2 readers online now  |  69 million page views
You're invited: Join Daniel Pipes & MEF on a fact-finding mission
to Poland, Hungary & Austria. For more information, click here

On the Civil War in Israel to this day, and at least since 1947, or since 70 AD

Reader comment on item: Why Israelis Shy from Victory

Submitted by Robert (United States), Sep 2, 2018 at 09:31

On the Civil War in Israel to this day, and at least since 1947, or since 70 AD

I suggest you replace the term "Victory" with "Vanquish," or better yet "Pacify."

Except for its metaphorical meaning of "Winning," I don't think "Victory" is a good enough word for what I understand you would like Israel to achieve. One better word I recommend is "Vanquish" because it's scope is goes beyond the military field. As you well know, in 1948 Israel "miraculously" defeated 5 or so invading armies of foreign Arab countries while engaged in a Civil War against its Arab neighbors in what was then Palestine. In 1956, Israel again was "victorious," but this time it was accomplished jointly with England and France when Nasser nationalized the Suez Canal. However, in 1967 Israel's "victory" was all its when it defeated all its Arab enemies while extending beyond its Armistice lines to the whole of the remnant of the former Palestine Mandate excerpted from the former Transjordan which subsequently became Jordan.

I've recited this history which you know extremely well in order to emphasize that, strictly speaking, military "victory" is not at issue for Israel. Rather, the issue essentially is the non-military one: what comes next after the military generals of have achieved their military goals. In fact, I shall argue that it precisely such a term as "Victory" which misleads the public especially in undue preoccupation with military tactics against the Palestinians, whereas it is only Iran, as Netanyahu repeatedly claimed, possess a serious existential threat to the Jewish State of Israel.

Much of what I want to say has been well put in writing by great Israeli official in 2002, Dore Gold (1953-), regarding the distinction between "Occupied Territories" as opposed to "Disputed Territories." His excellent legal, political, and diplomatic analysis is expressed here:

Jerusalem Letter / Viewpoints
No. 470 3 Shvat 5762 / 16 January 2002
FROM "OCCUPIED TERRITORIES" TO "DISPUTED TERRITORIES"
Dore Gold
"Occupation" as an Accusation / The Terminology of Other Territorial Disputes / No Previously-Recognized Sovereignty in the Territories / Aggression vs. Self-Defense / Israeli Rights in the Territories / After Oslo, Can the Territories be Characterized as "Occupied"?
http://www.jcpa.org/jl/vp470.htm

The only substantial and serious criticism I have of his view is that he omits the Coup de Grass of his argument – that the Jewish State of Israel is in a continuous state of Civil War against its Arab population who have called themselves Palestinians who did not wish to be Israelis – until very recently, perhaps, some, as the King of Jordan recently observed and reported.

It is my view that if Israel is "loosing," the loss is mainly in the non-military realm; if Israel isn't "winning," it is in the diplomatic and Hasbara realms where it has been most inept.

In the 19th century in Europe Nationalism had emerged together with Irredentist Revolutions. "Racism" did not mean what it did later it was still indistinguishable with legitimate Nation of the French people of the French Revolution. Subsequently, it also inspired the Germans under Bismarck to seek to form a National State of out the German Confederation that followed the defeat of the French empire under Napoleon Bonaparte. Poland and Finland eventually split of from the Russian Empire, as did the Baltic countries of the former Ottoman Empire in the 20th Century. It is in this context that Israel's "Thomas Jefferson," the Austrian Empire Jewish journalist, Theodor Herzl, had published in 1896 in Vienna his pamphlet or book, "Der Judenstaat" ("The Jewish State"). And only a year later, in 1897, The First Zionist Congress convened. It is to be emphasized that the Jews not only have a Religion – they also have a Nationality; they were previously known as a Race, before that term was discredited by Racism. Because of that unfortunate pseudo-scientific heritage among all peoples, the term "Nation" replaced the illegitimate term" Race" (which carries the connotation of Racism).
By 1917, during WWI, the British Empire recognized the legitimate (Nationalism) claim of the Jewish people to their National Home in historic Palestine. That recognition was embodied in a state paper known as the Balfour Declaration. And in 1922, the League of Nations adopted that position into International Law by granting Great Briton its Mandate for Palestine. Subsequently, also the League of Nations went out of existence, its successor, the United Nations, recognized and continued the status of Mandatory Palestine as the Nation Home of the Jews. In particular, arguably the most critical part of the League text is the following:
"Whereas the Principal Allied Powers have also agreed that the Mandatory should be responsible for putting into effect the declaration originally made on November 2nd, 1917, by the Government of His Britannic Majesty, and adopted by the said Powers, in favor of the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, it being clearly understood that nothing should be done which might prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country; and" [http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/palmanda.asp]

