69 million page views

Dear Aggie, how right you are!

Reader comment on item: Muslim Zionism
in response to reader comment: Obscuring the truth

Submitted by Moshe (Israel), Jun 11, 2006 at 11:59

The only thing is that you forget that it is useless to try to bother a Muslim with historical facts. They have made up a brand new "history" of their own according to which:

1. Jews have no historical ties to Palestine which they deceitfully are calling the Land of Israel.

2. Jews have never ruled Jerusalem in the past: The famous great Kings Daud (David) and Suleiman (Solomon) were of course Arab Kings.

3. Musa (Moses) was (you guessed right!)……. a well known Muslim prophet !

4. And last but not least: our common forefather Ibrahim (Abraham) was commanded by Allah to sacrifice his only son Ismail (Ishmael) in..-you won't guess-…In Mecca of course, you stupid!

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (127) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Yerushalem shel zahav [113 words]dhimmi no moreMar 24, 2014 18:13213980
The song sung by Jews [31 words]saraMar 25, 2014 22:09213980
2Good art belongs to all [181 words]dhimmi no moreMar 29, 2014 08:14213980
Dhimmi? [22 words]JohnApr 18, 2014 16:28213980
1Good art is for all and Qur'an 1:2 [446 words]dhimmi no moreApr 20, 2014 12:58213980
How interesting [10 words]saraApr 21, 2014 22:59213980
1It's not about "who shouts loudest"! [80 words]Andrew ShawMay 29, 2008 07:38130434
muslims tell us 08' [85 words]Phil GreendJan 27, 2008 18:54119096
3How many REAL muslims you know? [473 words]mohammedNov 19, 2006 18:2166647
RE: How many real Muslims you know? [193 words]Octavio JohansonNov 20, 2006 07:5166647
What point is Mohammed trying to make? [217 words]MosheNov 21, 2006 14:1866647
Muslim Zionism exists! [32 words]PeterOct 27, 2007 12:5266647
1False Believers [149 words]MeMar 8, 2009 01:4566647
2International Society of Legally Approved [1037 words]CRUXApr 9, 2013 09:4566647
Very well stated ..... [127 words]EphraiimMar 27, 2014 15:5066647
Muslim Militant Sleep Cell Organization Currently Under Investigation for making death threats against the President [489 words]CinderellaSep 3, 2006 22:2654826
Bar Ilan University is not in Jerusalem. It is on the suburbs of Tel Aviv. [15 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
BorisJul 30, 2006 03:4851198
I don't believe that Muslims are more reverent [62 words]PhilJul 19, 2006 21:2950246
Trying to understand [147 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Donald SegarJul 14, 2006 07:0749630
TO me it's elemental.... [55 words]SandiJun 11, 2006 11:0447443
1God is a Jewish God so get another one! [110 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJun 13, 2006 07:1347443
Are you saying.... [30 words]SandiJun 15, 2006 22:0847443
that is not all you said. [353 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJun 17, 2006 05:3947443
Thank you Abdul Rahman! [219 words]MosheJun 28, 2006 03:1447443
Islamicising you???? [315 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJun 30, 2006 10:2247443
1About understanding Islam and modern Israel. [844 words]MosheJul 2, 2006 07:1447443
vomit them from our midst [155 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJul 4, 2006 09:4547443
"Muslim Zionism"??? Maybe rather Gengis Khan's legacy? [302 words]MosheJun 11, 2006 09:0347436
rant [43 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJun 13, 2006 05:2547436
Hatred? [10 words]MosheJun 28, 2006 02:3047436
Lies, twisting words [122 words]JamaalJun 9, 2007 22:0547436
While Your Waiting for the Messiah...Do EVERYTHING With In Your Power To Deny You Are The One You Are Waiting For!! [1396 words]Tom Hanifin(raised Irish Catholic and fortunately no longer practicing))Jun 11, 2006 02:5847410
Muslim Zionism is The Greatest Threat and The Worst of all [182 words]TTSJun 11, 2006 01:4247403
Muslim Zionists should be supported [100 words]Benjamin SolomonAug 25, 2007 02:1647403
Muslim Zionism [454 words]Maurice PicowJun 10, 2006 16:0247377
Dark ages [154 words]ZavJun 12, 2006 10:1447377
despair [311 words]Mark KatzmanJun 12, 2006 21:3047377
talk to some real muslims not just your bogey men [185 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJun 13, 2006 07:0347377
law of return [170 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJun 13, 2006 07:2847377
Muslim Zionism [22 words]steven LJun 9, 2006 22:1147347
1World under threat of Muslim domination [406 words]Amitabh tripathiJun 9, 2006 11:0347328
Midget Indian Highjacker [206 words]HarrakJun 9, 2006 23:3447328
World under threat of Muslim domination [17 words]steven LJun 10, 2006 17:0647328
1Terrorists in Canada [312 words]CristinaJun 11, 2006 04:0947328
2Harrak, RAM and computers [95 words]Anubhav SinghJun 11, 2006 06:3247328
Kudos to you Singh! [24 words]MosheJun 12, 2006 02:4747328
Reply for Anubhav and Christina [177 words]HARRAKJun 12, 2006 10:0547328
Moshe!! موشي means NOTHING in Arabic [105 words]HarrakJun 12, 2006 18:4747328
1Thanks Moshe and recommendation on some books for everyone here [219 words]Anubhav SinghJun 13, 2006 01:1547328
1Agree [130 words]JaladhiJun 14, 2006 12:0447328
and you know all this from a book... [256 words]ahmad zafireJun 14, 2006 22:5747328
Response to Indian above [20 words]JohnJun 15, 2006 14:1947328
1responding to HARRAK [129 words]CristinaJun 18, 2006 14:2247328
depends on who you listen to [438 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJul 14, 2006 06:4947328
2Responding to Abdul Rahman Reijerink [275 words]CristinaJul 16, 2006 16:2547328
Cristina [582 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJul 18, 2006 21:5647328
1Responding to Abdul Rahman Reijerink [523 words]CristinaJul 19, 2006 17:5447328
thankyou [50 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJul 20, 2006 05:0147328
Hoping to clear some controversy.. [215 words]Youngg HackNov 14, 2006 00:0647328
It's a world conquest that is intended to be permanent [146 words]TonyMar 29, 2011 04:1947328
I dont think so... [288 words]OlegJun 9, 2006 08:2747324
oleg [119 words]ahmad zafireJun 9, 2006 21:2747324
ahmad zafire [223 words]ElizabethJun 12, 2006 17:0147324
elizabeth [530 words]ahmad zafireJun 14, 2006 06:2047324
Muslim Zionism, the hidden agenda [125 words]Octavio JohansonJun 9, 2006 07:5247323
שתי הערות: טוב שאתרכם באנגלית, אך צריך להיות [29 words]יעל ש.Jun 9, 2006 07:2747322
Reminds me of the time I spent a few days in Bangkok [85 words]SullyJun 10, 2006 23:5247322
Good point! [67 words]MosheJun 12, 2006 03:1647322
להיות [22 words]AlbertJun 30, 2006 00:1647322
Reality check [197 words]Johannes ThorlaciusJun 9, 2006 00:1847312
Typical Islamic Rhetoric [207 words]ElizabethJun 8, 2006 16:5247296
elizabeth [16 words]ahmad zafireJun 9, 2006 21:3247296
Explanation [156 words]AhmadJun 10, 2006 17:0147296
The Israeli face of defeat [209 words]Kenneth S. BesigJun 8, 2006 12:0347291
Response to K.S. Besig [22 words]BlackspeareJun 8, 2006 18:2947291
Enlighten us [201 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanJun 8, 2006 18:5347291
Too defeatist - there is sometimes a place for tactical withdrawal [187 words]SullyJun 9, 2006 01:4047291
Defeat or Fortress Israel [122 words]BlackspeareJun 9, 2006 11:4047291
Defeat is never pretty [109 words]Kenneth S. BesigJun 11, 2006 02:1847291
