| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Islam is a new religion
Reader comment on item: Debating PBS's "Muhammad" Documentary
in response to reader comment: Islam is not a new religion
Submitted by Annonymous (United States), Apr 5, 2011 at 02:46
If Islam were the same religion practiced by the prophets, then the Hebrews would have the same mindset the Muslims have, and they clearly do not, and that is because they did not teach Islam to them.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (65) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quran says God told Jews "Whosoever saves..." [43 words] | Adnan Husain | Dec 6, 2005 17:00 | 29540 | ||
| the truth of media [31 words] | Raghdah | May 27, 2004 01:22 | 15376 | ||
| 5 | Read about Islam and discover the way [335 words] | Mohamed Mohamed | Jan 26, 2003 23:11 | 6001 | |
 question... [69 words] | nico | Nov 1, 2006 07:06 | 6001 | ||
| sure we are but... [102 words] | salman | Jun 19, 2007 13:47 | 6001 | ||
| islam [28 words] | saami | Aug 10, 2007 02:00 | 6001 | ||
| I can't believe how Muslims think Islam will be fair and just [295 words] | Gracian Muthu | Nov 4, 2013 13:29 | 6001 | ||
| what really does the U.S. approve and sponsor Mr. Pipes? [214 words] | Angel | Jan 5, 2003 10:52 | 5498 | ||
| More religious nonsense on PBS [365 words] | Mike McGlothlin | Dec 29, 2002 18:44 | 5291 | ||
| Daniel Pipes is not Islamophobic [239 words] | Gabriel Grosso | Dec 29, 2002 16:26 | 5290 | ||
| 1 | Islam is not a new religion [112 words] | M Amer | Dec 23, 2002 22:54 | 5105 | |
| Islam is the light for humanity [107 words] | Noor | Oct 11, 2008 01:10 | 5105 | ||
 Islam is a new religion [37 words] | Annonymous | Apr 5, 2011 02:46 | 5105 | ||
| 1 | PBS Interviews Karen Armstrong [156 words] | Susan | Dec 23, 2002 18:58 | 5099 | |
| Susan, are you qualified enough to make generalized comment? [89 words] | Kaf | Apr 1, 2006 21:44 | 5099 | ||
| PBS' Simona Foltyn propagates for Iran's Hezbolah terrorists in Iraq [71 words] | Bernarda | Dec 28, 2021 19:09 | 5099 | ||
| Publish or Perish for journalists [273 words] | Prashant | Dec 30, 2021 11:36 | 5099 | ||
| What the Muslims don't tell you [88 words] | Shlomo Walfish | Dec 23, 2002 16:30 | 5095 | ||
| Be OpenMinded and fair. [101 words] | Be OpenMinded | Nov 5, 2007 12:23 | 5095 | ||
| Quran is the word of God not Muslims. [136 words] | Darlienst | Aug 14, 2010 07:13 | 5095 | ||
| Answers to pertinent questions... [227 words] | A. Marku | Dec 23, 2002 14:35 | 5092 | ||
| Aya 2.178 of Quran [128 words] | Nazia K. | Dec 23, 2002 12:28 | 5089 | ||
| PBS "Muhammad " [552 words] | Narendra Kumar | Dec 23, 2002 00:22 | 5085 | ||
| Who's show is it? [166 words] | Boris Frenkel | Dec 22, 2002 16:11 | 5074 | ||
| Our show? [165 words] | Sue Sly | Jun 7, 2006 21:20 | 5074 | ||
| concentrate on more important battles [36 words] | Tammy Erann-Soussan | Dec 22, 2002 07:14 | 5060 | ||
| Islam is a Religion of Peace [58 words] | Husb Egroeg | Dec 22, 2002 02:36 | 5055 | ||
| islam is a guidance to the whole mankind [26 words] | laiba | Sep 11, 2011 13:21 | 5055 | ||
| What exactly is the wisdom that is not found else where [51 words] | Prashant | Sep 12, 2011 01:24 | 5055 | ||
| Aspartame Islam [307 words] | R. Robert Delfin | Dec 21, 2002 21:21 | 5047 | ||
| Quran and Islam are not compatable with US constitution. [157 words] | hari iyer | Dec 21, 2002 18:48 | 5044 | ||
| A democratic gov. is illegal per koran [172 words] | Steve | Nov 27, 2009 22:33 | 5044 | ||
| 2 | Islam's hidden agenda [142 words] | Derek | Dec 21, 2002 13:56 | 5037 | |
| Islam: Not a religion; seems to be law/policies made by gangster [50 words] | Professor | May 19, 2008 08:42 | 5037 | ||
| THE brainwashed west [392 words] | ALI | Nov 15, 2008 10:30 | 5037 | ||
| And we call Muslim world close minded and oppressive [311 words] | A Humble Muslim | Dec 21, 2002 02:15 | 5027 | ||
| Islam and its People [139 words] | Alan Titus | Dec 10, 2006 12:09 | 5027 | ||
| In response to Michael and David [162 words] | Asiadeh | Dec 20, 2002 22:05 | 5021 | ||
| For the sake of one's religion [118 words] | M. Levy | Dec 20, 2002 18:39 | 5015 | ||
| PBS is sending the wrong message [126 words] | John Harman | Dec 20, 2002 17:03 | 5010 | ||
| Comments on MSNBC Interview on PBS Mohammad Documentary [464 words] | Ruben G. Perlmutter | Dec 20, 2002 15:58 | 5005 | ||
| How to train for Dhimmitude. [187 words] | Kumar | Dec 20, 2002 15:11 | 5001 | ||
| Islam and Violence [75 words] | Alan Fine | Dec 20, 2002 15:00 | 5000 | ||
| Yes, please help us understand Mr. Pipes [147 words] | Deborah | Dec 20, 2002 12:50 | 4994 | ||
| Don't boast, show in your deeds [129 words] | Xavier Gracian | Aug 24, 2013 04:35 | 4994 | ||
| Did Prophet Stop Violence or Promote it? [155 words] | J. Khan | Dec 20, 2002 12:47 | 4993 | ||
| Why was this programme made. [732 words] | Graham Spence | Dec 20, 2002 11:13 | 4987 | ||
| PBS- Islam [272 words] | Carl | Dec 20, 2002 10:57 | 4985 | ||
| Why Islam is indulged? [334 words] | KIRAN | Dec 20, 2002 10:23 | 4982 | ||
| Excellent interview [126 words] | Phebe Intihar | Dec 20, 2002 08:21 | 4975 | ||
| 1 | Have this guy any sense of reasoning ? [473 words] | Hilare | Dec 20, 2002 05:24 | 4972 | |
| ISLAM IS NOT A NEW RELIGION [39 words] | Sani dahiru SDB# | Jan 10, 2013 05:21 | 4972 | ||
| First Loyalty To Islam [145 words] | Danny Bonca | Dec 20, 2002 04:30 | 4970 | ||
| Pertinent questions [127 words] | S.C. Panda | Dec 20, 2002 04:13 | 4968 | ||
| Beauty of Islam [101 words] | A.M. Berlin | Dec 20, 2002 01:48 | 4963 | ||
| Islam: Theory & Practice [112 words] | Dolce Farniente | Dec 20, 2002 00:33 | 4960 | ||
| Interview critique [73 words] | John H. Corn | Dec 20, 2002 00:15 | 4959 | ||
| Koran teaches that "He who saves one life..."? [83 words] | David | Dec 20, 2002 00:05 | 4958 | ||
| Truth vs. Fiction [98 words] | Marcia Peters | Dec 19, 2002 22:30 | 4953 | ||
| My feelings on Muhammad [45 words] | Annaliesa | Aug 2, 2006 08:05 | 4953 | ||
| Great job! [13 words] | Joel Steinke | Dec 19, 2002 22:05 | 4950 | ||
| Clumsy proselytizing propaganda [52 words] | Michael | Dec 19, 2002 21:12 | 4948 | ||
| Keep up the good fight [27 words] | Rev John Morris | Dec 19, 2002 21:03 | 4947 | ||
| The Religious Ignorance of the Masses [116 words] | Michoel Zeldis | Dec 19, 2002 20:15 | 4945 | ||
| About the PBS "Documentary" [216 words] | Diana Nielsen | Dec 19, 2002 19:28 | 4940 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2025 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)