It is only the Jewish people who are "favored" regarding a "national home," under the restriction that the "civil and religious rights" of the "existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine" not be prejudiced. This distinction is further amplified by the recognition that Jews have "rights and political status" in "other countries." Accordingly, the "existing non-Jewish communities" do not have a "political right." At best, existing non-Jews in Palestine only have political rights as individuals.

The recently adopted Basic Law of Israel, which recognizes Israel as a Jewish state essentially expresses these provisions of the League of Nations that were continued by its successor organization, the United Nations – Israel is the National Home of the Jewish people, while other communities may live there as equal full citizens free to exercise their civil and religious liberties.

But there is also this total failure on the part of the Israelis establishment to take into consideration the history of "the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country" [emphasis added]. 6,000,000 Jews were exterminated during the Holocaust under the German Nazi, French Vichy, and Italian Fascist regimes. And subsequently, Jews in the Soviet and Communist countries were forced to flee as refugees because of the loss of their civil, religious, and political rights and status. And later, after the establishment of Israel, the Jews in the Arab and Muslim countries also lost their civil, religious, and political status and became refugees.
In this non-stop Civil War within Israel-Palestine since 1947, Israel has disengaged completely from Gaza and established the Palestinian Authority under the leadership of Abbas. Subsequently, Abbas has lost control of Gaza to Hamas, and smaller splinter groups. That, however, is an "internal matter" within the former Mandatory Palestine, and therefore only subject to the Sovereign authority of the State of Israel. Even though Security Council Resolution 242 constitutes an interference in the internal affairs within Israel-Palestine, Israel has fulfilled the legal international law requirements imposed thereby by withdrawing its military from territories in Gaza and the West Bank (again, in spite of the fact that this a Civil War in which the Security Council should have no jurisdiction). A Civil War is waging within Syria – but there the UN isn't imposing its solution; rather, the government has invited Russia, Iran, and its diverse non-state proxies for support.

After military defeats there generally follows "police" action. In the case of Gaza, Israel's withdrawal was followed by rebellion against Abbas's Palestinian Authority. This has the unintended consequence of a division against united Palestinian interests which should wisely be exploited by Israel in its own interests to the extent that the Palestinians refuse to compromise and settle their difference with Israel and its governing coalition.
The Israelis policy on the ground of continuously building "settlements" within the West Bank is an exercise of Israelis "Civil Rights" under the Mandate which still applies. Furthermore, the Palestinians have no Political Status anywhere in Palestine – especially because there are no "borders" within Palestine, only "armistice lines" set up to end the hostilities of the belligerents in the Civil War.

In summary, everything follows naturally from the recognition that Israel is engaged in a Civil War since at least 1947 before Independence, and continuously from Independence ever since 1948 to the present day. Accordingly, Israel as the only Sovereign within all of former Mandatory Palestine is the only state which has legal authority to impose its will on Palestine. It also has the only right to invite other foreign Sovereign powers, such as the United States, Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, the Gulf states, to assist in the Palestinian Arab Rebellion and "Devolution" (term I coin for "going down," as in the case of another Arab Rebellions, including Arab Spring and ISIS. Israel has also the legal authority to penalize the Israeli Arab members of the Knesset for Treason for going outside (as inside) of Israel and asserting the Political Status of non-Jews against the Jewish State of Israel engaged in its Civil War. All other issues follow logically from recognizing Israel as engaged in a continuous Civil War, which requires Police action, instead of Military action, with the exceptions is Iran, and its several "tentacles" in Gaza, Lebanon, Syria, and Iraq, attempting through its Crescent to complete its eventual Encirclement of Israel-Palestine.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submitting....

