69 million page views

treason?

Reader comment on item: Iraq: What's Next?

Submitted by ken yetzer (United States), Apr 3, 2003 at 03:03

Arnett should have not only been fired, he should be indicted for treason. Either this guy is brain dead or he defected to Iraq and now works for Iraqi television.
One important aspect of war (especially this war) is not only the action which takes place on the battlefield, but also the propaganda which may help determine wheather a combatant decides to keep fighting or lay down his arms and give up. If his ignorant comments (given directly to an Iraqi official) possibly cause a single enemy combatant to keep fighting (who might otherwise have come to his senses and quit) and eventually kill one of our soldiers, this is giving aid to the enemy and by definition is "treason".
In addition, one of those comments had to do with the number of Iraqi civilian casualties affecting the American public view of the war. I guess this guy had no idea that the Iraqi regime was ready and willing to sacrifice the lives of these people (by using them as human shields, and or outright killing some of them and blaming it on the americans).
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment

Reader comments (34) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
treason? [185 words]ken yetzerApr 3, 2003 03:037985
Iraqi Peter [64 words]Love My SoldiersApr 2, 2003 06:037928
Professional issue, not a political one [79 words]Molly A. Badgett, APRApr 1, 2003 22:267914
Against war [29 words]Mohammad Ali KhalidApr 1, 2003 21:447911
Too Many Are Missing the Point [127 words]Jason McMahonApr 1, 2003 21:287910
Arnett [25 words]Edgardo GascaApr 1, 2003 21:117908
Arnett should seek another country [43 words]AnnetteApr 1, 2003 18:047894
Bravo arnet..la libertad de expresion no debe morir [60 words]dessin georgesApr 1, 2003 15:447877
Peter Arnett's freedom to speak [48 words]lucy koteenApr 1, 2003 09:397843
Pulitzer Prize for Deception [33 words]NickApr 1, 2003 09:237841
The Truth? [826 words]David UmbargerApr 1, 2003 01:487835
Arnett is entitled to his opinion but... [46 words]Sgt. William R. SayersMar 31, 2003 21:307829
Disgusted with Arnett [81 words]Dr. Larry LippincottMar 31, 2003 21:277828
Peter Arnett's Freedom of Speech [217 words]William Lucas JonesMar 31, 2003 19:567826
May he rot [106 words]DeeDee MoxieMar 31, 2003 18:577823
Arnett's firing is absurd [133 words]wpcMar 31, 2003 18:057822
Arnett the Traitor [13 words]John DanielsMar 31, 2003 17:297820
Peter Arnett [10 words]Rose Marie GruttadauriaMar 31, 2003 17:097818
Pulitzer Prize Winner - Mr. Arnett [66 words]Robert W. WylieMar 31, 2003 12:507812
Bravo Peter Arnett, bravo! [50 words]Laurie ManisMar 31, 2003 12:077810
Another Jane Fonda wannabe [154 words]Robert HuffordMar 31, 2003 10:397807
Peter Arnett fired [35 words]susana bonilla matthewsMar 31, 2003 09:347805
Re: Peter Arnett [199 words]Barbara MireauMar 31, 2003 07:377804
Peter Arnett [89 words]HowieMar 31, 2003 01:527801
Slimy Arnett [49 words]MYWhiteMar 31, 2003 00:097799
Peter Arnett [31 words]Les StierwaltMar 30, 2003 20:287792
Peter Arnett has hurt the war [34 words]John SchlagMar 30, 2003 19:237790
Arnett has gone too far" [100 words]Geraldine M SepulvedaMar 30, 2003 18:487789
another jane fonda [39 words]chester bartkoMar 30, 2003 18:177788
Heck, no he hasn't mellowed! [16 words]M. McAlexanderMar 30, 2003 18:117787
Drain the Swamp [109 words]Glenn KlotzAug 19, 2002 06:431987
Pearls Before Swine [181 words]D.R.Aug 17, 2002 00:531962
Has Peter Arnett mellowed? [35 words]Paul M. NevilleAug 16, 2002 17:341957
Matthews was unfair to Pipes and Hackworth [56 words]Alan MencheerAug 16, 2002 07:501949

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)