69 million page views

Reaction to cuma

Reader comment on item: The Alawi Capture of Power in Syria
in response to reader comment: Natures Children

Submitted by Treize (Netherlands), Sep 6, 2013 at 11:40

Dear cuma,

It is interesting to hear your opinion. It is always good to have self-reflection.

From your post I get the impression that 1.) you are a women and 2.) you are not very much an Alawi/Nusayri anymore?

It must be difficult for a women to be a member of a community that keeps many things hidden from women. And the reasons for this seem quite dark indeed. The Alawi position towards women is a little bizarre if you ask me even though there are multiple versions of you true beliefs regarding women and some are not that bleak, but some are very bleak indeed. I know one Alawi women and she is very happy with her religion. I find it incredibly difficult to understand how a women can be such a proud member of a community that hides its inner teachings from them. And the reason for that seems to be the very bizarre view of women that this religion has, as opposed to the idea that women cannot keep secrets (this seems to be the standard explaination men give to women and outsiders).

As for you origins. I disagree, the Nusayris are not the descendants of pagans! They are Twelver 'ghulats'. The man called Muhammed ibn Nusayr was a mystic who claimed to be the 'bab' of imam al-Askari and later his teachings were developed into a religion by a man called Al-Khasibi who genuinely believed he was only pratisng the real Shi'ism. Later his successor called Al-Tabarani developed much more rituals, mainly because the sect started to grow a lot when the coastal population of Syria started to convert on a large scale (indeed, you do not allow any converts today, this is just contradicting, even the great Al-Tabarani was a convert and the founder Al-Khasibi was originally an Imami). So all in all your origins lie in Iraq and the sect spread to the Syria coast were it survived.

As for the rather 'interesting' cosmology that involves an original sin commited by the creatures of light, and the distincion between two types of humans (the enlightened who used to be these creatures of light and the other doomed ones) this seems to come from a pre-Nusayri ghulat mystic called Al-Muffadal. His works were later canonised by Al-Khasibi, your founding father, and he himself was made to be the 'bab' of the sixth imam in Nusayri religion.

The Alawi religion in essence is a gnostic religion just like Isma'ilism and its Druze offshoot. Now these esoteric, gnostic stuff is as old as monotheist religion. In the 300 years after the life of Jesus there were lots and lots of gnostic sect with beliefs quite similar to your sect. Also Neoplatonism was quite big in this time period. Also the Jews had their mystic cabbalism.

It is just that the Christian gnosticism was very undogmatic, reincarnation was endless and one would always become a human again, and even though only a very small number of people could free themselves of the material world there was no concept of predestination, there was also no anti-feminism, there was no End of Times and their was a big role for an evil creator God AKA the demiuge. Later Valentinianism introduces an end of times were the followers of the evil god would go to his imperfect heaven, the unbelievers would be burned with the rest of the material world and the small numbers of gnostics would be freed and be reunited with the true God. But Islamic gnosis seems to have left out the demiuge figure, instead everything is the plan of the one God and they also have introduced lots of dogma's and rituals (as an Alawi you will know this). Now one even needs guidance of a Shayk even though gnostism originally was a very individualist religion. Basically Nusayrism seems to me like an institutionalised, dogmatic form of gnosticism in an Islamic veil and with a typical closedness (which was probably more a result of persecution rather than a real choice).

I would like to talk more about this if you would be so kind. Please respond by e-mail, as this website is a bit difficult for this purpose:

Treize-Info@mail.com

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (150) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
2Religion [100 words]Skip ClarkMay 23, 2016 08:45229607
Your Excellent Analysis of the History of Alawi Syria [331 words]RobertDec 8, 2016 14:36229607
1Opposing Assad in Syria is a Cover for Opposing the Alawite - a Big Mistake [323 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertApr 6, 2016 13:33228738
2Obama is Wrong, Putin is Right, on Syria & Bashar al-Assad [195 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
RobertApr 4, 2016 13:33228709
Book? [15 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
IsabellaApr 1, 2016 11:47228664
As a matter of curiosity [14 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Kepha HorJan 23, 2016 20:27227791
2In the history of Humanity, 40 years of rule is NOTHING [135 words]KenshiroDec 16, 2013 04:08212180
thank you for this [6 words]malerie haskinsOct 22, 2013 15:23210884
5Modern Levant [145 words]caferAug 25, 2013 01:14209200
Hello [87 words]TreizeAug 31, 2013 11:33209200
Modern Levant [148 words]caferSep 2, 2013 02:51209200
Hello [237 words]TreizeSep 3, 2013 11:06209200
sorry buy i had to laugh [56 words]saraSep 3, 2013 20:25209200
1Natures Children [144 words]cumaSep 4, 2013 01:53209200
Religious violence. [438 words]TreizeSep 4, 2013 15:59209200
Reaction to cuma [702 words]TreizeSep 6, 2013 11:40209200
1Another victim of Arabian imperialism [346 words]dhimmi no moreSep 7, 2013 19:03209200
1It is ahl al-Nur and not the Pakistani ahl e nur [139 words]dhimmi no moreSep 8, 2013 07:22209200
Alawi or not to be [348 words]CumaSep 8, 2013 23:34209200
Reaction to dhimmi no more [262 words]TreizeSep 10, 2013 20:56209200
3Victims of Arabian imperialism revisited [231 words]dhimmi no moreSep 11, 2013 08:31209200
1In memory of the victims of the 9/11 atrocity and Ambassador Chris Stevens pay they rest in peace [409 words]dhimmi no moreSep 11, 2013 17:36209200
Dhimmi no more [138 words]TreizeSep 13, 2013 07:51209200
4Exposing lies and fabrications and ignorance [672 words]dhimmi no moreSep 13, 2013 18:31209200
1Dhimmi [13 words]TreizeSep 14, 2013 06:41209200
1Gnosis and Greek logic in late antiquity [642 words]dhimmi no moreSep 15, 2013 11:14209200
diverse culture [265 words]eugene quityJan 3, 2014 22:29209200
acceptance and unity [210 words]eugeneJan 3, 2014 22:44209200
A few questions for Alawi's regarding your beliefs. [296 words]NL321Aug 11, 2013 17:10208934
Check Daniel Pipes" Book [44 words]tonyAug 4, 2013 04:43208749
Good article [69 words]ZeinJul 10, 2013 09:01208059
6Assad sets a bleak futture for alawites [69 words]TonyDec 21, 2012 00:14201644
syira [59 words]mikAug 10, 2013 11:59201644
Analysis [42 words]George thomsonOct 4, 2012 09:42199483
3Alawi regime should be preseved. [104 words]JITENDRANov 23, 2012 03:23199483
1persecution drives them to hunger of power [254 words]eugene quityJan 3, 2014 22:09199483
Some nice analysis on Alawi sect [2 words]StanleyJul 21, 2012 03:45197343
Alawite [32 words]AlbertE.Jun 9, 2012 00:13196159
1and [11 words]shbhjk sdhjsaApr 5, 2012 20:11194997
2again me(obsessive: [509 words]shbhjk sdhjsaMay 2, 2012 20:42194997
Still in the Dark [36 words]andrew galeaSep 7, 2012 04:24194997
We need to contact!!! [55 words]UnkownFeb 9, 2013 10:57194997
DR PIPES POINT OF VIEW IS VERY TRUE INDEED [59 words]IMAD NAHASMar 19, 2012 00:13194504
2Organized and Dedicated Taqia [56 words]OmarMar 3, 2012 12:45193839
2so what ? [543 words]shbhjk sdhjsaMay 7, 2012 20:37193839
l try hard [8 words]mikAug 9, 2013 11:47193839
