69 million page views

Another incomprehensible US stroll into the Arab-Israeli minefield

Reader comment on item: Annapolis [Conference] Blues

Submitted by Charles Martel (United States), Oct 25, 2007 at 12:09

Of course the talks are stupid and won't go anywhere -- anyone can see that and it's not worth dissecting.

What I found interesting is Dr. Pipe's reasons for the latest "peace talks" goat rope. I have never understood why no US administration (right or left, competent or pathetic) can't resist trying to settle this.

These five are at least adequate explanations -- although only the second is even arguably a plausible US interest:

  • Iranian threat: Rice sees an opportunity for U.S. diplomacy in a Middle East re-alignment resulting from Iranian aggression, both actual (Hizbullah, Hamas) and future (nuclear weapons).
  • Inaction worse: If nothing is done, Kadima's already dismal standing in the polls will continue to fall and Fatah's tenuous hold over the West Bank will erode. The prospect of Likud and Hamas succeeding Olmert and Abbas pleases the Bush administration no more than it does those two men.
  • Legacy: Zbigniew Brzezinski has articulated the foreign policy establishment's hopes for Annapolis and its dim view of Rice: "She realizes that her legacy right now is really very poor. If she can pull this off, she will be seen as a real historical figure."
  • Civil rights: Rice believes in a bizarre analogy between West Bank Palestinians and southern Blacks.
  • Messianism: Both George W. Bush and Rice seem to view themselves as destined to resolve Arab-Israeli hostilities. One interlocutor recounts that "she believes this is the time for the Israeli and Palestinian conflict to end."
  • Submitting....

    Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

    Submit a comment on this item

    << Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

    Reader comments (69) on this item

    Title Commenter Date Thread
    Madness run amok in the name of "Legacy"? [53 words]JoshueJan 14, 2008 21:09118208
    Kiss my Camel's Kaboose [229 words]Ed AdamsDec 4, 2007 07:50115697
    It looks Like Olmert Finally Found Some Spine [78 words]Seamus MacNemiNov 30, 2007 02:16115396
    Another failed meeting [77 words]Henry DavisNov 7, 2007 04:43113291
    Pipes apprehensions from Annapolis are perfectly understandable! (#115031) [11 words]omar ibrahim bakerOct 31, 2007 10:37112728
    U.S.-Israel relations hanging by a thread? [166 words]Michael BakerOct 29, 2007 19:52112603
    The road to hell… [1444 words]Johnny S.Oct 28, 2007 00:52112478
    Road to Hell Not Paved, But Very Wide - Look to Holy Bible For Right Path to Streets of Gold [389 words]M. ToveyOct 29, 2007 18:51112478
    Good on you, Johnny! [142 words]Charles MartelOct 30, 2007 12:52112478
    1444 Words On the Road to Hell [219 words]EdAdamsDec 4, 2007 09:03112478
    Road to hell [118 words]Larry B.Jan 16, 2008 11:29112478
    Road map to destruction [584 words]shaynaOct 27, 2007 15:10112438
    Annapolis the Precursor to the Following Consequences [363 words]M. ToveyOct 27, 2007 22:38112438
    May God bless Daniel Pipes ! [60 words]A.M.DelcambreOct 27, 2007 09:19112430
    The Beginning of Israel's Demise (and U.S. retreat) [295 words]Bryan TaplitsOct 26, 2007 16:19112400
    analogies [362 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDOct 27, 2007 16:36112400
    Bush Administration Incompetence [85 words]KatteyNov 2, 2007 13:04112400
    The "Pipe" line to Better Understanding. [368 words]EdAdamsDec 6, 2007 08:56112400
    West Vs Muslim world [262 words]Syed KasimOct 26, 2007 15:25112395
    Syed Vs western world [496 words]JeffOct 27, 2007 18:02112395
    Muslim world versus the West [275 words]InfidelOct 28, 2007 14:23112395
    reply to Syed Kasim [605 words]shaynaOct 28, 2007 20:02112395
    Who is more at fault, the East or the West? [153 words]KatteyNov 2, 2007 13:25112395
    who is on first who is on second [50 words]GrunchlikDec 4, 2009 20:55112395
    I care. [27 words]KatteyDec 6, 2009 22:34112395
    Petition To Stop The Misguided Mideast Peace Conference [92 words]YnnatchkahOct 26, 2007 14:31112392
    wow [47 words]AgamemnonOct 28, 2007 12:59112392
    Agamemnon "logic". [128 words]YnnatchkahOct 28, 2007 20:25112392
    Imagine Churchill saying this: We shall switch your electricity off for 15 min [151 words]Mladen AndrijasevicOct 26, 2007 11:04112385
    Here we go again [254 words]Rebecca MouldsOct 25, 2007 23:36112353
    ONLY SOLUTION: GAZA UNDER EGYPT; PARTS OF WEST BANK LINKED TO JORDAN [154 words]G. MarcusOct 25, 2007 23:16112352
    Been there done that. [156 words]Joe KaffirOct 27, 2007 16:32112352
    Annapolis Must Not Succeed [241 words]ralphsrant1Oct 25, 2007 21:25112347
    Annapolis Blues [6 words]VirginiaOct 25, 2007 21:09112346
    Palestinians [191 words]jennifer solisOct 25, 2007 15:04112335
    What Annapolis Really Means - Not to Just the 'Palestinians' [523 words]M. ToveyOct 26, 2007 01:22112335
    Show of good faith. [186 words]KatteyNov 2, 2007 12:52112335
    No land should be given to Palestinians!!! [390 words]jennifer solisNov 3, 2007 15:45112335
    Palestinian State Train [138 words]IsraelOct 25, 2007 14:54112334
    Rice & co [236 words]Peter simpsonOct 25, 2007 14:47112333
    Last Chance for a Bush/Rice Legacy [172 words]Richard RheinerOct 25, 2007 13:05112329
    Another incomprehensible US stroll into the Arab-Israeli minefield [243 words]Charles MartelOct 25, 2007 12:09112326
    Two Faces [449 words]John R. PeacherOct 25, 2007 10:04112323
    If not now - when? [205 words]K.H. AhmedOct 25, 2007 09:34112321
    The arrogance of carelessness [99 words]David W. LincolnOct 25, 2007 09:18112320
    Let's not be too pessimistic [277 words]Ken BesigOct 25, 2007 08:53112319
    Winning the War First [337 words]Harvey UKOct 26, 2007 18:03112319
    bottom line [103 words]robert aOct 25, 2007 01:11112303
    the sound you heard was the nail getting hit on the head [12 words]TajOct 26, 2007 02:57112303
    Israel Trapped. Condi- a Pianist. Muslims Play Chess. [165 words]YnnatchkahOct 25, 2007 00:14112300
    Columbia Tenure Case [50 words]KCOct 24, 2007 23:58112298
    Why Rice & Bush are pushing conference [445 words]Arthur CohnOct 24, 2007 22:40112295
    Annapolis Blues [200 words]Dannel R. BallesterosOct 24, 2007 22:23112292
    INSANITY OF TRYING TO MAKE PEACE WITH SWORN ENEMIES [456 words]MORDECAI BEN HAIMOct 24, 2007 21:19112288
    INSANITY OF TRYING TO MAKE PEACE WITH SWORN ENEMIES [198 words]CherNov 26, 2007 20:25112288
    Annapolis: Peace at what cost? [218 words]robert fusfeldOct 24, 2007 19:55112282
    Once again, Daniel is right [156 words]MohOct 24, 2007 19:14112278
    "In God We Trust". Why Americans can not be trusted [103 words]Boris CelserOct 24, 2007 19:05112277
    No disrespect toward Dr. Pipes is intended. Mr. Bush is an utter and complete failure. [215 words]SteveOct 24, 2007 19:04112276
    Bush as a "Unitificator with Results" [362 words]Charles MartelOct 26, 2007 11:18112276
    Charles Martel: I'm sorry I did not make myself clear [156 words]Steve KleinOct 26, 2007 17:34112276
    Although Steve not a Moslem after all, the point stands [85 words]Charles MartelOct 29, 2007 13:09112276
    Charles, you are a Christian; I am a Jew. I believe our priorities are different [168 words]Steve KleinOct 30, 2007 10:28112276
    I don't agree with your eschatology, and I don't have a blog -- it must have been the work of an IMPOSTER! [71 words]Charles MartelJan 13, 2009 14:46112276
    Peace [102 words]Donald W. BalesOct 24, 2007 18:12112269
    Example... [97 words]donvanOct 25, 2007 12:50112269
    Fake "Palestinians" - Fake victims [482 words]AlJan 28, 2008 20:44112269
    Where angels fear to tread.... [58 words]VijayOct 24, 2007 18:02112268
    Arab/Israeli negotiations [244 words]AyashaOct 24, 2007 21:03112268

    Follow Daniel Pipes

    Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

    All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

    Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

    (The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

    Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

    For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)