2 readers online now  |  69 million page views

You have brought a mighty rubbish thing

Reader comment on item: Israel and Clear Victory
in response to reader comment: Here are a few off the top of my head

Submitted by sTs (United Arab Emirates), Jan 27, 2009 at 02:43

1. Over 12,000 recorded terrorist attacks just since 2000 in the name of Islam or committed by Muslims from Thailand to the Philippines to Spain to the Uk to the United States to Russia to India to Kenya and every point in between. That´s about 11,990 more than all the other religions combined.

(Christians forced Muslims to convert during Crusades, in the Philippines the nation was Muslim and by force converted to Christianity - The Muslim world after the collapse of the ottoman empire were Oppressed - their lands were occupied and their people were killed, any uprising is suppressed - what do you expect, see tha Bask in Spain and the Shin fien in Irland they are rising against the british and spanish regime for their independence, see the baden , every were in the woreld there are Muslim they are oppressed, look how they promised the Jews a land it does not belong to the occupier. - you must know almost all troubles of the world is becaudse of this promise that was given by the British - the Muslims have the right to uprise against the aggressors. - you don't see that do you???

2. No free will or choice of religion for individuals born into Islamic lands or to Muslim parents.

(Obama was a Muslim, he was changed to Christian- did he have free will) - besides many Muslims were changed to Christianity by force, did they have free will)

3. An "apostate" if you choose to leave a religion (Islam) forced upon you, and the Koran sanctions an apostates death. No other religion attempts to force a person to remain in it, besides be born in it without a choice. (Christians may be raised in a Christian home to Christian parents, but make a choice to become Christian themselves, if they choose, later when they are old enough to read the New Testament and make sound choices on their own.

(The Quran does not order the killing of a Muslim if converted to any other religion - but Islam and Muhammad commanded so to any Muslim converts and make mischief - conversion by itself is not condemned to death, but making loud noise about it is condemned to death.

4. Men relegate women to lower staus, allowing men to marry up to four wives, yet allowing a woman only one husband; a female rape victim needs four male Muslim witnesses; the Koran states a daughter is to get half of what a son would get in inheretance, etc. Koran sanctions beating a wife. Christianity and Judaism allows for reform on matters obviously from ancient times, but the Koran cannot and never will.

(Women in Islam elated, they were considered lowly by the Jews and the Christians.) they have right to possess, they have right to inherit, they have right to do business - unlike old time Jews and christians - the woman had no rights)

5. No criticism allowed of the prophet of Islam or Islam itself. If you think you can, write a column to your newspaper doing so and give your name and address.

(Do you critisize Jesus???),

6. Islam´s prophet was a war lord with blood on his hands who sanctioned to deaths/murder of untold numbers.

(wrong, you are not reading any Islim books seems, you only read hate books), (God says in the Quran, fight those who fight you and do NOT aggress)

7. The prophet of Islam and the Koran encourage the hatred of Jews, Hindis (polythiests) and to not befriend Christians.

(The Jews did not leave any room for reconcileation even with God, so God put His wrath on them, they are cursed in the Torah, Gospel and the Quran, it is not only Islam who hate the Jews, God hates the Jews in the Torah)

8. The concept of Jihad, which is today the cancer of the planet and a threat to all humanity.

(This is similar to point (2), Jihad is commanded in the Torah and in the Gospel and it is worse. the torah command the killing of children and women and command the Jews to keep the little women 9virgin) to their pleasure)

9. "Fatwas" put on the heads of people who criticize or question Islam; people like Geert Wilkders, Hershi Ali, S. Rushdie, The Dutch cartoonists, and untold number of others whose lives are ruined now because of Muslims who believe t}killing people who insult Islam or its prophet will gain them paradise.

(Let me see what would be the reaction of the vatican if someone publicly cursed Jesus)

10. The concept of "the ummah," where Muslims are always supported and backed no matter how wrong and evil their deds, which is why you see Muslims protesting like raging maniacs at cartoons, yet not a peep about Breslin or Mumbai, and even cheering in the streets when 3000 innocent civilian Americans die at Muslim hands.

(Jews support each other, Christians support each other, there is no issue in here, you would support your brothers and sisters from your parent, would you NOT?)

11. Muslisms all over the world in the last month going into the streets either praising Hitler or berating him for not finishing the job, calling for the seaths of Jews openly - and not just Israeli Jews, but Jews period - and publicly without recrimmination from anyone in the Arab press, because Mohammed himself called for the deaths of Jews. (

Hitler said in his memoires that he left few of the Jews to show the world why he was agaisnt them)

12. Over 200 verses in the Koran calling for Jihad and fighting the "infidels" and "kufrs" and "unbelievers" until Islam is supreme over all, which if followed (which it is by millions of Muslims) means perpetual war in the world until everyone is a Muslim or serving Muslims as dhimmis. (

Only thos who fight the Muslims, and if th eKafir opted for peace then incline to peace) this is what the Quran teaches us.

13. The belief by Muslims that God Himself would choose as a prophet a man of war, a raider of caravans (thief and robber), a killer of innocents, a peadophile who actually married a six year old little girl and had sex with her when she was nine, a bigot full of hatred for all who questioned hhim or did not follow him, and demanded his followers also hate, and a dozen other wonderful little tidbits about Mohammed - that over a billion Muslims actually believe a man like this would be chosen by God as an example of manhood and to be a prophet. (Or do most Muslims know God is loving and intelligent enough to know what major and very serious problems a Mohammed brings into the world but are too afraid to say so for fear opf losing their lives?

(First a peadophile would be surrounded by little children,all his wives were widowed, old, or divorced, except one who was virign of 11. (so he is not peadophile, second I want you to give more reasons for your description of GOd's Prophet that will enter you to HELL, He is not a warlord, He is not killer of innocent, also check the USA law in the 1930 what is the legal age for a girl to marry also check why caesar emperor of Rome set a law for the girl age to be married at 10, (because the parents used to make them marry at much lower age. also check what was the age of St. Mary when she delivered Jesus Christ (she was 11 years of age)

14. Islam is hated by the masses because it deserves to be hated by the masses because of its violence, bigotry, hatred, and oppression (just to name a few things). It is the cancer of the Earth and a threat to all nonMuslims in the world. Read the news....daily.

(Ofcourse it is hated by the masses who follow the Jewish Media who is controlling almost all the world media.)

15. Islam is political and not separate from an Islamic country´s policy, which presents a myriad of problems as we see today (and throughout history). There is only one "Christian" country: The Vatican, the smallest country in the world, where The Pope resides. And it is non-political. Jesus set the principal (because He KNEW what was best) of separating religion from government.

Islam and Judaism are political as well as spiritual, and you follow Judaism)

16. I could go on if you wish me to continue later about my "problem with Islam." Mostly the same things the rest of the Western world and most of the Eastern world consider problems with Islam.

(All your points are rubbish and do sho how shallow your knowledg eof Islam is) - I can go on and on but with your set mind, i don't thing you are worth it)

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to You have brought a mighty rubbish thing by sTs

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List
eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2020 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)