69 million page views

Ironically, Ottoman Jews were better tolerated than their Turkish successors

Reader comment on item: Is Turkey Going Rogue?
in response to reader comment: Jews of Eastern Thrace in Turkey were oppressed, expelled in the 1930s

Submitted by Jon Ozdamar (United States), Oct 3, 2011 at 09:38

Iskender (Alexander),

There is no doubt that Turkish Jews were oppressed in the early years of the Republic. However, this oppression was a slap in the wrist compared to what happened to Jews in the first half of the 20th century. Turkey was one of the few countries that helped Jews in the holocaust. (http://www.adl.org/PresRele/ASInt_13/4730_13.htm) Modern politics is pushing Israel into alliance with Greece and Bulgaria, even though both countries enthusiastically gave up their Jews (who they saw as unwanted vestiges from the Ottoman era) to the Nazis

You are obsessed with Dhimmitude, so let's set the record straight:

Ottoman Jews were classified as Dhimmis, and as such were legally inferior to Muslims. (This class distinction was however eliminated by Sultan Abdülmecid I in 1856, whose reforms made all Ottoman subjects legally equal regardless of their religion. The Sultan, also the Caliph of Islam, in effect directly contradicted the Koran by freeing all non-Muslims from the Jizya poll-tax).

In contrast, Turkish Jews are an official minority and ostensibly have rights equal to any other citizen of Turkey.

Iskender, you will not find a single example of violence against Jews instigated by ethnic Turk in Ottoman history. It can be argued that all Jews were universally abused as second-class Dhimmis. However, relative to what Ashkenazi Jews had to endure in Europe and the abject humiliation Mizrahi Jews faced in Morocco and Iran, Sephardic Jews in the Ottoman Empire were tolerated and sometimes even prospered.

An example: The Ottoman city of Salonika (modern day Thessaloniki, Greece), was the only city outside of Israel in history that had a Jewish-majority population. This demographic was entirely a product of Ottoman migrations; Salonika did not have a substantial Jewish population before the Ottoman era, and after passing to the Greeks her Jews were erased from history. Salonikan Jews prospered in the classical Ottoman era (even though they were officially classified as Dhimmis). The ornate textiles of the Janissary corp., the elite division of the Ottoman Military, were exclusively woven by the Jews of Salonika. Their prosperity however gradually diminished in correlation with the disbandment of the Janissaries in 1826.

