69 million page views

9 out of > 4,000 isn't many.

Reader comment on item: The Guantánamo Arrests – What Do They Mean?

Submitted by Peter J. Herz (Taiwan), Oct 2, 2003 at 10:21

While I'm usually in Dr. Pipes' cheering section, I think we probably can afford to be a bit "politically correct" about the common run of Muslims in America, including in government and the military. The Taliban state notwithstanding, not one of the people involved in the 9/11 attacks was of Afghan origins--and we have Afghan-origin people here, including some with mujaheddin experience. Despite the violence that flares up in western China and Eastern Turkistan from time to time, I don't see many Uighur or Hui residents of the US (yes, even they are here) being picked up as terrorist suspects.

We didn't need official anti-Semitism or heightened scrutiny of Jews to bust Jonathan Pollard for spying for Israel. Time was when the American Communist Party had disproportionately large Eastern European Jewish, Finnish, and West Indian memberships. Yet the American Communists were marginalized and contained readily enough without an official anti-Semitism or calls to send a few hundred thousand people back to the Karelian Isthmus or the Caribbean Islands. After all, the bulk of people of Eastern European Jewish, Finnish, or West Indian heritage in the country were not even close to being Communists.

I notice John Muhammad and a handful of other Muslims with US military experience turned out bad. But John Muhammad, like H. Rap Brown (I forget what he calls himself now), was probably attracted to Islam because he started out as America's own disaffected native son. James Yusuf Yee seems to be a case similar to John Walker LIndh, although probably a more intelligent man. But such are a far cry from the run of the mill South Asian and Mideastern immigrants for whom the USA is, as it was for people of other ethnicities and creeds before them, a chance for a new life. It seems that those bad guys in Buffalo got caught because others of Muslim Yemeni heritage were shocked and contacted the authorities (as any other law-abiding American or immigrant American wannabe would do). I suspect that the people who called the authorities are more representative of Muslim immigrants and their offspring than the would-be bombers.

Dr. Pipes himself notes that most Turkish-American and American Shi'ite associations seem to keep their distance from the crazies. And, I suspect, that some of the Afghan-origin people living here, who have so far have notiicably failed to stick up for the Taliban, may themselves have mujaheedin experience.

As a Christian, I cannot believe Muhammad was a prophet, or that Muslims are anything but theologically mistaken. But Muslims, like the rest of us, should be treated as innocent until proven guilty.
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (52) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
From Immigrant To US Marine [27 words]Lt. Col. Dominik George Nargele USMC (Ret) ( Author)Sep 6, 2005 00:3625505
Swimming in half truths [34 words]MArco MachiavelliJan 24, 2004 17:5513523
Why God in the military? [263 words]Travis WorkmanNov 16, 2003 23:5912201
The Guantanamo Arrests, Oct. 1,2003 [78 words]S.C.PandaNov 6, 2003 15:4612094
How Is This Not Terrorism? [146 words]Mary Ann MeierOct 7, 2003 13:0911725
islam is the problem [11 words]JoMay 1, 2009 04:2811725
Stastical Analysis: The Correct way to look at it [196 words]Leonard ApplebaumOct 7, 2003 10:2811715
sarah (?) eltanawi [84 words]Joyena AbrahamOct 5, 2003 17:5711696
Military/PC [74 words]zeph ruziahOct 5, 2003 13:0711692
Percentages [125 words]Gershon Y. Perry, M.D., F.A.C.C.Oct 4, 2003 16:4711685
Has O'Reilly Really lost his mind? [47 words]Howard MirkinOct 4, 2003 14:0611683
1Militant Islam - We must destroy it [166 words]Pete DumasOct 3, 2003 17:5111680
Convert them [43 words]elijah jay clarkFeb 26, 2006 19:1611680
Militant Islam [43 words]S SinghAug 11, 2006 08:2311680
Ants [73 words]Michael ArianOct 3, 2003 15:2211679
Have You Noticed... [158 words]J. SpiroOct 3, 2003 14:3011677
1Japanese Internment and Muslims [1197 words]Bob PriceOct 3, 2003 12:1511676
Regarding your comments [61 words]Austin SatoJun 4, 2007 13:0711676
Just a 'comment' [84 words]A lover of the English language (Amanda)Nov 3, 2009 18:5511676
PC too far? [81 words]Ivan BarnaOct 2, 2003 21:5811674
Daniel, You sure know more than Sarah Eltantawi [14 words]GaryOct 2, 2003 18:1511669
Islamists need extra vetting [101 words]A. AhmedOct 2, 2003 18:0111668
People like Daniel Pipes [86 words]Jeff BercovitchOct 2, 2003 17:3011667
In complete agreement [230 words]Mariana Harari FromentOct 2, 2003 16:0111665
Eltantawi and her comments [122 words]Shahin ShadmerOct 2, 2003 13:3211664
Facts v Lies [10 words]Charles ChristineOct 2, 2003 13:2711663
Better vet than dead [56 words]Virginia ThogersenOct 2, 2003 13:0511662
The numbers are insignificant... [87 words]LucileOct 2, 2003 12:2911661
Similarities in treason during World War II, the Cold War, and now. [234 words]Dr. William E. WatsonOct 2, 2003 11:0211660
On your O'Reilly Factor appearance. [32 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Sol LevitinOct 2, 2003 10:4911657
1Muslim clerics [126 words]Dov Sussman, Esq.Oct 2, 2003 10:3511656
9 out of > 4,000 isn't many. [433 words]Peter J. HerzOct 2, 2003 10:2111655
Chasing our tails [96 words]John MaloneyOct 2, 2003 08:5611652
The Real Enemy [579 words]Kyle GosnellOct 2, 2003 07:3011650
Eltantawi More Interested in Dissing Dr. Pipes [238 words]Dan BobinskiOct 2, 2003 05:0311649
u.s.military chaplains in particular muslims [148 words]robert finkOct 2, 2003 01:5311647
Muslems involved in the military's war on terror [131 words]Dennis BrownOct 2, 2003 01:5111646
Muslims in the Army [38 words]Walter E. WallisOct 2, 2003 01:3611645
Assimilation [206 words]Robert HicksOct 2, 2003 00:3911644
Sarah Eltantawi [241 words]Nora AmraniOct 2, 2003 02:0511642
Appearance on O'Reilly Sept. 30 [109 words]harold foxOct 2, 2003 01:4511639
bush needs to say it [12 words]pat forrestalOct 2, 2003 01:2611638
Eltantawi harms moderate Muslims [87 words]Lori-Ann BernathOct 2, 2003 00:1911636
Relative Likelihood of Terrorism Among Muslims and Non-Muslims [81 words]P. G. LubinOct 2, 2003 00:0911635
Sept. 30th O'Reilly Program [106 words]JeanOct 1, 2003 23:4311634
No Answer [17 words]Betty MatherneOct 1, 2003 23:0011631
Forthright [31 words]Stephen MachtOct 1, 2003 22:5311630
Gitmo Arrests [218 words]James HellwigOct 1, 2003 22:3511629
muslim traitors? [77 words]Y. B. DavidOct 1, 2003 21:5311627
What Muslim Clerics Preach [87 words]Mike RamirezOct 1, 2003 21:3511625
O'Reilly appearance [94 words]Professor Matthew YarczowerOct 1, 2003 21:3311624
the o'reilly show. [72 words]kevin cardOct 1, 2003 21:0411622

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)