Should Israel invade Gaza?

by Daniel Pipes
Wed, 25 Oct 2006
updated Wed, 8 Nov 2006

Send

Comment

RSS

Question asked of Jerusalem Post columnists: "In light of the rampant weapons smuggling between Egypt and the Gaza Strip on the one hand but also the delicate situation involving kidnapped IDF soldier Gilad Shalit, who is held in Gaza, should Israel launch a large-scale offensive in the strip, similar in scope to the 2002 operation 'Defensive Shield'?" For all replies, see "Burning Issues #8: Should Israel invade Gaza?"

The kidnapping of Gilad Shalit is a tragedy for this soldier and for his family and friends, but a soldier's predicament cannot be allowed to influence the fate of a nation.

Eventually, the Israeli authorities will have to take back control of Gaza's border with Egypt and will have to intervene to prevent Gaza's further militarization, effectively reversing the IDF retreat of September 2005. No one wants this step, but it is hard to see the Palestinians controlling their aggressive impulses sufficiently so that it can be avoided.

More broadly, two schools of thought exist vis-à-vis Israel and the Palestinians: the majority opinion holds that Palestinians will accept Israel only when their political, economic, and other aspirations are satisfied.

The minority one - mine - holds that they will accept Israel only when their will to make war has been crushed. Existing anarchy has started this process but it will be more expeditiously achieved when Israelis themselves can administer the defeat. (October 25, 2006)

Related Topics: Arab-Israel conflict & diplomacy, Israel, Palestinians

TrackBack URL for this post: http://www.danielpipes.org/blog/trackback.php/697/51aa5/581

Reader comments on this weblog entry

Title	By	Date
Crush the Palestinians? [w/response] [37 words]	mb	Nov 21, 2006 15:01
↔ Whose land? Who are the illegal settlers? [291 words]	Doron Zielinski	Mar 16, 2007 06:18
Quagmire [w/response] [183 words]	Fred Schlomka	Nov 21, 2006 14:18
↔ No, Surround it with a moat [162 words]	Doron Zielinski	Jul 23, 2007 19:50
yesterday [65 words]	dfwhite	Nov 17, 2006 15:58
↔ DEATH BY A THOUSAND CUTS... [106 words]	DONVAN	Nov 22, 2006 14:46
Should Child Molesters Be Left In The Elementary School Without Supervision? [76 words]	skmiller	Nov 13, 2006 11:27
Yes [45 words]	Octavio Johanson	Nov 9, 2006 17:53
Agree on this one [97 words]	Peter Edwardsson	Nov 9, 2006 13:31

Comment on this weblog entry

Name:	Email Address: Email me if someone replies to my comment
Title of Comments:
Comments:
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited, before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but not hostile, libelous, or otherwise objectionable statements. Original writing only, please. For complete regulations, see Guidelines for Comments. Top 25 recent comments Daniel Pipes Blog Homepage

Daniel Pipes Blog Homepage

ADVERTISEMENTS