You abuse the term "Dhimmi" because Jews in fact were better tolerated in the Islamic Ottoman Empire than in the secular Republic of Turkey. It is painfully ironic.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (150) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1Nuclear Turkey? [215 words]AlexandrosJan 10, 2014 10:59212563
1always someone elses fault. [68 words]batya daganJun 29, 2012 10:19196820
The naivety sucks. [359 words]IamJosephJun 27, 2012 20:15196768
3Australian Situation [206 words]Garry LockwoodOct 20, 2011 19:19190211
Turks are redefining the legacy of the Ottomans [155 words]Mohammad Mansoor Ali AnsariOct 14, 2011 02:57190019
1New Definition of Ottoman Turkey Does Not Include Israel [244 words]M. ToveyOct 18, 2011 12:54190019
5Turkey going to Medieval way [226 words]Muslimk***Oct 26, 2011 04:02190019
3Turkish Leadership to New World Order [74 words]sephardiOct 12, 2011 18:47189995
correction [18 words]Ayla KosebeyOct 11, 2011 02:36189949
6Going Rogue! [21 words]trans-parereOct 7, 2011 20:07189907
11Turkish translation [17 words]Ayla KosebeyOct 6, 2011 03:01189870
15Dear Mr Tim Lock - ... [505 words]Sinbad the SailorOct 3, 2011 19:13189818
Thank you for the letter [304 words]Tim Lock (not e)Oct 4, 2011 14:05189818
JUST a reminder [56 words]Wlad The GreatJul 30, 2012 20:35189818
1Seeing Details [50 words]Jay1Oct 2, 2011 19:58189787
9Defying all the rules of law and risking war [272 words]Dan B.Sep 30, 2011 23:37189754
3Blind parrot talk par excellence [153 words]Tim LockOct 2, 2011 15:10189754
1Turkey's Intentions - Words or Deeds [29 words]M. ToveyOct 3, 2011 19:12189754
3Muslim "Waters" [42 words]Joe Six-PackOct 7, 2011 13:19189754
2yaşasın türkiye [254 words]havasSep 29, 2011 18:00189710
8Havas' comments on Turkey and Israel [237 words]PrashantOct 1, 2011 00:31189710
1Havas does represent the average Turkish people [217 words]Tim LockOct 2, 2011 15:26189710
2Long Life in Turkey Remains to be Seen [300 words]M. ToveyOct 4, 2011 19:14189710
Tim Lock: Your views are fantasies. [229 words]TurkcekonusanamerikaliOct 27, 2011 20:36189710
16PM of Turkey is a Person who deceived EU and USA [196 words]Hamma MirwaisiSep 29, 2011 11:12189697
6Prove that or Take back... [93 words]Tim LockSep 29, 2011 17:28189697
7Turkish Strike Kills Family In Iraqi Kurdistan [270 words]Hamma MirwaisiSep 29, 2011 20:03189697
2Turkish Hitler [79 words]BlackfeatherSep 30, 2011 11:32189697
2Thank you I wont buy Kurdish News Agency news based on PKK spokesman [36 words]Tim LockOct 2, 2011 15:34189697
1Hiter apologist [7 words]KerryOct 3, 2011 07:42189697
1Congratulations Tim [26 words]İdris SarıOct 4, 2011 21:37189697
your link is also groundless like your comment [101 words]İdris SarıOct 4, 2011 21:44189697
4I really like your posts [432 words]TurkcekonusanamerikaliOct 27, 2011 14:43189697
to türkçekonuşanamerikalı [591 words]havasOct 30, 2011 07:21189697
1Reply to Havas [124 words]Turckce konusanamerikaliNov 3, 2011 17:49189697
3Reply to Havas [416 words]Turckce konusanamerikaliNov 3, 2011 19:08189697
Sedat Ergin comment on Turkey's treat ment of its "brotherly" Kurds. [177 words]TurkcekonusanamerikaliNov 5, 2011 10:49189697
3Info on Jewish-Kurdish genetics from Wikipedia [337 words]TurkcekonusanamerikaliNov 5, 2011 11:09189697
Iran's Delusions. Are they Turkey's [203 words]TurkcekonusanamerikaliNov 10, 2011 15:20189697
Opportunity [6 words]CostasNov 14, 2011 14:54189697
4Me, Mr. Erdogan? [395 words]Tim LockSep 28, 2011 19:43189675
2What you do what you say [77 words]Taner MersinSep 29, 2011 01:44189675
4Erdogan and Psychoanalysis [42 words]Mark DSep 29, 2011 22:22189675
2... Tim [60 words]KerryOct 3, 2011 07:49189675
Just a partiel fact but I see most have no idea [33 words]Tim LockOct 4, 2011 14:08189675
1Tiresome Tim [31 words]KerryOct 4, 2011 19:06189675
1Mendatious Myopic Tim [4 words]KerryOct 8, 2011 09:41189675
2really? [71 words]Peter HallNov 9, 2011 01:53189675
8160,000 sq. mi. Muslim lake? [358 words]Art J.Sep 28, 2011 18:19189670
4Art J is right [176 words]PrashantSep 28, 2011 20:32189670
fear is the path to war [113 words]Selami ZorluSep 29, 2011 05:51189670
Prashant [10 words]KerryOct 3, 2011 07:53189670
6so Turks have bought new cars [354 words]Selami ZorluSep 28, 2011 18:11189669
