4 readers online now  |  69 million page views
You're invited: Join Daniel Pipes & MEF on a fact-finding mission
to Poland, Hungary & Austria. For more information, click here

A "No-State" Solution

Reader comment on item: The Three-Way Option: Arab States, Israel, Palestinians

Submitted by David Barnett (United Kingdom), Jan 27, 2017 at 09:30

The list of "bottom up" measures lacks the insistence on cessation of anti-Israel and anti-Jewish slanderous incitement. Without this, all else is pointless. It was a feature of the Egyptian peace treaty, and also the Oslo accords, but never enforced in either case.

All the politicians and academics are seeking political "solutions" for middle-east problems (not just re Israel); but there are none.

Politics is about wielding communal power to coerce compliance. This is legitimate when applied to security against predators (both external and internal) and to administer justice.

But whenever the state reaches beyond security and justice administration (even with the best of motives) the opportunities for favours and "jobs for the boys" multiply. The politically well-connected tend to extract resources from everyone else, creating huge resentments which can be redirected easily to convenient scape-goats. And in the middle-east, with its multitude of interleaved ancient communities, provides ample scope for this.

The slanders persist because the politicians of the free world have an appeasement mentality, and the corrupt Arab elites have every incentive to preserve their alibis.

This is not a new phenomenon.

In late Ottoman times, the effendi class made huge profits out of the tax system on the backs of their fellahin (peasants). Taxes had to be paid in cash; but the fellah had no cash, only his crops. His effendi would "lend" him cash for the taxes against a pledge of a large part of the harvest.

Jewish economic activity disrupted the tax racket. How? The Jews employed Arab labour and paid cash. Come tax time, the fellah was in a position to decline the effendi's offer of a loan.

The effendis fought back by getting laws passed banning land sales to Jews. However, Jews were prepared to pay such good prices, that the land sales continued by one subterfuge or another. [The same is happening today in the PA territories despite death-threatening fatwas against land sales to Jews].

With the failure of the land-sale ban, the effendis resorted to whipping up fervour for the "honour" of Islam. It was not hard to do because of the feudal mentality - that the owner of the land owned everything on it, including the people. How could it be right that a dhimmi can own a Moslem, especially in a land regarded as dar-al-Islam?

So the "nationalist" anti-Jewish campaign was stirred up by the Arab elites as a tool to preserve their exploitation privileges over the masses.

The British appeasement of the "nationalists" effectively endorsed the extreme anti-Jewish racism within the Palestine mandate. In a fit of insanity, they gave the religious post, Mufti of Jerusalem, to Amin Al-Husseini, a scion of an effendi family. He used his post to eliminate all dissenting voices [literally - he ran a private army of thugs]. This same Al-Husseini was very pally with one Adolf Hitler and fled to Germany during the war.

The pattern of anti-Jewish propaganda and incitement was set in late Ottoman times and entrenched during the British Mandate rule. It would take at least a generation of intense effort to undo the poisonous atmosphere. But as along as politics rules the day, the problem is intractable.

Symptomatic of the poison is the Arab insistence that Judah and Samaria should be Jew free. It is this Arab racist opposition to Jewish settlement that is the obstacle to peace, not the settlement. Most people do not realise that most of the Jewish settlement is on land acquired privately. Imagine how the liberal-left

Before even talking about x-state solutions anywhere in the middle-east, one ought to do a first principles examination of what a state ought to be and do. Given the patchwork of interleaved nationalities, sects and tribes, perhaps some alternative security arrangement to a "nation-state" needs to be devised.

After more than a century of failed attempts at a political solution, perhaps it is time to look beyond politics. A "no-state" solution would remove the controversy over who should be in charge.

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".


Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (33) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
2DAVID M. FRIEDMAN and Jews on What's Best for Jews in Israel [905 words]RobertFeb 20, 2017 17:34236839
3Try-partite solution will not work [356 words]PrashantFeb 3, 2017 22:30236282
Trump, the mideast conflict and the Jordanian option [36 words]PezDispenserJan 29, 2017 12:49236002
No Palestine [63 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Melvin A. FechterJan 29, 2017 02:44235964
2Best options so far [167 words]Sandy SaksJan 29, 2017 00:28235954
Only One Option Stands Out for Israel's Best Interests- The World Needs to Get Out of the Way [194 words]M ToveyFeb 6, 2017 16:31235954
1The Saudi Plan Offers Israel Conditional Recognition [110 words]DaveJan 28, 2017 20:31235944
external guarentor rarely works [110 words]ajnnJan 28, 2017 17:15235932
The dangers of 3rd party help [126 words]David BarnettJan 28, 2017 18:49235932
reliance on the altruism of nations is rarely beneficial [167 words]ajnnJan 31, 2017 21:36235932
1A "No-State" Solution [664 words]David BarnettJan 27, 2017 09:30235893
1Option Four (4) Israell, Palestine and the Arab States (after the Arab Spring) [252 words]RobertJan 26, 2017 20:54235869
2settling persecuted christians in the west bank? [178 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
fred debrosJan 26, 2017 07:27235849
christian settlers in the westbank [256 words]fred debrosJan 29, 2017 14:05235849
westbank settlements [82 words]fred debrosJan 29, 2017 14:13235849
christians in palestine [45 words]FredJan 29, 2017 14:15235849
westbank settling [15 words]fdeJan 29, 2017 14:29235849
United States is "occupied" territory - Not Jerusalem or Judea and Samaria (The whole territory of the Historical Land of Israel) [984 words]YJ DraimanJan 26, 2017 06:25235848
Jordan, Israel and Egypt need to work this out. Everyone else needs to butt out. The PA must be disbanded. [711 words]Michael SJan 26, 2017 05:56235847
Transfer is not a dirty word, says Ben Shapiro [341 words]martin kesslerJan 25, 2017 19:42235822
Sharia is Palestinian Stumbling Block [58 words]DENNIS ALLEN DURKOPJan 25, 2017 19:21235821
All Four Proposals Fail for the Lack of Integrity of Any That Will Not Recognize Israel's True Rights [466 words]M ToveyJan 25, 2017 19:10235818
One state solution [129 words]DebanjanFeb 12, 2017 21:37235818
Israel's Future Monarchy - Voting Rights will NOT be a Central Issue. [400 words]M ToveyFeb 15, 2017 11:25235818
A proposal that could work [268 words]Michael SFeb 17, 2017 01:30235818
One state solution and votes for Arab citizens of Israel [136 words]PrashantFeb 18, 2017 22:24235818
The Muslim States Are Stuck in 1949, Or Maybe 649? [56 words]DaveJan 25, 2017 17:10235815
A Rose By Any Other Name [342 words]Keefe GoldfisherJan 25, 2017 15:00235813
Illusions [161 words]Hanspeter BuechiJan 25, 2017 14:32235812
Fly in the Ointment [74 words]John NudgeJan 25, 2017 14:28235811
Solving of an un-solving conflict [111 words]KesselmanJan 25, 2017 14:26235810
The three way option: Arab states, Israel, palestinians [293 words]Frances WeingartenJan 25, 2017 13:54235808
Why Peace When Non-Peace Pays Better! [65 words]Barry BlackJan 25, 2017 13:19235807

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to A "No-State" Solution by David Barnett

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List


eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)