69 million page views

Changing Jihad

Reader comment on item: Jihad through History

Submitted by Reuven Paz (Israel), Jun 1, 2005 at 04:42

I must admit I have not yet read the new book by David Cook. Yet, from Dr. Pipes' comments I can tell that the conclusions of this book seem to be correct and very well presented. As a scholar in the field of radical Islamist movements and doctrines for many years now, I would like to provide the following comments:

a. The radical and extremist interpretations of Jihad in our days, or in the past 25 years since Abdallah Azzam imported his interpretations to Afghanistan, opened the "Pandora box" and the "open university of Global Jihad," and since the killing of an Arab "infidel" president in Egypt, have gone only in one direction -- more extremism.

"Moderate Islam and Muslims," and "moderate Arab and Muslim governments," and there is some misleading use of the term "moderate," indirectly assisted the spread of radical Islamist global Jihad through the attitude towards Israel in particular and Jews in general. A majority of Arab and Muslim governments and publics intensively supported the use of "suicide operations" as an ISLAMICALLY legitimate method of operation, and thus paved the way and opened the door for the legitimacy of such operations on their own soil and against MUSLIMS as well.
One of the leading Saudi clerics of the new generation of the Islamic establishment in the kingdom -- Sheikh Abd al-Muhsin al-Ubaykan -- who is trying nowadays to lead the Saudi fight against its own extremists after they had opened their terrorist Jihad on Saudi soil, admitted it. In an interview already in 2003, he couragiously stated that "the legitimacy for suicide operations in Israel opened a door we could never close." Therefore, whether you support either side of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, this conflict is used by the "moderates" only to inflame the extremists and lead them to more radical interpretations of Jihad.

Two weeks ago, 58 Pakistani clerics signed a fatwa that prohibited suicide operations. In the several hours that followed this fatwa, a spokesman of the group hurried up to clarify publically that the prohibition "does not include Kashmir, Iraq, and Palestine." The Muslim official policy of "moderates" is hypocritic and comes only, so far, to defend themselves but not to deal with the real issue.

b. Radical doctrines of Jihad are flexible and dynamic. They depend also on the changing definitions of the ENEMY. Yet, there is a permanent factor -- the sense that they could never close the wide gap between them and the West in most fields. Therefore, they are motivated by the sense of humiliation, and hence, the automatic tendency to through everything against the West and its culture, looking backwards to the glorious past of the Muslim empire of the Middle Ages. This sense of humiliation is shared by almost all Muslims, including in Muslim communities in the West.

Humiliation, as wrote Franz Fanon in the 1960s, is a main factor in extremism and the approach to violence. Fanon was one of the leading ideologues of secular neo-Marxist terrorism, but it implies to Muslims and Islamists as well. Wether this sense is justified or not, the fact is that it exists and it is very difficult, maybe impossible to uproot it from the Muslim mindset of both extremists and moderates. Therefore, the answer to radical jihad is only through education of the future generations of young Muslims. But, not by imposing upon them what the West or the United States view as "correct" -- Western terms of democracy; imposed reforms in the curriculum of their studies; radical and quick changes of national order such as the power given to the Shiites in Iraq after 500 years of Sunni rule.

Fighting global Jihad and extremism is a very long mission and cannot be acheived in a generation or two. Continuing sense of humiliation through what they, including the "moderates," perceive as "Western cultural colonialism" could only lead to further support for the doctrines of global Jihad.

c. ALL the developments of the doctrines of global Jihad with no exception, come from the Arab world and exported to the non-Arab Muslim world, where the majority of Muslims and moderate forms of Islam exist. Fighting extremist interpretations of Jihad should start above all in the Arab world itself. The non-Arab Muslim world has no influence over the Arabs. Moderate interpretations of Islam in India, Indonesia, or Central Asia, are useless in the Arab world. The change could come only from within the Arabs, and there the focus should be.

d. One of the most helping elements for radical Jihadists is the fact that they are in many cases the only opposition to dictatorships, some of them are less cruel but not better than Saddam Husein's. Hence, Islamist groups became leading elements in struggling for human and civil rights, and gain support by youngsters who are naturally attracted to such movements of opposition. Jihad in their eyes is not just anger, terrorism, anti-Americanism or Judaism, or an attampt to blame the Western enemy for all their suffering. This is in many cases perceived as a struggle for freedom, civil rights, reformism, and values that the United States is doing its best to export to the Arab world. They cannot support the United States while she is the primary shield for the Saudi royal family.

Support for global jihad is in many cases a very emotional element, motivated by the complexity and ambivalency of the socio-political situation in the Arab world, and the messages of the doctrines of global Jihad. Especially when the heart and mind of those Jihadi fighters who exiled from the Arab world remained in their own homelands -- Osama bin Laden in Saudi Arabia; Zawahiri in Egypt; Azzam in Palestine, and even Zarqawi in Jordan, not in Iraq. The globalization of modern Jihad was also a means to bypass the difficulties of fighting on Arab soil. It was also a political compulsion that was covered by Islamist doctrines.

Thank you

Reuven Paz
PRISM
Israel

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (69) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1Mistaken Morality of Contemporary Terrorism; Stop using the word Jihad [234 words]Athar Waheed,Msc Criminology LSE, LondonFeb 8, 2007 11:5676553
Question [10 words]JessicaDec 13, 2010 16:1476553
Sophistry [17 words]Jeremy PoyntonFeb 11, 2011 04:5676553
1A Challenge to all Muslims [183 words]DaoudApr 23, 2006 21:4743948
1Don't Judge [193 words]What Jihad really isDec 13, 2006 12:1243948
well said [2 words]chrisApr 13, 2009 07:4243948
What is JIHAD? [42 words]Usman SabriApr 19, 2006 16:4243592
could any1 finish or terminate god's words and help to people? [43 words]kontarSep 23, 2006 18:5843592
3A Saudi teenager opinions in Jihad [243 words]mido .....Nov 29, 2005 03:4328965
2Islamification of Europe [164 words]DeanNov 22, 2005 20:4728734
3Subversion [373 words]BritishPatriotJul 27, 2007 04:0628734
1You're right [53 words]LeahMay 22, 2008 15:0728734
Resist Now [153 words]charles martelMay 17, 2012 20:2428734
all religion cause wars [110 words]joeNov 14, 2005 13:2328364
The great wars [18 words]KellyDavisMar 17, 2008 20:2428364
2Three Christian girls beheaded in Indonesia [67 words]CristinaOct 30, 2005 17:1427523
cowards [20 words]maheshSep 15, 2008 13:0327523
More fatwa fibs [1029 words]Ilana MercerAug 2, 2005 12:0224211
Hostile Islam: The Biblical Perspective [296 words]william h walshJul 15, 2005 09:1323508
vessels of mercy [438 words]RicFeb 4, 2006 21:0623508
Christian Suicide Pact? [77 words]SusanMar 16, 2006 15:1123508
Us vs. Them? [341 words]ScootterAug 20, 2006 01:0723508
the Myth of Moderate Islam [208 words]Dennis DuBoisJul 13, 2005 11:4423452
1Jihad [70 words]Shakeel ShaikhNov 13, 2007 10:3123452
Let's do justice to the history of Islam [467 words]Mustapha BabaganaJun 29, 2005 09:1422997
Islamic Terrorism and its Truth [49 words]Elias D'CostaJun 28, 2005 16:1222949
