1 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Dear ANN BALFOUR - Response

Reader comment on item: My Disrupted Talk at UCLA
in response to reader comment: Dear YNNA:

Submitted by Ynna(TCHKAH) (United States), May 22, 2007 at 19:45

First of all, Ann Balfour.

I studied about AN ARTIST, MANY years ago, called Greta Berlin as an artist, so there is an artist called Greta Berlin.

True I have never seen her .

Many years ago, even before coming to America, I have studied about her in the university, so before calling me Ill informed, plot by yourself on the Web to see that there is another person there that IS an artist and her name is Greta Berlin. I studied about her work, briefly in the University, many years ago, adjacently, as my Metier there, was not this one.

And, Madam Balfour, I'm extremely happy that this woman called Greta Berlin is not the artist.

It would be a tragedy to our environment to have this "activist, so ill informed about the Israeli Tragedy when having Islamo Fascist exterminating them, to have her close to my former Metier.

And, looks to me NOW as an activist that she was a professional parasite, like many self proclaimed activist, e.g.Shapiro. You said you like to hear others' opinions.....

Since you support her attitude and as you said, I do not have to agree with you and her, in my opinion,she is not an activist, she is a professional well paid parasite, wanting to get some support and feel herself as a complete human being.

I'll not bother myself to see her "extensive" writings for what, size (extensiveness), does not mean anything to me, and you said that she has been shot by Israeli Military...

Come On....

...1. I was not there to see.

1.1 I did not hear the Israeli Army Side- a true balanced position that you didn't bother to take, as a "balanced woman".

2. Was she in the middle of a shooting time in between the Israeli Army struggling to defend its people, and she by being brain washed by Islamic Fascists was defending Palestinian children who were being used by Hamas to attack Israelis, or what, so this argument maybe or not a fallacy.....

3.She was attacked by a Hebron Settler?

You are ill informed Ann Balfour....

Actually you called me so aggressively- ill informed-, because you took sides already, despite to the fact that you "like" to hear different opinions, struggling to picture yourself as a very fair and balanced woman, which I totally disagree.

A Hebron Jewish citizen, is NOT a settler.

Jews have been living in that region for centuries....

The case of the fallacies of the occupied territories and the biased and Wrong interpretation of resolution 242, does not corroborate the Jewish citizen living there as a settler, and again, was madam Berlin protecting a hamas that was trying to mutilate the "settler" and kill a victim of their terrorism, so by playing human shield and thus a hero, Berlin was looking forward to be recognized- YOUR argument is not acceptable by me- for the simple lack of proof.

AND,

This is not an illegal occupation.

But, this place- right here- is not a blog to discuss the lack of accuracy in your speech.

So the most important two things here are:

1. I'm extremely happy she is NOT THE artist. It will be deplorable to a real artist spirituality.

2. You are not a balanced woman, MADAM BALFOUR-despite to the fact that you use a sort of a Dale Carnegie tool and a small touch of Orwellian language here, to be seen by others as fair and very reasonable person.

The tune of your speech here was full of emotion and support for Berlin and aggression against me.

Yet, I do think it is ridiculous, at least in my culture, perhaps not in your culture, to a woman in her 60s and 70s, to disrespect students at the University, as Madam Allison expressed the way she was disrespected by the time she tried to reach a sit- a brief e.g.

Time to hang up her boots.

So, if you are to reply my answer, please do not come with stupid discussion about illegal occupation, for what it is not illegal, nor an occupation., There is nothing absolutely you can say, that will change my mind about the way Islamic fascist are struggling to make up the history.

Again, the fact that BERLIN was attacked by a settler, and the Jewish military, are non proven facts and by the way, widely repeated as a mantra by Islamic facists and Jews haters playing victims.

...And she deeply disrespected Dr. Daniel Pipes, so since you are such a balanced woman, did you try at least to silence her, for what if it were her lecture, then she could have act in any way she would want, but this lecture was provided by an organization, so she should respect others or leave, or call aside later on Dr. Pipes, and as an historian add to his vast experience, her case, without disrupting.

Finally, your first argument, that your normally do not respond to people, but you responded to my post, was not because I was was ill informed.

Yes, about her status as an artist, I was badly informed, but

My Ill informed that touched you was not b/c of that, but b/c I pointed out some painful truths about the situation in my understanding, and its psychological sphere, and you got somehow identified consciously or unconsciously to what I said, so you angrily replied as a way to repel it ASAP.

This is basic lacanian analisis.

Are you well informed about Jaques Lacan, ANN BALFOUR.

And, I wrote ANN BALFOUR instead of Ann Balfour, as a courtesy to the way you addressed me: YNNA- instead of Ynnatchakh.

You want to show you know Russian, Ann....Anyone knows this basic thing, without even knowing a word in Russian. It is Common Culture.....Your do not have to make others non-ill-informed about the diference in between Ynna and Ynnatchkah....Everybody knows that.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submitting....

