5 readers online now  |  69 million page views

We Tried, We Failed

Reader comment on item: Tempering Ambitions [in Iraq]

Submitted by J.A. Morris (United States), Nov 11, 2006 at 20:59

For starters, the Clintonistas refused to acknowledge that serious national security threats existed or that America was in any way threatened by the Islamic world. Despite Bush being at the helm on 9/11, he still refuses to perceive that an Islamic threat exists except among a few radicals. No one wanted to deal with "Islam" or confront its history of murderous violence. By ignoring the 1993 WTC bombing, the bombing of our troops in Saudi Arabia, the bombing of 2 Embassies and the bombing of the USS Cole, the Clinton gang was grossly negligent. During the Clinton years, Clinton ordered the bombing of Christian Serbia (who posed no security threats to the U.S.) and Ms. Halfbright toasted champagne with Kim Jong Il.

9/11 obviously changed a lot of our perceptions as our cozy secure world proved beyond any doubt that America could easily be attacked. So we had no choice but to go to Afghanistan, clean out the Taliban and hunt for OBL. On the threat scale, Saddam Hussein was more than a mere nuisance. Every nation on earth including the US believed him to be a threat with WMD's. I reluctantly supported the invasion of Iraq but had serious regional geo-political concerns. The thrill of seeing Hussein literally plucked from a filthy hole was enormously gratifying.

But here's the reality. We can never deliver functioning democracies to Muslim nations. I hoped we could. Both Afghanistan and Iraq have constitutions that are decidedly Islamist and no laws may conflict with the Koran. Sharia law prevails in both nations. Both nations are doomed by their culture and religion to be violently tribal and we can't change that but that is the precise 1400 year old history of Islam. We demanded that the Palestinians have democracy and they democratically elected Hamas. In Algeria, elections resulted in a victory for Islamists and a ruthless civil war waged between the military and the religious lunatics. In Turkey, the Muslims elected an Islamist leader (Erdogan)who had been in prison for agitating for Islamic law. For whatever reasons, democracy and tolerance are unable to take root in the Muslim world.

Back to Iraq. Saddam Hussein was a ruthless genocidal maniac who maintained peace, Muslim style. As a minority Sunni, he viciously oppressed the Shiite for decades and stole the entire oil wealth of the nation. With Iraq exploding daily because of ethnic/religious violence, it's clear that some in the region are agitating for a failed Iraq, notabily Iran.

What will probably happen is our worst nightmare. Shiite Iraq will merge with Shiite Iran to create the mother of all Shiite nations (66 million Iranians plus 25 million Iraqis). Considering that the combined oil wealth of both Iraq and Iran is sufficient to hold the world hostage to Iran's demands, this will be very problematic, catastropic actually. Iran, which already controls/funds Syria (a Sunni majority nation) will solidify existing areas of influence, including Lebanon, and will create the proverbial Shiite Empire ruled by Tehran - the new Persian Empire.

Also, Iraq is an artificial nation that was created with the stroke of a pencil by British Arabist Gertrude Bell at the demise of the Ottomen Empire following WWI. It doesn't have the historical and national longevity of Syria or Persia or Turkey. Also, if Iraq literally dissolves, you can be sure that the Kurds will emerge fighting for their own nationhood. This will explode into a regional war as Turkey and Iran vie for more real estate, especially Iraq's oil wealthy regions.

The problem with the middle east and the Muslim world is that we do not understand them, how they think, how they react and how they perceive us. We foolishly assume that they are just like us and other folks around the world. They are not. They always end up with leaders like Saddam Hussein, Qadaffi, the House of Saud and Assad. Why? Because they only understand raw terror and brute force which is precisely how one earns respect in the Muslim world.

Reagan bombed Libya and Qadaffi stopped terrorizing the world. No one heard so much as a peep out of him for several decades. In the crazy quilt mosaiac of the Muslim world, respect is earned through fear. No one respects that which they don't fear.

Wars only end when someone is militarily defeated or the pain of continuing is unbearable and someone capitulates. The Israelis blundered badly by not wiping out Hezbollah and now the entire Muslim world has lost respect for a nation that they once greatly feared. Hezbollah will be back but the next time they will have more accurate and longer range missiles.

We cannot win in Iraq or Afghanistan. It was a noble experiment, I don't regret it but we failed. We need to find an honorable exit. The Taliban is ruling most of Afghanistan and Karzai is, for all practical purposes, the mayor of Kabul. Our "friend" Musharaff the closet Islamist who orders attacks on India cut a deal with the Taliban and OBL types in his frontier region. The Pakistani Army will not enter those places of tribal lawlessness. Moreover, Pakistan's intelligence is loaded with jihad Islamists. Our "friends" the Saudis financed Pakistan's nuclear program.

Historically, the Muslims have not peacefully co-existed with anyone except in a slave master relationship (if you wanna call that peace). If we are truly worried about national security, we need to commence divorce proceedings with the Wahhabist and most of the Islamic world. If we don't need Muslims in America achieving a critical mass as they have in Europe or we will experience Paris type rioting across the nation. We will live in terror of them and capitulate to their every demand just as Europe now surrenders to Islam.

Bush has massively encouraged Muslim immigration in the U.S. In fact, in 2005, the number of Muslims legally entering the U.S. exceeded the sum total of the preceding 20 years (NYT). This is very dangerous and is the equivalent of inviting Nazis into our country during WWII. Moreover, the Bush open border policies have resulted in hundreds of thousand of "Other than Mexicans" crossing our borders and many have been identified as Islamist, Hezbollah etc. It is generally estimated that only a very small percentage of illegals are even caught. Therefore, we have no idea how many Islamists Bush has welcomed into America. Even more interesting is that OTM's are immediately released under the Bush "Catch and Release" program.

The war on terror? What a joke. But what isn't a joke is that the Bush Administration has used the WOT to hack away at civil liberties while using the braindead GOP Congress to grant him unaccountable absolute powers that no President should ever have.

I confess, I'm an idiot. I voted for Bush in 04 because the alternative was even more terrifying.

But where do we go from here and how do we find an honorable exit? Staying the course is no more than a death sentence for our soldiers. They aren't dying for our freedom and dying for Iraqi freedom is a total waste of our noble military.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (46) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Success in Iraq [161 words]stranchanMay 26, 2012 02:38195842
Iraq in 10 years from now [95 words]sevillaMay 11, 2012 04:30195551
Iraq after withdrawal [66 words]KeralaApr 19, 2012 00:40195188
Question for Dr. Pipes regarding Green zone in Baghdad [227 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
American MuslimDec 3, 2006 00:5868093
Militarily we already won.. but politically? [260 words]AndrewNov 15, 2006 20:4766260
Two Postscripts [95 words]Susan WalkerNov 14, 2006 06:2966070
Kurds and Sunnis [48 words]JayNov 13, 2006 23:2466050
In War: Resolution [263 words]JackdawNov 13, 2006 22:4466047
When We Lost the Battle of Iraq [266 words]Douglas BoggsNov 13, 2006 22:0266043
Goals according to Bush + BEWARE OF SPIN! [193 words]MelMNov 13, 2006 18:4866035
Correct Strategy for Iraq [176 words]Chris ChrismanNov 13, 2006 13:0065999
It Is What It Is [65 words]Jeffrey BradleyNov 12, 2006 23:0065958
Pulling out. [143 words]John RNov 12, 2006 22:3065957
I respectfully disagree. [116 words]John PhilipsNov 12, 2006 22:0465955
National Schizophrenia & Political Paralysis [500 words]AbijahNov 12, 2006 18:2465946
A Caveat [49 words]Richard WittrupNov 12, 2006 17:5665942
Am I the Only Bush Defender? [90 words]lindaNov 15, 2006 17:0265942
You're not alone. [194 words]Kevin MNov 16, 2006 11:5565942
Dare to Be Different [239 words]lindaNov 16, 2006 19:3765942
America's successes or failures in Iraq [276 words]Maurice PicowNov 12, 2006 14:3665926
Iraq [168 words]A. MaranoNov 12, 2006 22:2365926
WOW! [224 words]BlackspeareNov 12, 2006 10:0765912
Some challenges to Dr Pipes' ideas [549 words]Stuart FaginNov 12, 2006 09:4365910
Hold the Fort [489 words]K.H. AhmedNov 12, 2006 08:3665907
ratchet down [133 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDNov 12, 2006 07:4965904
Our Understanding of Iraq [314 words]Leonard MarkowitzNov 12, 2006 05:5865901
West point has not, but Israel certainly had [237 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Yuval Brandstetter MDNov 14, 2006 07:4665901
The Failure of the Bush Doctrine [455 words]Prof. Paul EidelbergNov 12, 2006 01:5865892
Purple Hearts & Defense of Rumsfeld [605 words]lindaNov 11, 2006 22:3965880
Success in Iraq [177 words]Peter NamtvedtNov 11, 2006 21:1065863
We Tried, We Failed [1188 words]J.A. MorrisNov 11, 2006 20:5965861
"We swear we will not rest from our jihad... before blowing up the filthiest house, dubbed the White House," [544 words]FreemanNov 11, 2006 20:5565860
Is this Victory? and Tempering Ambitions [101 words]John LothNov 11, 2006 20:5065858
VICTORY AT ALL COSTS [472 words]JackdawNov 11, 2006 17:5565844
response to your comments [141 words]TinaNov 11, 2006 20:4865844
You are 100000 % correct ! US must crush these Islamist Terrorists ruthlessly [130 words]MahatmaNov 11, 2006 21:1565844
Cultural transfiguration [244 words]David W. LincolnNov 11, 2006 17:0665840
comment on your comment [128 words]TinaNov 11, 2006 20:3765840
All the seven accused in July 11 Terror Attacks are Muslims [151 words]RamanNov 11, 2006 21:3565840
Evaluating societies [158 words]David W. LincolnNov 12, 2006 17:0865840
Point of Clarification [194 words]David W. LincolnNov 12, 2006 17:2065840
Don't give up [162 words]Octavio JohansonNov 11, 2006 16:4065837
you're not up on the news [104 words]TinaNov 11, 2006 20:2965837
Bajaur madrassa trained suicide bombers: Musharraf ( An honest confession of an Islamist ) [301 words]LeaderNov 11, 2006 21:2065837
A perfect exit stategy, unlike Vietnam: Jacobs Ladder comes of age [53 words]Mark-Alan WhittleNov 11, 2006 15:2965831
depressing [261 words]TinaNov 11, 2006 15:1265830

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to We Tried, We Failed by J.A. Morris

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List


eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)