4 readers online now  |  69 million page views

A New Report In Sweden Reveals Erdoğan Orchestrated July 15 Coup In Turkey

Reader comment on item: Why I Rooted for the Turkish Coup Attempt
in response to reader comment: Islamist coup in Turkey

Submitted by Petros Houhoulis (United States), Jul 20, 2017 at 15:24

A New Report In Sweden Reveals Erdoğan Orchestrated July 15 Coup In Turkey

Last year's failed coup attempt in Turkey is nothing but a false flag orchestrated by Turkey's autocratic President Recep Tayip Erdoğan and his henchmen to create a pretext for a mass persecution of critics and opponents in a state of perpetual emergency, a new detailed study titled 'July 15: Erdoğan's Coup' by Stockholm Center for Freedom (SCF) concluded.

Based on publicly available data, the coup indictments, testimonials in court trials, private interviews, reviews of military expert opinions and other evidence collected by researchers, SCF is fairly confident that this attempt did not even qualify a coup bid in any sense of military mobilization which was unusually limited in numbers, confined in few cities, poorly managed, defied the established practices, tradition, rules of engagement and standard operating procedures in Turkish military.

"This was a continuation of a series of false flags that were uncovered in the last couple of years under the authoritarian rule of Erdoğan regime and it was certainly the bloodiest one," said Abdullah Bozkurt, the President of SCF.

"Erdoğan appears to have tapped on widely circulated coup rumors in Turkish capital and staged own show to steal wind and set up his opposition for a persecution," he added.

Judging from the results of the coup bid, Erdoğan won big time by securing imperial presidency, consolidating his gains, stifle the opposition and even launching cross border military incursion into Syria for which he had been itching for too long. No wonder why he immediately called the attempt as "a gift from God."

The report was originally published in Turkish. SCF plans to release an English edition soon with new changes and updated data.

Here are some of the findings from 191-page detailed report on what happened on July 15, 2016, and days leading to that.

A huge gap has emerged between facts and the government's narrative on coup bid despite intense efforts by Erdoğan regime's in the form of censorship, propaganda, pressure, threats and even torture and ill-treatment. The testimonials from defendants and the evidence that was uncovered so far has further bolstered the view that the coup attempt was nothing but a set-up.
The conflicting public accounts by Erdoğan regarding the chain of events on the day of the coup, his recollection that even differ from the indictments issued by judiciary that is tightly controlled by his regime, the anti-democratic measures taken in the aftermath of the July 15, the shuttering of thousands of institutions and the arrests of tens of thousands of civilians cast a long shadow on July 15 events.
The fact that the head of Turkish intelligence service (MİT), Hakan Fidan, was tipped off about the coup in advance according to his own written statements sent to Parliament, but he neither informed the Prime Minister nor the President strengthened the claim that the coup bid was totally staged. There is no explanation for why the officials who are, first and foremost, responsible for discovering, thwarting, and halting the coup attempt against the elected government remained unreachable on the day of the coup and why they followed the daily routine even after they learned about the attempt.
Against the background of intel chief Hakan Fidan's lack of testimony either as a suspect or witness in any judicial investigation into the coup attempt, his no-show at the Parliamentary Coup Investigation Commission for a testimony, and the very fact that he kept his job, Erdoğan actually expects everybody to believe in his constructed narrative about the coup attempt without even questioning and investigating anything significant.
The fact that intel head Hakan Fidan met with the top military officials for hours a day before the coup as well as on the coup day, his trip to the General Staff's headquarters despite alleged tip-off that he was going to be whisked away and detained by military, his leaving the military headquarters without a hassle, and the launch of the coup attempt right after his departure has not been explained and justified as of today.
It is also important to note the Chief of General Staff Hulusi Akar made conflicting statements. Testimonials by witnesses and defendants do not confirm the account provided by Akar. The military experts that SCF has consulted in preparing this report clearly underlined that the coup bid, tipped-off in advance, could have stopped easily in its tracks and prevented by simple and quick measures. Yet, Akar's not resorting to such preventive measures fuels deep suspicions about July 15 events.
It was highly unusual and odd for the top commanders of the military had gone on with their usual routine, even attending wedding ceremonies at hours when there was credible and alarming intelligence of a coup attempt was received. This is against the established traditions, practices and rules of the operating procedures in Turkish military.
According to official account, 8,651 officers took part in the coup, corresponding to 1.5 percent of the total military personnel in the Turkish Army. Of those 1,761 were private conscripts, 1,214 were military students, and 5,761 were officers and non-commissioned officers. But even these numbers do not reflect the actual mobilization that was seen on the ground during the coup attempt. Given the fact that 168 generals and thousands of officers are now being tried on coup charges, the military experts find it odd that such an insignificant number of troops took part in the coup attempt. It is estimated that there are 200,00 troops under the command of these generals who are charged with the attempt.
The strange events such as shutting down the Bosphorus bridge to the traffic one way, hitting targets that have not served to the goals of putschists at all, the sparing of politicians who should have been the primary target, killing civilians, trying to seize institutions by only a handful of troops were not explained. The limited mobilization of military assets was confined to few cities and the teams that are supposed to detain Erdoğan came to his hotel hours after his departure. All these makes-no-sense events appear to be suggesting that they were staged to give an impression and supply footages and photos for the coup.
Even after one full year, Turkish government has failed to present a convincing and solid evidence that proves the Hizmet movement (popularly known as Gülen movement) was behind the coup attempt either as a mastermind or a participant. The fabricated and forced testimonials apparently taken under heavy torture in custody were later refuted by defendants when they appeared in court for trial hearings.
As various researches that were published or reported by international institutions have revealed, officers who are charged of attempting the coup comes from various ideologies and backgrounds. In most cases, the troops were mobilized over threats of impending terror threats or as part of the military drill, defendants' statements in the court has shown.
Fethullah Gülen who has inspired the Hizmet movement that was accused of coup bid by Erdoğan, stated in an exclusive interview with SCF that the coup bid was "outrageous heinous scenario constructed by Erdoğan and his accomplices." He said it was launched to pursue unprecedented witch hunt against the Hizmet movement. He made it clear if anyone who was sympathetic to the Hizmet movement took part in this heinous act, they betrayed the very ideals of the movement. Gülen reiterated his call for an international commission to thoroughly investigate the coup, an offer that Edoğan has failed to respond.
The uncertainty behind the ballistic investigations on the weapons used in the murder of civilian and troops still lingers on. The paramilitary groups that took part in clashes, and that later appeared in various videos taken on coup night were not identified and how they were organized and mobilized remains a mystery. There were also reports that Turkish police distributed high-caliber weapons to civilians on the night of the coup.
Turkey is no longer a country governed by the rule of law and democratic principles. It is now a state ruled by the government decrees under constant state of emergency. The judiciary is under full control of the government, freedom of press and expression are under hold, the parliamentary is no longer functioning and opposition politicians are behind bars.
More than 150,000 government employees were dismissed from their positions on the basis of their critical views without an effective judicial and administrative probes. The purges in the military, judiciary, foreign service and security apparatus have reached to alarming levels. 51,889 people were put behind bars, without an evidence, a trial and conviction, mostly housewives, teachers, students, doctors, merchants, journalists who were affiliated with the Hizmet movement.
Please click for the report's PDF in Turkish

July 5, 2017


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submitting....

