3 readers online now  |  69 million page views

(Islamic) religious extremism

Reader comment on item: How Many U.S. Muslims?

Submitted by John Williams (United States), Jan 16, 2005 at 15:43

Slaying of 4 may be tied to (Islamic) religious extremism (NJ Egyptian Christian family had throats slit)




Islamic extremists may have murdered four members of a Coptic Orthodox family found bound, gagged and with their throats slit on Friday in their Jersey City home, a law-enforcement official familiar with the case said.


The official confirmed that Hudson County investigators, as well the FBI, were "knee-deep" in pulling computer records and were coming to terms with the possibility that the family may have been targeted for death because of exchanges about religion in an Internet chat room.


The official cautioned, though, that investigators have not ruled out other possibilities, such as a robbery gone awry.


Hossam Armanious, 47, Amal Garas, 37, and their daughters Sylvia, 15, and Monica, 8, were found dead in their Oakland Avenue home early Friday after family members alerted police that nobody had heard from them in days.


First Assistant Hudson County Prosecutor Guy Gregory declined to discuss any details of the case, other than to confirm that police have ruled out a dispute the family had with a former tenant as a possible motive. He cautioned against speculating about the motive behind the murders.


"This is a very delicate investigation and one where we have spent hours at the scene collecting evidence and with the evidence collection complete, we're moving to bring in people that we feel need to be interviewed," Gregory said. "It's unfortunate that people are speculating."


But as the theory spread that revenge and religion were the driving forces behind one of the most heinous murders in the county's long history, fear enveloped the city's Coptic community.


Friends, relatives and co-worshippers of the devout family spent much of Saturday wondering how the seemingly upstanding Armanious family could fall victim to such a shockingly brutal crime. Several spoke of Hossam Armanious' participation in heated discussions about the Islamic faith on the Paltalk.com messenger service and threats he received for expressing his views about the religion.


Milad Garas, an uncle of Amal Garas, said Saturday that he was told investigators are probing whether the killings could have been prompted in part by the chat sessions. He also pointed to a passage in the Muslim holy book, the Quran, that details how enemies should be killed - bound and their throats slit, an assertion that drew a rebuttal from some Islamic scholars, but was supported by others.


A translation of passage 47:4 of the Quran reads in part: "Therefore, when ye meet the Unbelievers [in fight], smite at their necks; At length, when ye have thoroughly subdued them, bind a bond firmly [on them]."


"There is a very wide range of interpretation of that, and it depends on where people are in the spectrum," said Frederick M. Denny, a professor of religious studies at the University of Colorado and author of more than a dozen books on Islam. "If they were going toward the extremist side, it could lead someone to believe it is justified. ... There are those that take that [passage] quite literally."


The close-knit Coptic community promised protests if the religious revenge theory proves accurate.


"If it turns out they were killed for religion, then we will [protest]," said Ayman Garas, Amal's younger brother. "We have to be patient, we can't do anything stupid. ... But it looks like it is religion, maybe."


The Armanious family moved to the United States from Egypt in part to escape religious persecution. Hossam Armanious had sensed a rise in anti-Christian extremism and wanted to make a better life for his family in America, Ayman Garas said.


"What I really want to know is: How?" he said. "We just can't believe it at this point. Everything has passed like a dream."


The details of what may have been said in the chat sessions were not known Saturday night.


Fred Ayad, deacon of the couple's St. George Coptic Orthodox Church, said that the entire community was in a "panic" over the apparent targeting of the family, as well as the murders of a Coptic deacon in December and a Coptic cabdriver in late 2003.


Prosecutor Gregory said the conjecture about the murders is hampering his office's investigation, which he said has been exhaustive.


Copts are Egyptian Christians, a minority group of about 6 million in a nation of 60 million, and have been killed in religious rioting and during attacks on Christian churches by Islamic militants. Coptic leaders also say they lack representation in the Egyptian government and are treated like second-class citizens.


Over the past decade, Copts have increasingly immigrated to the United States. Currently, they number about 1 million in this country. Coptic Orthodox churches are scattered throughout the nation and, while there is no official count, Coptic Web sites list about 10 large congregations in New Jersey and about 20 in the tri-state area.


Islamic leaders said Saturday that the murders could not have been the work of someone inspired by the Quran.


"We are not a bloody people," said Ahmed Shedeed, director of the Islamic Center of Jersey City. "This is not from the Quran. This is not from Islam at all."


Shedeed, who is Egyptian, said his group recently co-founded a social service organization with local Coptic churches, called Egyptian Family.


"We are trying to get religious leaders from both communities to meet on a monthly basis to break the ice between the people," he said. "We meet as individuals, but as organizations we never have done such a thing. We are trying to show that Egyptians together can benefit."


Shedeed said that as part of that effort, he attended Christmas Eve services at St. George's this year.


