69 million page views

ISLAM AND 11/9 ATTACK- Contradictions.

Reader comment on item: Did Michael Jackson Convert to Islam?
in response to reader comment: Reverted....

Submitted by haJra hAdi (India), Sep 26, 2007 at 03:38

Assalamaikum wrwb(Peace)all,

Your Right Mr.Donvan. We MUSLIMS very much believe that we have access to "Special Knowledge" ..SOURCE?our HOLY QURAN :) Which i can proudly state -In fact HOLY QURAN revealed atleast 1400 years back is the ONLY Most Accurate Holy scripture which when looked at in the light of Todays ESTABLISHED-Scientific Facts..not Theories (which are supposedly presumptions and analysis based) is the most accurate Book...also with a civilized way of life being prescribed not Barbaric as u would call it...."Doubts"? you may go your investigation sites..whatever sources you got :) and best if you read it self...and know;althought a Translation is a human handy work which is subject to few basic errors of language or interpretation.

-->[Ref:THE HOLY QURAN,Text,Translation and Commentary by Abdallah yousuf Ali-New revised Edition,Published by Amana Corporation]

Ok,..Whats funny is the way you say Muslims all over are probabyly faced by profound personality disorder with suicidal ideation..at the same time you talk about muslims being ruled by superiority complex...No match!

Non-muslims know others by their actions? i can actually claim its vice-versa..cause while i see many muslims keepin in mind the general thinking of others ,they actually make sure that they don't be prejudiced about others-yea not all muslims,but "IS IT LEGITIMATE TO COUNT ON FEW IRRESPONSIBLE MUSLIMS AS -'ALL' OR A SYMBOLIC OF ISLAM AS A WHOLE?"

>>>KINDLY don't ignore :-
MUSLIMS DON'T CONSTITUTE ISLAM ..IT'S ISLAM THAT CONSTITUTES MUSLIMS!so that as a whole comes to the "Practicing and non-Practicing Muslims "part , which classification actually exists in any community be it Jews,Cristians ,Zoroastrains,Jains or whoever..Right?
Alas!..today muslims are universally "classified as criminals" ,now Look at the way non-muslims look at muslims?already following the Notion" oh thats a muslim-an opportunist ,fundamentalist,terrorist..etc etc etc" .And Muslims are not randomly blaming others on the grounds of responsibilty...as they very well know they are accountable for their individual-actions as they beleve in the day of resurrection is certain.

Its appreciable though the way you put forth your thoughts Mr.donvan.... your ability to scribble down your beliefs n thinking is appreciated..it would be much more interesting only if it didn't lack the whole "making sense" part(expected of you)..if u go about picking one or two irrelevant things for arguements sake..more of the most -vague reasonings i have come across to jump to ur 'so not Intellectual' conclusions,makes it harder for a sensible person to respond ..but i can .. as,i DONT STILL doubt My ability to make sense enough .ALthough they say."its useless to argue with fools",yet I believe in TRYING ,thats why i gave u the right source Holy Quran...so that u read ..if not to believe but to GET SOME DATA based on which u can claim the RELIGION Islam on the whole to be wrong(Nauzbillah!) >>iff u can Actually say so,that is.

For the muslims who cause destruction, lets face it man!.. you really think its Osama Bin Laden or any Muslim-Organisation's involvement in the 11/9(the twin tower attacks)?!?...IF you say that was done by planes.

Let's try to figure it out-Like we know, the time the building took to collapse was about 9 seconds...if you count the time and make some calculations you'll find out it's the free fall time for an object of that weight and more over just before the collapse , small explosions were spotted and an engineering professor said that the heat emitted by the plane can't do that to the body of the building .

Also note that -the falling was "horizontal"(Ok all the engineering students can have a laugh :)) then compare it with other destructions of the buildings those which are made by the engineers to demolish a building,You will get shocked !It being a horizontal fall-took the free fall time ,meaning there was no resistance .so either the floors beneath it was already destroyed before the plane touched it-so it made no resistance,Or ,the falling mass-part was SO heavy which is excluded cause, even a body of a high mass must gain high speed to destroy what i have said earlier.

FOR GODSAKE ! ...i thought all knew it by now -THE "WHO"did it...no? Then why don't you ask your very own-Saviour-Respected-president of - US of A -Mr. Bush ...lets hope he whispers it in your ear (secret apologies)>>Laughs<<. well ,many masterminds..and then just imagine a world power nation unable to do anythng while Osama hijacked 2 planes..if one was not enough.

And even if that makes sense to someone -Howcome One plane having attacked already..with a good-gap of about half an hour theres another plane and US with all its Special Armed-forces coudn't do anythng? ..Hmm ...makes less sense? maybe its a nice story for babies lullabyes or fools who prefer staying in dark and blindly bowing to medias presentation of facts.Big nO nO for Me.

Even intelligence -personnel themselves stated it is an "inside job" post investigation. okay if that's not it...there were articles on- how a man called his mother narrating that the planes been hijacked whats interesting is he mentions his surname to talk to his own mom? eh..as if she woudn't identify (thought only fathers identification is hard in THE west) ..was that out of panic? then how about while efforts are still on to make the cell phones work from that height of a plane, this guy calls up his mother and has a CLEAR conversation (in year 2001 itself??...wow!miracles still happen?) or you mean he had some Special cellphone?:) ..think about it.

Lots of references can be given if we go on about the whole "11th september thing" finally what remains? Grim faces with horryfying memories and xperiences...stil tryin to overcome the losses(personal..financial n..all sorts)?Friend you and i put together can't reason out the Loss that took place, as our false/valid accusitions are of no use For those effected by the whole distruction...since, some wounds even time cannot heal.

SO its for us all (Irrespective of whether a muslim ,christian,jew,..whoever) to take heed from and realise Mere accusing each other with "YOU DID THIS AND YOU WRONG, I DID THAT" kinda attitude won't lead us nowhere..Lets at least go by the principle of -Live And Let Live..Keeping intact all will believe what they follow to be right.My Efforts are only to get rid of the vague,irrelevant,unfair and baseless accusitions grouping against Islam/muslims.

<>If the observer of a fast does not give up false utterances and their pursuit,then God does not require him to give up his food and water(Souce-Sahih Al Bukhari)

Ref:200 Hadith (selection from Al Bukhari,Muslim,Tirmidhi,Abu Dawood,Ibn Maja,etc),

>>Accusations within the lines of decency are most welcomed.MAY Allah SWT/God guide us aright...removing the veils of darkness from our eyes and the seal of ignorance set on our hearts-Amen

peacE :)

p.s. Delay in responce is due to my being caught up with the holy month of Ramadan which is apologised for.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to ISLAM AND 11/9 ATTACK- Contradictions. by haJra hAdi

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2021 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)