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (40) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Thank you Mr Pipes - my response [373 words]PhilipMar 11, 2017 08:02237498
Why the difference between the West and Turks' point of view here? [138 words]Solomon2Sep 16, 2016 14:36232749
Recent coup attempt in Turkey [89 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Steve HagermanAug 13, 2016 20:02231368
Security camera footage of Turkish generals' abduction [21 words]Solomon2Aug 23, 2016 16:04231368
The elephant in the room [118 words]TonyAug 12, 2016 06:31231298
Question [18 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Alan GlazmanAug 4, 2016 17:21231202
What about the Gulenist network in America? [76 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Solomon2Jul 26, 2016 09:33230889
Was it truly a ssecular coup? [124 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Kepha HorJul 25, 2016 11:20230851
What course will Turkey now take? [41 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
SteveJul 22, 2016 13:31230722
"A stronger NATO"? I don't think so [371 words]Michael SJul 31, 2016 12:36230722
2Islamist coup in Turkey [6325 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Petros HouhoulisJul 22, 2016 04:23230655
A New Report In Sweden Reveals Erdoğan Orchestrated July 15 Coup In Turkey [1456 words]Petros HouhoulisJul 20, 2017 15:24230655
The new reality: Dictatorship, dictatorship and more dictatorship [321 words]Michael SJul 22, 2016 00:26230631
Me Too! [106 words]JerryJul 21, 2016 16:03230587
The Western Dandy leaders can't deal with Erdogan. [139 words]Michael SJul 29, 2016 05:30230587
1933 Revisited? [238 words]Dr. Jack LawsonJul 21, 2016 09:31230561
2Turkey's occupation of Cyprus [51 words]DavePJul 21, 2016 05:02230555
Islamismo Turco y Europa. [167 words]RafaelJul 21, 2016 03:07230553
Islamists came out of the woodwork [79 words]adaJul 21, 2016 01:03230550
1A successful coup would have been better [117 words]Ron ThompsonJul 20, 2016 23:25230548
2turkey [52 words]fred schwartzJul 20, 2016 19:11230544
The More Things Change [19 words]Barry BlackJul 20, 2016 17:16230538
1I, too, rooted for the coup [163 words]Ann WigginsJul 20, 2016 15:26230535
2Was the attempted coup genuine? [80 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Rich McJul 20, 2016 13:08230534
Too Late [32 words]Barry BlackJul 21, 2016 08:50230534
False flag [43 words]AlanAug 19, 2016 17:13230534
exceptional analysis [34 words]Timothy HadleyJul 20, 2016 13:00230532
Not a minority of one: I also rooted for the Turkish coup attempt! [41 words]Daniel BamfordJul 20, 2016 10:33230530
1Turkey's Coup [178 words]Mark in St. Louis MOJul 20, 2016 10:05230529
You Are Not Alone [136 words]Stuart WeissJul 20, 2016 09:10230528
This coup like the coup in Ukraine and many other places around the world since end WWII - designed by US. [116 words]S. LatzJul 20, 2016 09:01230527
4At first, I hoped it would succeed. But then... [260 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
There is NO Santa ClausJul 20, 2016 08:39230526
1Isolated Opinion- really?? Like Reichstagbrand 27 Feb 1933 [255 words]From GermanyJul 20, 2016 08:19230525
The Pakistanization of Turkey [7 words]carJul 20, 2016 03:04230521
How Obtuse Are Our Leaders? [121 words]DaveJul 19, 2016 20:26230515
1Members of the terrorist group The Muslim Brotherhood must have been having panic attacks following the coup attempt [61 words]dhimmi no moreJul 19, 2016 11:43230513
The Paradox That is Turkey - Why Erdoǧan Remained - This Time [192 words]M ToveyJul 18, 2016 16:35230502
Recep Tayyip Erdogan had it coming [122 words]YJ DraimanJul 18, 2016 15:29230501
1Minority of One --- But Absolutely Right [104 words]Domenic PepeJul 18, 2016 12:25230496
1Not alone [96 words]Marc WhitneyJul 18, 2016 11:57230494

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to A New Report In Sweden Reveals Erdoğan Orchestrated July 15 Coup In Turkey by Petros Houhoulis

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2018 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes