thanks [3 words]LCDFeb 8, 2007 16:3276148
    1Radical Islam. The word 'Radical' seem redundant. [69 words]SergeyFeb 5, 2007 18:0976138
    Islam by concept is FUNDAMENTALIST -- reply to Sergey [100 words]Romesh ChanderFeb 5, 2007 18:4976138
    "Radical" / "Extreme" / Violent Islam is True / Pure Koranic Islam [192 words]Keith SkillicornFeb 5, 2007 19:2376138
    totally agree [157 words]TerryFeb 16, 2007 18:2976138
    Keep Perspective [67 words]LDCFeb 17, 2007 23:3676138
    Identifying a threat is not enough [131 words]TerryFeb 19, 2007 17:3376138
    Don't Underestimate... [130 words]LDCFeb 19, 2007 19:2476138
    wait til those records are opened ....... [242 words]KatJun 11, 2007 08:3176138
    Canada: Classic Left Wing Mentality, Anti US, Israel = Hizbollah A budding Canadistan [171 words]Nabil ShwarmaFeb 5, 2007 17:3076131
    Threat Level Awareness, And Response [172 words]orange yonasonFeb 6, 2007 11:5876131
    You would have to live here to understand what's going on... [241 words]J.S.Feb 7, 2007 19:1576131
    . . . And I'm In Good Company [72 words]orange yonasonFeb 9, 2007 13:3176131
    Please read Nabil: How Canadians really feel [173 words]gellin&infidellinFeb 10, 2007 13:0776131
    Research in the USA [44 words]MariFeb 5, 2007 16:5676126
    You are darn right [52 words]JaladhiFeb 6, 2007 13:0076126
    Radical Muslim Rhetoric [114 words]Romesh ChanderFeb 5, 2007 15:5376118
    Romesh [8 words]LDCFeb 5, 2007 21:2676118
    Reply to LDC -- I hope British have the guts to smash Islamic Fundamentalism [76 words]Romesh ChanderFeb 6, 2007 16:2176118
    Brits & Islamists [134 words]LDCFeb 6, 2007 17:0476118
    thank you [35 words]TerryFeb 17, 2007 20:3576118
    Terry... [30 words]LDCFeb 17, 2007 22:4976118
    Ugly indeed [30 words]TerryFeb 18, 2007 18:4476118
    radical islam [34 words]herb abelowFeb 5, 2007 15:0476114
    Documentary Exposes Radical Muslim Rhetoric [233 words]MariaFeb 5, 2007 14:4176110
    Good Muslims [193 words]orange yonasonFeb 6, 2007 01:5076110
    there are no effective moderates [73 words]truth_finderFeb 6, 2007 02:0276110
    You can'ttrust them [28 words]JaladhiFeb 6, 2007 09:2876110
    Britain could be the first to surrender [118 words]muminsalihFeb 6, 2007 15:4076110
    Don't trust them at all [49 words]jesperFeb 7, 2007 08:1976110
    Maria, only safe muslims are ex-muslims [130 words]NaziaFeb 7, 2007 16:2176110
    Nazia, Islam today is a very dangerous disease! [67 words]MosheFeb 8, 2007 03:0176110
    Documentary exposes Muslim rhetoric [271 words]FaqiFeb 8, 2007 04:0976110
    Moshe, Nazia, jester & muminsalih [27 words]LDCFeb 8, 2007 16:3976110
    Hate documentary [203 words]Terry CurryFeb 12, 2007 15:5376110
    nazia ...you are ex muslimah [432 words]syed mohammad aliFeb 13, 2007 01:4176110
    nazia you have no idea what you're talking about [99 words]AaliyahApr 8, 2007 18:4676110
    recount please....... [63 words]KatJun 11, 2007 08:3776110
    Perhaps you should show this [113 words]KatJun 11, 2007 08:4476110
    You have a problem...... [40 words]KatJun 11, 2007 08:4676110
    who said old testament is abandoned [87 words]syed mohammad aliJun 21, 2007 04:2576110
    Many ignore it..... [269 words]KatJun 21, 2007 20:3776110
    horror of war [23 words]syed mohammad aliJun 23, 2007 14:1976110
    our leadership.... [281 words]KatJun 24, 2007 11:5876110

    Follow Daniel Pipes

    Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

    All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

    Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

    (The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

    Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

    For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)