Asked about passages in the Quran that may suggest murdering non-believers in a manner that resembles the family's deaths, he replied, "The Quran talks about people fighting in the battle of war. It's not talking about people who live next to you. ... This has nothing to do with our community at all."


"The Quran stands very firmly against taking human life," said noted Islamic author Zayn Kassam, chairwoman of the religious studies department of Pomona College in California. "If someone read a verse and used it to justify the killing of four people, I believe that person is unbalanced. ... There are very few Muslims who would support this sort of thing."


On Saturday, the family received mourners at the church, as friends left lighted candles and flowers in front of the home. Neighbors talked of an exhaustive police investigation, with a former Armanious tenant, Nelly Ramirez, saying police had questioned her, her son and her son's girlfriend.


Meanwhile, friends of Sylvia, a high school sophomore who would have turned 16 on Saturday, lingered in front of the house, alternately crying and laughing. They talked of an extremely gifted teen who recently won a trip to Italy from the National Honor Society for a series of essays she wrote on topics such as Shakespeare and Charles Dickens.


"She used to write all the time," said her friend Jankil Patel, 15. "She used to go to church all the time. ... She'd debate people in class and even had a religious tattoo on her [right wrist]."


"She had a lot of friends; she was very popular," said Jessica Cimino, 15, another friend. Cimino and the other girls said they plan to attend the family funeral on Monday and wear T-shirts bearing Sylvia's image to school on Tuesday.


Ayman and Milad Garad and other family members were allowed into the crime scene for the first time on Saturday morning to gather the needed paperwork for the cemetery. They left the home with a briefcase and several other items, including a tank with several small turtles inside.


Staff Writer Kathleen Carroll contributed to this story. E-mail: troncone@northjersey.com

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submitting....

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (34) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
No 1 knows [33 words]UnknownMay 29, 2012 10:26195889
1Citizenship [123 words]Judith WilsonFeb 23, 2011 01:13182903
Who cares [11 words]John SmithOct 22, 2010 19:52179551
1Protection Money Paid to Islam, Without Taxpayer Approval [2423 words]Kurt SteinerSep 1, 2010 12:38177550
1When in Rome, you do what the Romans do. [194 words]frank carterFeb 28, 2008 14:15121341
I'm confused [342 words]S.B.Mar 12, 2008 16:29121341
3Islam,Islam,Islam!!! [71 words]JabSep 15, 2009 11:55121341
SB- well said! [202 words]sandiNov 1, 2010 15:54121341
Why leave islamic countries ? [80 words]Phil GreendMay 18, 2007 12:0993484
3Oh the poor Muslims [193 words]Junaid BhuraApr 20, 2008 15:5393484
4We do not leave our countries because of Islam [98 words]ILIOct 15, 2009 10:0293484
Why? [112 words]HonestieMar 5, 2010 13:0293484
Money [22 words]miguelAug 3, 2010 07:2993484
History Repeats Itself [289 words]JohnAug 21, 2010 19:1993484
2deluded [79 words]kapoorSep 1, 2010 21:3193484
1see the truth [27 words]Abdur RaufSep 2, 2005 12:0325388
I Love America [52 words]AbdullaJul 11, 2008 12:5625388
3What For !! [174 words]IsaJul 17, 2005 21:1123544
1Which God? [250 words]G.D.Apr 13, 2006 18:4923544
GD [450 words]KHMay 29, 2008 16:4923544
1That is not fair or equal [142 words]HonestieMar 5, 2010 12:5323544
2Which God You Ask??? [212 words]The WatchmanJan 28, 2011 17:2723544
Re: How many US Muslims? [15 words]Nafata BamagujeJun 23, 2005 15:4722831
Re: How many U.S. Muslims? [34 words]Isa, m.s.Apr 25, 2008 07:4022831
who cares/so what [86 words]Moses (the lawgiver)Mar 8, 2005 12:4920870
(Islamic) religious extremism [1267 words]John WilliamsJan 16, 2005 15:4319699
Armanious family actually killed by non-Muslim neighbours....any retractions please???? [50 words]Truth TellerNov 26, 2006 19:5019699
Mr John Smith we use "May" probability not for certainty ,extremism is not an easy word [155 words]truth is a self-evidenceDec 31, 2007 22:5119699
Religious Islam [58 words]Don VanJul 1, 2004 11:0715864
Good job [23 words]Marvin BifferJul 29, 2003 19:4810304
How many Muslims in USA ?? 7M? 8M? 10M? [111 words]Saul PfefferDec 21, 2002 20:465046
3number of Muslims [294 words]Sir Daniel M.J. TobinMar 13, 2010 11:555046
1yay! [9 words]anonymousApr 25, 2010 14:185046
I Rock [219 words]Sir TobinApr 26, 2010 11:345046

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2017 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes