2 readers online now  |  69 million page views

A Claim Superior to the 'Palestinian' Objection is Invoked

Reader comment on item: A Turning Point in the Arab-Israeli Conflict?
in response to reader comment: Palestine

Submitted by M. Tovey (United States), May 18, 2011 at 13:17

Are we to understand that by a revisionist sentimentality of the previous post the 'Palestinians,' a people of various Arabic and similar descent, who have been able to use the land for centuries without having to describe themselves other than by the names given to them by others like the Caliphate of the Ottomans (and others), now need to take away the land already consigned by history to Israel; and to revert the previous contentions of the United Nations in 1948 that Israel has a right to exist? By asking the question: "why have they left the 'Palestinians' with no country," a presupposition needs to be addressed, that of why did they not form the nation when there was the better chance?

Prior to the rebirth of Israel, 'Palestine' was not a nation, nor was there a national presence. The indigenous peoples were, for a very long time, subjects to the various regimes that had control over the land for centuries, the Ottomans being the last of the Islamic empires that held the control before being wrested away by the British, who helped make the region, labeled Trans-Jordan, a protectorate until the United Nations performed in an act of unconscious obedience to the promise made to the people of Israel thousands of years ago. Until the underlying circumstances of the real reason of why the 'Palestinians' are seeking to have Israel reduced to a former state again, the questions of 'why' will be perennially academic as they have been for millennia.

The 'Palestinians' are a cause for uniting the fundamentalist Islamic followers to achieve one thing, and one thing only: the destruction of Israel. Do you think that the Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has promised to 'wipe Israel from the land' for no reason? Did anyone not understand that when Kofi Annan of the United Nations made his presentations for dealing with Israel, that the map of his depiction of the nation of Israel was labeled entirely 'Palestine,' in Arabic? Indeed, the people that live in the Middle Eastern area now comprised of Israel for over sixty years (and Judea-Samaria since 1967) and the surrounding territories, have been fought over between Israel and the Arab neighbors for one reason only; the militant Islamic forces from before the rebirth of Israel have never recognized Israel at all; ever.

There is no recognition by them of Israel's right to the promise to Abraham; nor do the powers that be ever want to allow Israel to continue in spite of the fact that no one has yet been able to evict Israel. And they have not yet figured out why. Let us temporarily dismiss the precepts of Hertzl's secular national identity, or the evangelical Christian perspective as to why Israel seems to defy the odds at remaining in the land. As much as many would like to provide some justification for and against Israel retaining the rights to the land, there is a subliminal circumstance for why no one seems yet to be able to diminish Israel's claim. But if it is impossible for any to see that Israel is, in fact, in possession against all odds, then discussing the hidden facts will not help here. Israel remains; and the 'Palestinian' cause will be the cause of the destruction of many who seem intent on trying to eliminate Israel's claim to the land. As to a birth right to the land, if the ethnicity of those who filled the land during the Ottoman reign could truly be determined, and of those who were born there generations after their ancestors' moved in were truly known, then there would be an understanding of how the development of the land (prior to Israel's involvement, development was by most accounts-stunted-like Gaza is now) evolved over the millennia. Ask them to explain how they were never able to nationalize back then.

When Gaza was ceded (a prophetic circumstance, by the way) to the 'Palestinian Authority,' virtually most of the advancements found in Gaza were set to ruin in order to 'cleanse' the 'Jewish' influences. Then Hamas was invited by the 'Palestinian' population, not to advance the 'Palestinian' cause, but to advance the cause of hatred against the Jewish people. If, in this experiment they are unable to bring about a civil society that is willing to live with any neighbor, how can it be expected things will change if they are given any more land when they cannot control what there is now. Israel is a functioning democracy now, with a certain indigent Arab population that, when not held accountable to extremist threats, are more than willing to live under the more benevolent Israel government than the definitively oppressive Hamas/Fatah controlled 'Palestinian' Authority. Ask again: "why have they left the 'Palestinians' with no country?" One must first seek the real reason why they have not for centuries; then understand that Israel did return to the land because it was meant for them to, 'Palestinians' notwithstanding.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (58) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
110 MAIN POINTS IN ARAB – ISRAEL CONFLICT [607 words]DaisySep 2, 2011 13:23189031
4Supporting Israel [6 words]Clifford IshiiMay 19, 2011 15:55185359
Whole Humanity supports Israel [12 words]Ravi Ranjan Singh Bharat PanthiMay 26, 2011 09:23185359
3Question for mr.Pipes [18 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
EDJul 28, 2011 19:28185359
1Question 2 [35 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
EDJul 29, 2011 07:15185359
Turning Point is an Understatement [178 words]Barry BlackMay 18, 2011 10:32185330
Messianic Sovereignty [95 words]Adam NeiraMay 17, 2011 20:25185317
One world order? [36 words]KarenaMay 23, 2011 22:44185317
1Messianic Kingdom, and Its King Defined By Isaiah [505 words]M. ToveyJun 1, 2011 13:19185317
Non violence is a step in right direction [165 words]PrashantMay 17, 2011 11:17185310
an ill-wisher indeed [133 words]yuval Brandstetter MDJul 19, 2011 11:30185310
1America No Longer The Leader Of The Free World [56 words]CharlesMay 17, 2011 08:27185308
4The Palestinian Arabs are fishished! FINISHED! I tell ya! [324 words]There is NO Santa ClausMay 17, 2011 07:27185303
4Naturalize the Palestine Arabs [135 words]Peter HerzMay 17, 2011 06:04185298
Related? [46 words]David BowmanMay 17, 2011 00:20185293
Make the border so dangerous they won"t attempt the cross [57 words]YerkelMay 16, 2011 23:10185292
1The Palestinians are doing it in a Jewish way [202 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Debanjan BanerjeeMay 19, 2011 12:46185292
Seriously Doubt Palestinians Would Do ANYTHING Jewish [473 words]M. ToveyMay 23, 2011 18:07185292
My reply to M Tovey [236 words]Debanjan BanerjeeMay 26, 2011 21:55185292
5Debanjan Banerjee needs to be corrected [133 words]PrashantMay 28, 2011 02:58185292
Think Israel is Not Exceptional? Think Again! [16 words]M. ToveyMay 31, 2011 16:09185292
1Prashant [455 words]Debanjan BanerjeeJun 4, 2011 05:12185292
1Why Israel was/is Never Part of the Ummah [843 words]M. ToveyJun 9, 2011 15:57185292
10LONG LIVE ISRAEL [29 words]NickMay 16, 2011 22:34185291
Loving Israel is saving humanity [67 words]Ravi Ranjan Singh Bharat PanthiMay 26, 2011 00:59185291
1Palestine [76 words]LindaMay 16, 2011 21:59185290
A Claim Superior to the 'Palestinian' Objection is Invoked [827 words]M. ToveyMay 18, 2011 13:17185290
Sovereign Borders [43 words]David CampbellMay 16, 2011 20:23185288
1Israel's New Challenges [140 words]Ilbert PhillipsMay 16, 2011 13:24185280
6"Nakba" [154 words]Patti ZentaraMay 16, 2011 13:10185278
2What prevents poor nations from walking in on rich nations? [26 words]AnonymousMay 16, 2011 13:01185277
Mexicans ARE walking into the US [9 words]alanMay 20, 2011 02:06185277
Wolves in Sheeps' Clothing [80 words]Frank LukeMay 16, 2011 09:49185272
interesting [17 words]connorMay 16, 2011 04:16185266
5Electrify the fence [261 words]StevenMay 16, 2011 01:29185255
1Peace in the Middle East ?? [35 words]Avik Bar-OnMay 17, 2011 07:21185255
11Israel Must Defend Her Sovreignty [465 words]Jerrold L. SobelMay 16, 2011 01:03185254
Must punish criminals [130 words]Ravi Ranjan Singh Bharat PanthiMay 17, 2011 08:01185254
Hope they didn't ban landmines. [5 words]Eric1May 15, 2011 22:53185252
We don't know who is responsible for the violence [80 words]David FisherMay 15, 2011 22:26185251
3Israel, the time has come to finally wise up and lose theillusion. [182 words]NuritGMay 15, 2011 21:55185250
Being Palestinian [62 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
ScottMay 15, 2011 21:51185249
Why would non-violence work better than violence for these border incidents? [8 words]Roslyn FranklMay 15, 2011 21:20185248
Pretty plain Syria is behind this. [65 words]lcloselyMay 15, 2011 21:00185246
The Syrians' bravado is laughing at them. [80 words]batya daganMay 15, 2011 20:25185244
2The Israeli-Arabs are unruly. They are no more than Israel's 5th Column. [304 words]NuritGMay 15, 2011 20:06185242
1The ugliest thing one can be. [78 words]batya daganMay 16, 2011 21:49185242
1Yes they are the worst kind, the 5th Column all over Israel and growing [458 words]NuritGMay 17, 2011 21:48185242
2old war [64 words]Dan FriedmanMay 15, 2011 19:43185241
2Overall, "nonviolence" is a pipe dream in historical perspective of Islamic populations. [70 words]kmanMay 15, 2011 18:42185238
1No choice [80 words]AngelMay 15, 2011 20:11185238
Palestinians [11 words]Pamela SmithMay 15, 2011 18:22185235
1Palestine? [71 words]DAVID R.GROESBECKMay 15, 2011 18:08185234
1When Derelict Leaders Aim To Lose.... [260 words]Adina Kutnicki, IsraelMay 15, 2011 17:23185231
1The Flock Desperately Needs the Good Shepherd [687 words]M. ToveyMay 16, 2011 16:39185231
Barak must get out of the Govt. [253 words]PhilippeMay 20, 2011 15:03185231
5Doesn't make sense [36 words]RobbyMay 15, 2011 17:21185230
Israel/Palestine compared to United States/Mexico [151 words]messengerMay 16, 2011 20:04185230

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to A Claim Superior to the 'Palestinian' Objection is Invoked by M. Tovey

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List
eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2020 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)