Daniel Pipes replies:

I appreciate the constructive criticism but "victory" quite exactly expresses what I hope Israel to achieve. If you want to be even more precise, it's a Palestinian defeat.

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (61) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Cradle of Civilization [357 words]Fred HastingsNov 3, 2018 18:04245790
1Outside In Strategy - the Case of the Sultanate of Oman [212 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertOct 30, 2018 00:00245735
1Khashoggie Murder is a Tactical Opportunity for Trump [236 words]RobertOct 24, 2018 10:54245687
There is no substitute for victory [50 words]kandelOct 23, 2018 05:57245658
Why an Israeli "victory" won't bring peace [112 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Jeffrey SheffOct 21, 2018 21:28245621
1Backwardness of Islamic thought [413 words]PrashantOct 22, 2018 19:12245621
2"US Jerusalem consulate merger draws Palestinian anger" - ALJAZEERA [118 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertOct 18, 2018 19:22245555
1Eight (8) Israeli Policies for "Victory" [192 words]RobertOct 16, 2018 11:36245478
2Updating Henry Kissinger's Jordan, Israel, Palestine Plan [170 words]RobertOct 13, 2018 10:08245430
2"Jordanian enclave, not confederation, in Judea and Samaria" by David Singer [442 words]RobertOct 11, 2018 11:51245380
2Marshall Plan II - Trump's Palestinian Deal of the Century [660 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertOct 8, 2018 14:23245295
2Trumps Deal of the Century - A Marshal Plan II (for the Palestinians) [586 words]RobertOct 7, 2018 07:26245270
2On the "So-Called State of Palestine" by John Bolton [520 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
ROct 4, 2018 00:41245192
2March 22, 1979 - History of Israel [514 words]RobertOct 3, 2018 10:07245175
2Between the Sword of the Conqueror and the Scale of Justice: "Jordan is Palestine" (Again) [738 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertOct 2, 2018 11:34245163
2Confederation - Five Way: Egypt-Israel-Jordan-Palestine [778 words]RobertSep 25, 2018 10:44245054
Another version of Israel Victory? [101 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
CamelinspaceSep 25, 2018 07:27245050
2"Danny Danon's "Obsession with Israel" & BDS for China (Tibet), Russia (Unkraine), & Turkey (Kurdistan) [385 words]RobertSep 25, 2018 17:47245050
2On Trump's Rumored "Ultimate Deal" - by Dr.Martin Sherman [155 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertSep 22, 2018 17:04245000
2THE ATLANTIC: "You've lost, get over it." – Trump Team [431 words]RobertSep 20, 2018 14:41244960
2Outside-In Approach, Solution, Stradegy [728 words]RobertSep 20, 2018 10:30244956
Israel Should Not Shy Away from Who It is that Promises Their Victory [157 words]M ToveySep 19, 2018 16:37244931
2Very Complex Strategies Required [448 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertSep 18, 2018 09:07244911
2The New "Pale of Settlement" for Jews: Israel, But NO "JEWS ALLOWED" in Leftover Former Mandatory Palestine [470 words]RobertSep 15, 2018 15:25244876
2On the Road to Victorious Israel - In the Eye of the Storm of Political Islam [665 words]RobertSep 15, 2018 13:40244874
2President Trump Wages "War" on Palestinian Exceptionalism, Writes Journalist CAROLINE B. GLICK [308 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertSep 13, 2018 18:06244855
2"Victory" on the Plains and Fields of Education on American University Campuses [248 words]RobertSep 13, 2018 14:45244851
2President Donald Trump "Onion-Peeling" Policy for Israel's Victory is Making the Philistines Cry [187 words]RobertSep 13, 2018 12:46244849
2Nazi Europe's Ethnic Cleansing of Jews [332 words]RobertSep 11, 2018 19:14244830
29/11 (September 11, 2001) Anniversary Today - 19 Non-Philistine Arabs did it. [134 words]RobertSep 11, 2018 10:16244817
Maybe, because Westerners have not yet ended their proxy war against Israel? [557 words]Martin J. MallietSep 10, 2018 20:48244809
2Realpolitiks vs. The Truth (Or does it?) [355 words]RobertSep 11, 2018 14:38244809
Miguel de Cervantes and Edward Saïd [280 words]Martin J. MallietSep 11, 2018 18:36244809
1Israel needs to play offense not defence [178 words]globe trotterSep 10, 2018 20:00244808
4"Trump administration closing PLO mission in Washington" - Andrew O'Reilly [98 words]RobertSep 10, 2018 16:53244805
2A Simple Analogy. [40 words]Reynald de ChatillonSep 10, 2018 01:19244792
Your simple analogy is indeed very useful … [205 words]Martin J. MallietSep 12, 2018 11:11244792
Your simple analogy as also been very helpful … [288 words]Martin J. MallietSep 13, 2018 02:13244792
A Simple Clarification. [89 words]Reynald de ChatillonSep 14, 2018 01:33244792
2"We don't tell Israel what to do" – David Friedman, September 8, 2018, Ariel Kahan [218 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertSep 9, 2018 14:14244786
2Four-State Solution: Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, & Iraq [291 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertSep 9, 2018 13:42244785
21948-2018 Israel's Civil War Against the Philistines [472 words]RobertSep 8, 2018 13:38244777
Legitimising the Enemy. [230 words]Reynald de ChatillonSep 8, 2018 01:01244767
Double entendres can be understood in many ways [92 words]Martin J. MallietSep 12, 2018 11:50244767
2How American Conservatice Republicans Shy from an Israeli Victory [232 words]RobertSep 6, 2018 22:35244742
2Timidity of Israeli government [135 words]Martin ZukoffSep 6, 2018 15:21244729
3Victory Requires Knowin Who Your Enemy Is [267 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertSep 6, 2018 13:20244727
Palestinians will "never give up." [31 words]RobertSep 6, 2018 23:38244727
Palestinian steadfastness [558 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Shepard BarbashSep 5, 2018 23:28244715
2One makes peace only with the enemy? [62 words]Yakov FaitelsonSep 5, 2018 16:45244693
1Dangerous Attitudes and Beliefs [99 words]BisleySep 5, 2018 14:36244690
2Way to Victory: Regime Change in Iran ? [221 words]RobertSep 4, 2018 07:09244618
Why even bother anymore? [17 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
George_BannerSep 3, 2018 22:04244604
3But the "War"is waging primarily outside Israel-Palestine [411 words]RobertSep 3, 2018 09:24244587
1It is not based on logic [172 words]Bart BenschopSep 3, 2018 04:38244582
3On the Civil War in Israel to this day, and at least since 1947, or since 70 AD [1569 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertSep 2, 2018 09:31244573
1Jews Are Reluctant Warriors [218 words]DaveSep 1, 2018 13:42244557
2Not Military, but Civil, Political, and International Goals [333 words]RobertAug 31, 2018 22:44244542
2Soviet Propaganda's Ripple Effect Must Be Overcome [378 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
DaveAug 31, 2018 18:38244537
3Is it a local Civl War - or a Jihad against the West? [139 words]RobertAug 31, 2018 23:16244537
1Good Point or...Stating the Obvious [70 words]DaveSep 6, 2018 11:56244537

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to On the Civil War in Israel to this day, and at least since 1947, or since 70 AD by Robert

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2018 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)