1continuation of Bani Israel [99 words]M. IrfanSep 2, 2013 13:12193839
2Another victim of Arabian imperialism [87 words]dhimmi no moreSep 5, 2013 15:41193839
No Offence to anyone ... [110 words]M IrfanSep 6, 2013 13:46193839
No your comment was not an "Academic one" [127 words]dhimmi no moreSep 8, 2013 07:12193839
Very aggressive [6 words]M IrfanSep 11, 2013 08:54193839
He is back and I wonder why! [142 words]dhimmi no moreSep 13, 2013 06:19193839
still taking comments ? [12 words]Carl LoeberFeb 20, 2012 23:10193523
7Asad and the Jews [36 words]y Brandstetter MDApr 1, 2011 04:56183788
Assad and the Jews [124 words]foxtrotNov 17, 2012 12:19183788
3alaouii of morocco are they alawi??? [34 words]fatima el marzoukiMar 27, 2011 20:54183652
1Alawi of Morocco [25 words]Abu YoussefJun 13, 2012 05:59183652
21re facts on alawis [94 words]alawi beautyAug 22, 2010 09:01177091
7Alawi [91 words]SusieJan 18, 2011 03:00177091
3Alawi [15 words]MohammedMay 15, 2011 03:49177091
4Facts on Alawis [79 words]Mohamed BhallooSep 3, 2011 23:14177091
3we are the only religion that respects all mankind? [176 words]kimbaAug 6, 2012 08:37177091
run away [31 words]Badra SidSep 24, 2012 23:51177091
1You are wrong alawi beauty [110 words]TonyAug 4, 2013 04:21177091
you are right Kimba [29 words]tonyAug 4, 2013 04:30177091
love [24 words]mikAug 9, 2013 11:24177091
Alevi or Alawi? [339 words]NL321Aug 22, 2013 15:17177091
11Not correct [243 words]AliAug 14, 2010 13:48176695
The Furure of Alawite Control in Syria [62 words]Wildbill46Mar 27, 2011 08:52176695
reference [11 words]abo aliApr 28, 2011 17:00176695
2Islamic drivel [54 words]dhimmi no moreApr 28, 2011 19:27176695
gem [49 words]mikAug 10, 2013 21:04176695
7Confirmation is more valuable than speculation [186 words]The TruthMay 9, 2010 21:41172480
8this is all a load of rubbish! [254 words]unknownMar 7, 2010 08:56169801
4Christmas [89 words]SusieJan 18, 2011 03:16169801
4Ba Alawi [47 words]Mirhaniya MowlanaJul 8, 2009 03:32158596
1The french gave you the name of alawis to make you feel close to sunnis .... [44 words]Badra SidSep 25, 2012 00:00158596
So true [2 words]KenshiroDec 16, 2013 03:55158596
This is not about Ba Alawi [12 words]SamiJun 16, 2017 14:48158596
14an alawi girl [82 words]laraJun 18, 2009 07:15157573
3Well said [26 words]TurabAug 25, 2009 14:44157573
4Alawites and proud to be! [63 words]Freedom to AlawiteApr 8, 2011 12:40157573
pride [47 words]AmineAug 5, 2012 03:21157573
440 years - civilization of crimes against humanity [105 words]AmineAug 5, 2012 03:38157573
You are so right ! [112 words]KenshiroDec 16, 2013 04:02157573
Wrong [6 words]Zena El MApr 21, 2014 11:26157573
so sad story [76 words]MagdiMar 11, 2009 15:17152106
false [61 words]mcoMay 27, 2008 15:23130209
5What Alawites did to Syria and Lebanon [92 words]LebaneseFeb 17, 2008 17:03120419
6Aalawi [92 words]MarwaApr 1, 2009 00:34120419
2in the same hole [238 words]levantenMay 12, 2010 07:55120419
3what alawites did to syrian & Labanon [152 words]Mohamed BhallooSep 5, 2011 02:53120419
1The problem is closed mindednes along with closed heartedness! [232 words]A so-called Alawi in reality a member of Ahlul-BaytDec 24, 2012 17:16120419
1yes [2 words]mikAug 10, 2013 21:12120419
They do not go to hiding [35 words]M. IrfanSep 2, 2013 13:29120419
Excellent, besides my personal skepticism. [77 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
GodotApr 10, 2007 12:0388964
very interesting article [12 words]TaghridFeb 23, 2007 15:0178535
6wake up! [189 words]bFeb 12, 2007 12:4376912
9in reply to wake up ppl [194 words]in replyAug 3, 2009 16:5876912
Thank you! [26 words]RoseJul 2, 2012 21:4376912
1Alawis of Syria and the Vlachs of Greece [141 words]MatousisOct 30, 2006 05:0064797
1The Vlachs of Greece [124 words]George MaraMar 11, 2007 20:4864797
2Almost correct information [203 words]RagnarokMay 5, 2009 17:4764797
3the Truth [123 words]tarekSep 16, 2006 09:1756152
7good alawi [109 words]alawiMay 7, 2006 20:1044998
1Good..but! [113 words]Omar Haj IbrahimJun 24, 2006 09:4944998
18A Real Alawi [388 words]RayRayNov 24, 2005 22:4528821
2Well said [22 words]TinaSep 12, 2007 23:5128821
3i strongly agree [104 words]Very much AlawiMay 4, 2008 17:0028821
1rayray like a ray of light into my research [26 words]alawi gurlJul 5, 2008 07:0128821
23Alawi Beliefs [165 words]kim from AustraliaAug 24, 2008 20:3828821
1DONT DO IT!!! [57 words]lebanese MUSLIM!Sep 17, 2009 15:0928821
9how uneducated [149 words]blessedJan 5, 2010 21:0428821
2Allah knows it better [116 words]Proud AlawiJan 31, 2010 14:5328821
1Alawites-Arevitner-Shamsiyun, Shams it means in armenian Arev-------it is sun in English [16 words]GrigorFeb 2, 2010 13:3228821
2ALAWI PRIDE [17 words]Proud alawi girlApr 12, 2010 23:2828821
3Confused about Alawis! What exactly is their religion? My research [785 words]Andrew Jeffrey UkAug 20, 2010 16:2928821
4JUST A LITTLE RESPECT [337 words]BellaSep 4, 2010 03:3328821
5alawite means freedom tolerance and quality [19 words]kamalSep 15, 2010 08:5328821
1same [93 words]SAJan 18, 2011 03:0728821
1Open [31 words]SAJan 18, 2011 03:0928821
If the Alawi fall what will become of Syria? [52 words]Seamus Dafydd Dives MacNemiApr 10, 2011 00:1728821
5If Alawis are so peaceful [62 words]MikeJun 18, 2011 15:4028821
peace in syria [271 words]JusticeApr 1, 2012 21:2128821
1respect [15 words]respect2Apr 11, 2012 14:0528821
Power and Syria [100 words]simonsonJul 19, 2012 21:4228821
alawis morrocco and syria [44 words]AmineAug 5, 2012 03:1428821
2convert to Islam and not to a sect [21 words]AmineAug 5, 2012 03:4628821
alawite freedom tolerance and quality [16 words]AmineAug 5, 2012 03:5828821
caves [11 words]AmineAug 5, 2012 04:0428821
Alawis do not believe women are lower grade [317 words]JoeAug 28, 2012 11:0928821
Alawi in Morroco [31 words]andrew galeaSep 1, 2012 06:2628821
morocco [32 words]Abu YoussefSep 2, 2012 00:3228821
Alawis [21 words]andrew galeaSep 4, 2012 04:0928821
3Nusairis NOT Alawis [106 words]Abu YouusefSep 6, 2012 05:3528821
Alawi, My research [91 words]Andrew JeffreySep 24, 2012 11:2528821
Thank You Joe for explaining [45 words]Andrew JeffreySep 24, 2012 11:2728821
Correction, It's in Prophet Muhammad Ahadis, Mother has three times rights than Father [24 words]Andrew Jeffrey UKSep 24, 2012 11:3228821
2call them nusairi NOT alawi [44 words]Badra SidSep 24, 2012 23:4428821
You are totally wrong. [106 words]SejanDec 27, 2012 01:0928821
3The good bad and ugly [137 words]A human beingJan 13, 2013 09:5528821
Just Ask directly to your husband. [33 words]SKKFeb 4, 2015 06:4428821
origin myths [205 words]Prof. H----Oct 12, 2015 13:0228821
Alawites [138 words]DefneAug 19, 2016 13:3228821
You know nothing about Alawites [175 words]A REAL ALAWITE MAN WHO LOVE 124,000 PROPHETSSep 4, 2016 15:5428821
3Purdah of Alawi Women Vs Muslim Purdah [171 words]Allison KnightSep 4, 2005 23:3925485
Ayad Alawi's role as PM [35 words]Kent FrazierDec 7, 2004 00:3818887
Insightful useful research [13 words]Robin WilsonJan 28, 2003 07:476031
Well-documented, valuable [49 words]Gerald D. SackJan 14, 2003 01:205706
3Excellent Article [42 words]NebilSep 16, 2002 21:302489

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)