2Power struggles [84 words]Rebecca MouldsSep 28, 2011 17:11189667
1An economic initiative to resolve most of the problems. [102 words]SamirSep 28, 2011 17:01189665
3A problem [121 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Jack KalpakianSep 28, 2011 09:56189647
1turks became muslims and then... [42 words]L. ManoharSep 28, 2011 07:22189641
2Plunder is not an available tool any more [161 words]PrashantSep 28, 2011 20:44189641
2Violent methods of Turkey? [48 words]Tim LockOct 2, 2011 16:40189641
2Hubris and revanchism is a poor basis for a foreign policy [208 words]jonSep 28, 2011 07:21189640
6What do you mean ROGUE? You mean Turkey is not dancing to every tune regardless how wrong the policies are? [218 words]MarkSep 28, 2011 02:41189632
1Your opinion has support at the highest level. [131 words]TurkcekonusanamerikaliNov 19, 2011 16:44189632
The major Issue is not Turkey as the Isreal the real problem. [197 words]Mohammed MirzaSep 28, 2011 01:55189631
Western capitalism is superior [16 words]KerrySep 29, 2011 18:21189631
3Orientalism [112 words]Tim LockSep 30, 2011 02:51189631
2Tim Locke [155 words]KerryOct 2, 2011 09:53189631
1Behind Time Tim [105 words]KerryOct 3, 2011 07:29189631
3Israel Does Have A Problem With the World Having a Problem With Israel [353 words]M. ToveyOct 7, 2011 13:54189631
3WHY ISRAEL NEED NOT CARE! [74 words]peter knopflerOct 11, 2011 23:28189631
Jealous Islam [129 words]Wlad The GreatJul 30, 2012 20:49189631
Wake up West Turkey plays you a chup [54 words]NuritGSep 27, 2011 23:09189629
1Don't agree [98 words]CemSep 27, 2011 22:20189628
1what about 9/11 [30 words]calebSep 27, 2011 21:32189626
Turkey is driving a wedge between America and Israel [73 words]Jon OzdamarSep 27, 2011 19:24189620
Israel is the only non Christian democratic state in the region [99 words]Costas KalotarisOct 22, 2011 01:42189620
Question for Dr Pipes [53 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Jay1Sep 27, 2011 18:42189618
oh dear [20 words]JJ BurkeSep 28, 2011 08:15189618
2Failure to respond to attacks of war against America embolden those described in this article. [107 words]Ralph C Whaley MDSep 27, 2011 17:12189617
7Much is needed before considering all-out war [99 words]Stephen BlantonSep 28, 2011 19:01189617
6... Unhelpful [179 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Tim LockSep 27, 2011 17:10189616
2exposing of the real rogue [76 words]mythSep 28, 2011 04:51189616
8Marmara etc [253 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanSep 28, 2011 18:51189616
4Oh really, how many Israeli soldiers are dead [101 words]Tim LockSep 28, 2011 20:06189616
7marmara 2 [298 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanSep 29, 2011 05:26189616
2Nonsense cannot be argued with [326 words]Tim LockSep 29, 2011 18:01189616
4simple question [204 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanSep 30, 2011 00:28189616
Facts basic and no more stupid discussion [387 words]Tim LockOct 2, 2011 15:50189616
5Agreed - we do want the facts [1936 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanOct 2, 2011 22:33189616
No title [238 words]Tim LockOct 4, 2011 14:58189616
... strikes again [7 words]KerryOct 4, 2011 19:08189616
4hindsight's great [490 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanOct 8, 2011 06:02189616
Your sources? [17 words]Amin RiazOct 16, 2011 21:47189616
3OMG you have a lot to learn Tim [469 words]Peter HallNov 10, 2011 02:32189616
3Tim, Have you ever watched a Television show?? [190 words]Peter HallNov 12, 2011 05:55189616
13Turkey has always been rogue [255 words]IskenderSep 27, 2011 16:15189614
9Brawl Breaks Out at U.N. between Security Staff & Turkish diplomats [314 words]Dan SchwartzSep 27, 2011 16:02189613
9How to use diplomatic immunity ? Throw a woman across the room in the UN ! [517 words]IanusSep 28, 2011 06:44189613
3The rationale for burqas [46 words]Paul S.Sep 29, 2011 18:53189613
16National Interests [18 words]Ayla KosebeySep 27, 2011 15:35189611
5Quranic dicta take precedence over infidels' dicta [134 words]IanusSep 28, 2011 09:57189611
18Laic Turkey [36 words]Ayla KosebeySep 30, 2011 16:45189611
9What is it? It has no freedom of thought and 99,8% Islamization rate and yet boasts of being "laic and democratic"?... The Turkish wonderland! [277 words]IanusOct 2, 2011 14:02189611
15bravery is a nice wisdom [158 words]Ayla KosebeyOct 4, 2011 03:44189611
13Aren't you implying the Turks fully justify their notoriety for crime and barbarism ? [1066 words]IanusOct 8, 2011 10:39189611
6I'm not surpised! [159 words]Jacob ThomasSep 27, 2011 14:56189610
2So southern Europe is falling-apart in either appeasement of non-workers, or a re-run of the Ottoman. Surprised? [523 words]Alex ScipioSep 27, 2011 14:14189608
1Don't forget the issue of water levels along the Euphrates [42 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Aymenn Jawad Al-TamimiSep 27, 2011 14:00189606
9Turkey made the wrong choice, just like Germany in the 1930s [125 words]Jayson RexSep 27, 2011 13:55189604
5Very true [115 words]AnnaSep 28, 2011 06:43189604
1Thats exactly why the murder is murder [117 words]Tim LockSep 29, 2011 12:00189604
3Turks and Europeans [123 words]Tim LockSep 29, 2011 12:06189604
7... denials and reality [2366 words]IanusSep 29, 2011 18:25189604
2Refute it yourself [77 words]AnnaSep 29, 2011 18:31189604
5A better idea [129 words]IanusSep 29, 2011 19:29189604
5Turkish law criminalizes the truth. [83 words]IanusSep 29, 2011 20:29189604
3tim lock [16 words]herbert smytheOct 1, 2011 11:36189604
2Organized Armenian propaganda machine-hungry of identity fed on victim psychology [480 words]Tim LockOct 2, 2011 16:16189604
6... forget the sources and keep accusing the opponent of your own crimes [280 words]IanusOct 3, 2011 08:40189604
10"Somebody else's filth" ;) [610 words]IanusOct 3, 2011 11:29189604
You have no answer [227 words]Tim LockOct 4, 2011 15:55189604
Still that old good orientalist filth [121 words]Tim LockOct 4, 2011 16:50189604
5"Deutschland und Armenien" 1919 vs. Turkish lies [248 words]IanusOct 6, 2011 16:56189604
6Oriental filth old and new [503 words]IanusOct 8, 2011 08:00189604
3too much hate [176 words]havasOct 10, 2011 11:12189604
12Two rogues -Mahomet and Ataturk [1333 words]IanusOct 11, 2011 17:56189604
4Beyond the statistics [352 words]TurkcekonusanamerikaliNov 2, 2011 19:50189604
4Erdogan Takes Turkey Into (Militant) Islam [206 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Ron ThompsonSep 27, 2011 13:46189603
1Turkish Anxieties [247 words]M. ToveySep 28, 2011 18:51189603
1Israel relying on the US [124 words]Mark D.Sep 29, 2011 22:34189603
Israel's Reliance on Defense Cannot be Focused on US [216 words]M. ToveyOct 3, 2011 12:10189603
3Show of Hands-Who is Really Surprised About Turkey [364 words]M. ToveySep 27, 2011 12:46189602
1Biblical catastrophy [87 words]Tim LockSep 29, 2011 12:13189602
1Biblical Catastrophe Indeed-But Whose Nuke? [216 words]M. ToveySep 29, 2011 18:37189602
3Turkey, a "Moslem Model" for the Arab Spring [43 words]LudvikusSep 27, 2011 12:46189601
2A Contrary Opinion [59 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Shel_TRSep 27, 2011 12:34189600
4Turkey did not help during the holocaust, it oppressed its non-Muslim citizens [129 words]IskenderSep 28, 2011 15:22189600
3An eyewitness [145 words]rkmSep 29, 2011 18:59189600
1Jews in the 1930s preferred Turkey over anti-Semitic Christian neighbors. [159 words]Jon OzdamarSep 30, 2011 20:24189600
4Jews of Eastern Thrace in Turkey were oppressed, expelled in the 1930s [123 words]IskenderOct 2, 2011 01:00189600
7Jews and their Turkish oppressors [455 words]IanusOct 2, 2011 14:46189600
5More than 9000 or more than 15 000 ? [41 words]IanusOct 2, 2011 19:36189600
4Correction [143 words]IskenderOct 2, 2011 21:10189600
1Ironically, Ottoman Jews were better tolerated than their Turkish successors [382 words]Jon OzdamarOct 3, 2011 09:38189600
5Jews were oppressed in the modern Turkish Republic [179 words]IskenderOct 4, 2011 00:06189600
8"Turkish secularism" is an insult to intelligence [188 words]IanusOct 4, 2011 14:30189600
5Let's listen to the Jews for a change [383 words]IanusOct 6, 2011 17:38189600
Bektashi Muslims were influenced by Jewish Kabbalism. [78 words]JonOct 6, 2011 18:35189600
8The story of 100 liars [662 words]IanusOct 8, 2011 07:29189600
6Where is Obama? [78 words]jdSep 27, 2011 11:41189599
2and because of that [66 words]AlanSep 28, 2011 12:55189599

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)