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (51) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Ex-admirer who woke up first hand [140 words]kjanApr 20, 2016 12:50229076
3what is wrong with our universities? [1378 words]gary fouseJul 15, 2007 22:15103738
Petro-dollars at work. [28 words]AndyMay 23, 2010 00:59103738
IRAN: a solution other than war or appeasement [61 words]John OmidiJul 11, 2007 10:05103446
response to "Israeli Jets vs Iranian Nukes" [429 words]Ron ThompsonJun 13, 2007 09:3797972
2Overboard? [136 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Abraham CorriganJun 6, 2007 12:0296256
2What are you trying to accomplish? [958 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
~JehanZeb~Jun 3, 2007 15:1995898
3Isn't Greta Berlin A Bit Old For College? [107 words]Steve HancockMay 30, 2007 05:4995313
1UCLA insults Daniel Pipes [154 words]Al OrtizMay 30, 2007 00:1695197
1Do the Words, "Goose" and "Gander" Come to Mind? [130 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Julian TepperMay 29, 2007 09:1695109
Revealing statement [157 words]Stuart FaginMay 29, 2007 09:0095108
The cost of letting it slide [40 words]David W. LincolnMay 28, 2007 15:5895040
"handled appropriately" huh? [79 words]Mark PrestonMay 23, 2007 11:2794075
Mark Preston and the Constitution [27 words]Emily ScopesAug 16, 2007 16:3594075
The Constitution is the Constitution [22 words]Mark PrestonAug 16, 2007 21:2694075
Foolish pretention [43 words]Emily ScopesAug 17, 2007 23:2594075
2For some real "Hate Speech," please turn to the Koran [55 words]Acharya SMay 17, 2007 03:0293307
2The anti-Israel Hate Fest at The University of California Irvine [258 words]Richard B Kates, MDMay 9, 2007 23:1892318
1CNI Foundation ad in Sunday NYT, 4/22/07 [168 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Muriel EfronApr 23, 2007 18:0790405
1To Muriel Efron. [754 words]Ynnatchkah Dievetchkah Kharoshaya.May 10, 2007 22:2690405
gratitude [56 words]bea ferreiraApr 21, 2007 13:0790071
2"LIAR" [37 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Greta BerlinApr 19, 2007 23:1989881
1Oh, please [28 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Greta BerlinApr 21, 2007 22:0989881
1To Greta Berlin - the artist. [372 words]Ynna(Tchkah)May 9, 2007 03:0089881
2Motto Perpetuum- Islamo Fascists Heinous Lies- Adopted by Greta Berlin. [387 words]Ynna (tchkah)May 9, 2007 04:0589881
15Greta Berlin acted like a child at UCLA [195 words]Allyson Rowen TaylorMay 17, 2007 01:0689881
To Allyson about Greta and Her "Teen" Buddies [539 words]Ynna (tchkah)May 18, 2007 18:1889881
Dear YNNA: [209 words]Anne BalfourMay 21, 2007 01:3189881
point of order... [181 words]donvanMay 21, 2007 16:0389881
1Dear ANN BALFOUR - Response [983 words]Ynna(TCHKAH)May 22, 2007 19:4589881
Donvan- Loved what you wrote. [2 words]Ynna (Tchkah)May 23, 2007 03:1489881
Puhleese Greta!... [47 words]FrummerMay 27, 2007 18:5889881
1Greta needs a dose of the truth... [302 words]David BlainMay 27, 2007 19:1889881
quite right Frummer [75 words]James ForsythJun 9, 2007 01:0089881
What makes an occupation legal anyways? [219 words]ShintoJul 14, 2007 00:0189881
2Putting the record straight [75 words]Greta Berlin ArtistNov 9, 2007 04:2889881
18A Role Model for Peace? [254 words]Ava E. BerlinNov 9, 2007 20:3989881
3Re: Greta Berlin and her anger [122 words]Allyson Rowen TaylorNov 23, 2007 20:0989881
I have true compassion for Ava Berlin, Greta is a very unpleasant person [144 words]Ryan MervinAug 12, 2012 03:0689881
greta jewish? no. immature? extremely [74 words]alanMay 3, 2018 09:0889881
accompaniment [25 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
DarrenApr 18, 2007 10:1489649
Thanks for the link to my site Dr. Pipes [2 words]Student of ObjectivismApr 17, 2007 01:3789441
fanatical hard-lined leftists [45 words]charles steeleApr 15, 2007 11:5089316
Thanks for participating [181 words]Roger ParianApr 14, 2007 22:3589283
Thank you Daniel [36 words]JohnApr 14, 2007 18:4989264
Islamo-fascism exposed [102 words]dhimmi no moreApr 14, 2007 18:1589262
Part 2 of my coverage of your discussion (pictures) [47 words]Todd (Hecubus)Apr 14, 2007 14:1989236
Good new. [46 words]jamalApr 14, 2007 14:1989235
I led the shout of "out" [270 words]Mark PrestonApr 14, 2007 12:0889222
fair comment [79 words]charles steeleApr 15, 2007 11:3889222
Response for request [20 words]Mark PrestonApr 15, 2007 22:1289222

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Dear ANN BALFOUR - Response by Ynna(TCHKAH)

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2018 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes