Sufi
Reader comment on item: "The Jews Are Going, the Arabs Are Coming"
in response to reader comment: reply to jim

Submitted by Jim (United States), Aug 4, 2009 at 15:23

Sufi,

Neither Facts can not be distorted nor realities can be hidden. Jews craved for many centuries to get land in Palestine - WHY DID JEWS HAVE TO WAIT MANY CENTURIES? THERE WAS NO "PALESTINE". DOES'NT ORIGINAL OWNERSHIP MEAN ANYTHING?

British made conspiracy (Belfore Declaration) to provide space to the Jews by weakling Muslims - THIS IS AN EXAMPLE OF HOW MUSLIMS ARE TAUGHT HISTORY. BE THE AGRESSOR AND PLAY THE VICTIM.

Once again you have taken light and narrow definition of word 'significant cause '. Actually , I meant if some one attack you , create hurdles or manhandle , in such conditions Islamic state not Muslims state ( not individuals) are allowed to declare Jihad - DOES A SECULAR EDUCATION, DEMANDING EQUALITY BETWEEN THE SEXES, EQUALITY BETWEEN INFIDELS AND MUSLIMS, DENOUNCING JIHAD AND OTHER FORMS OF ISLAMIC SUPREMACISM MEAN "CREATING HURDLES"?

until evils are rooted out. - SOUNDS TOTALITARIAN, BUT THEN ISLAM IS A TOTALITARIAN IDEALOGY.

In fact, there are differences on Fikh issues; however, no Muslim is allowed to kill another Muslim - BUT KILLING INFIDELS IS OK? ARE SHIA'S MUSLIM?

There is basic point that you people do not accept Muhammad (Peace Be upon Him) as Divine Apostle) - I HAVE A HARD TIME ACCEPTING A PEDOPHILE AS A PROPHET.

However, we are bound by religious book to respect and accept all previous prophets. - ARE YOU BOUND TO USE YOUR BRAIN?

Jews were chosen nation but not for all ages. Their period is mentioned. When Jews disobey injunctions of Allah and killed innocent prophets, wrath of Allah did incur upon you. Jews were expelled from Holy city not by Muslims but by Christians. When Muslims advance towards Palestine, a key were handed over to the Caliph Omer and without blood shed city was conquered. - THERE'S NO POINT RESPONDING TO NONSENSICAL DOGMA.

Not taught by Muhammad (PBUP) but by Allah - ALLAH IS MUHAMMAD'S ALTER EGO.

History is replete with illustrations and conspiracies which Jews made. It was time that Jews were not allowed to trade in grain and food items. They were not allowed to wear common dresses. Such rules were adopted by West not Muslims - WHAT CONSPIRACIES DID HINDUS MAKE THAT MUSLIMS ATTACKED THEM IN WHAT IS TODAY'S PAKISTAN? AND CHRISTIANS, THAT MADE MUSLIMS ATTACK ISTANBUL (CONSTANTINOPLE)? AND BUDDHISTS THAT MADE MUSLIMS ATTACK WHAT IS TODAY'S AFGHANISTAN, UZBEKISTAN ETC.

We are facing problems crated by you. But you people never blame your government why money, weapons and training were provided to young to fight for your cause. Your objects were achieved, you left Muslims in wilderness. It is your responsibility to make peace because US was a peace disturber. AT WHAT POINT DO MUSLIMS TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR THEIR OWN CONDITION?

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.