Our Man in the Trenches [94 words]Dave M. O'NeillJun 23, 2005 01:4422813
Ask the Balkans and they will tell you what Jihad did to them [105 words]ashar khokharJun 22, 2005 16:4722804
Jihad in New York City [212 words]Arlinda DeAngelisJun 17, 2005 21:5422733
Islamist Year Zero [88 words]TimbreJun 6, 2005 23:4322586
Do We Fully Appreciate The Madness Of Their Method? [664 words]YonasonJun 6, 2005 17:4522582
Isolation may be necessary [227 words]PatJun 6, 2005 14:4622581
Comment by Pat [4 words]BlueEyesFrJan 3, 2009 13:2122581
Understanding Jihad Through Quran [30 words]AliJun 6, 2005 05:2322576
Understanding Jihad [312 words]David PazJun 5, 2005 17:3422570
do you really believe this is the future? [158 words]Laura MaizelsJun 5, 2005 01:2722562
Jihad in religious sense [452 words]WernerJun 4, 2005 11:1422555
Jihadist only know the language of strength [51 words]S.C.PandaJun 4, 2005 06:2322553
An Age of Denial [264 words]Zeph SteeleJun 4, 2005 05:1022552
Choking on words [363 words]Vernon RichardsJun 3, 2005 17:4722549
The story is a bit more complicated [158 words]Jonathan WeitsmanJun 3, 2005 15:3622545
I have got good news! [153 words]Octavio JohansonJun 3, 2005 02:0822540
Q. How long has America been at war with militant Islam? [240 words]YonasonJun 2, 2005 19:1422537
Ancient and Modern Jihad [105 words]Rob JamesJun 2, 2005 14:4422535
Multiculturalist madness [41 words]Octavio JohansonJun 2, 2005 10:2922534
Jaladhi is correct [109 words]Roger E. NasiffJun 2, 2005 09:0922532
Jihad [61 words]Mike RolfJun 2, 2005 07:3622531
Pure Hogwash!!! [150 words]Arvind MadhavanJun 2, 2005 04:3122529
"Disillusioned" youth? You fell into the trap! [222 words]J SchamrothJun 2, 2005 04:1622528
1Have you ever even read the Koran? [266 words]KMDec 12, 2006 02:4222528
It must rain lollypops and gumdrops where you live. [7 words]tonyJun 26, 2007 02:4222528
Optomists and Marine 'T' shirts - The balance! [195 words]Andy StephensonJun 2, 2005 01:3722527
Jihad Through History [430 words]Walter ManchurJun 1, 2005 22:3022526
Blasphemy laws [17 words]J TILMAJun 1, 2005 17:4022523
Muslim terrorism -Jihad in the service of Islamism or justifiable revenge? [422 words]GuyJun 1, 2005 16:5422521
Misinterpretation of Muslim Beliefs [178 words]Peace loverJan 1, 2008 00:1222521
Meaning is in the use. [78 words]Matthew BessonJun 1, 2005 16:3922519
Video clip I got [3 words]Sergio M.Jun 1, 2005 16:2322518
Convert or Die [45 words]Cecil DonahoJun 1, 2005 14:1122516
Jihad only means holy war - nothing else. [158 words]JaladhiJun 1, 2005 14:0822515
Of course jihad means war...who doesn't know that? [159 words]Dr Ahmed Youssif. MDJun 1, 2005 13:3222514
Islam Jihad is the same today as it was in the beginning [130 words]Roger E. NasiffJun 1, 2005 09:3022507
Roger E. Nasiff (United States), Jun 1, 2005 at 09:30 [25 words]RandyMay 24, 2011 10:4722507
1Our dear Randy is another victim of Arabian imperialism [283 words]dhimmi no moreMay 28, 2011 06:4722507
Changing Jihad [991 words]Reuven PazJun 1, 2005 04:4222502
The true meaning of the word "Jihad" [216 words]Octavio JohansonJun 1, 2005 03:4722500
Demographic development and Jihad [177 words]WernerJun 1, 2005 01:4422498
Jihad [112 words]Donald W. Bales, M.D.May 31, 2005 20:4822495
A Plague upon all your houses..... [424 words]AlanoSep 3, 2007 08:0522495

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)