A "bargaining chip" [83 words]Kenneth S. BesigJun 11, 2006 02:2247291
Defeat is defeat no matter how you try to pretty it up [150 words]Kenneth S. BesigJun 11, 2006 02:2947291
You have no idea what you are talking about [127 words]Kenneth S. BesigJun 11, 2006 02:3547291
Jerusalem's many lovers [314 words]JayJun 8, 2006 01:2147276
Whoa!!!! [27 words]Garry LockwoodJun 7, 2006 23:4247275
Response to Garry Lockwood [73 words]ElizabethJun 8, 2006 16:5947275
garry [107 words]ahmad zafireJun 8, 2006 22:4047275
According to what I've read -- NO mention of the city of Jerusalem in the Koran... [45 words]J.S.Jun 9, 2006 14:5347275
You are correct, Gary... [135 words]J.S.Jun 12, 2006 18:1347275
Sad, but true [21 words]Allen WeingartenJun 7, 2006 12:2047243
And then what...? [21 words]Mark GarretsonJun 7, 2006 18:4747243
300,000 people in distant Tehran [111 words]AndyJun 7, 2006 05:4647218
10.000.000 gathered to abolish your theory Mr Ex-communist citizen! [168 words]HarrakJun 7, 2006 21:4947218
Zionism [123 words]Shahin S.Jun 9, 2006 00:3447218
islam is worse [137 words]G. BisvasJun 10, 2006 05:4147218
Yearning for something is easier if you don't own it ! [91 words]Jon-a brit in EurolandJun 7, 2006 04:5747213
Arab "love" of Jerusalem? [148 words]Susan IrelandJun 7, 2006 03:3547211
I could be wrong... [55 words]Vic CoffeyJun 7, 2006 02:4947210
Zechariah told it [120 words]Topi HeiskanenJun 7, 2006 02:2447209
Pissing Contest [112 words]BlackspeareJun 6, 2006 22:5647202
Dr. Pipes' New York Sun column on the significance of Jerusalem to Muslims [107 words]Norman MeyersonJun 6, 2006 22:1047199
info post here -- the term Jerusalem does NOT appear anywhere in the Koran... [203 words]J.S.Jun 9, 2006 14:4947199
Jerusalem, my chief joy [90 words]r wilkinsonJun 6, 2006 22:0247198
Mr Wilkinson is partially correct - The "new" Israelis are too eager to please CNN, BBC, ABC, CBC, ,,surrender territory [243 words]nabil shawarmaJun 9, 2006 15:0847198
Islamize zionism [58 words]Nenette GrunbergJun 6, 2006 20:3447197
Kadima's willingness to divide Jerusalem invites Islamist agression - and ipso facto invalidates two state idea [178 words]Ben van de PolderJun 6, 2006 20:2047196
The difference between the two Zions [57 words]HarrakJun 6, 2006 19:1147194
Great article: The keys are with their rightful owners. [180 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanJun 8, 2006 08:0547194
1Obscuring the truth [176 words]AggieJun 9, 2006 02:1647194
1Dear Aggie, how right you are! [117 words]MosheJun 11, 2006 11:5947194
1How Right You Are [67 words]AggieJun 11, 2006 19:3347194
1You are right-- P.S. [96 words]AggieJun 11, 2006 19:3947194
What Happened Is That The Land Went Back To Its Rightful Owners [58 words]AnneMJun 12, 2006 23:0147194
Excellent Points.. [48 words]Another InfidelJun 13, 2006 01:0547194
1Aggie, one cannot argue with the arbitrary! [141 words]MosheJun 13, 2006 04:2947194
rightful owners? under what law? [198 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkJul 5, 2006 10:3547194
1Yes Abdul Rahman, rightful owners! [332 words]MosheJul 6, 2006 09:0147194
Not for her own sake [230 words]Ari LevyJun 6, 2006 18:5847191
article on Muslim Zionism [104 words]Lucy ChambersJun 6, 2006 18:3047188
Yes, an ironic twist here... [176 words]J.S.Jun 6, 2006 17:3047186
2muslim zion [140 words]donvanJun 6, 2006 17:2947185
1Yes you're right but... [117 words]rickJun 6, 2006 16:3947183
1Disagree with the term [102 words]MickeyJun 8, 2006 13:3547183
Very well said! [9 words]MosheJun 9, 2006 06:1347183
Totally agree with your suggestion [13 words]Pakistan DramasAug 29, 2012 09:3447183
Isn't it about Jewishness? [66 words]David W. LincolnJun 6, 2006 15:4547177
1i think [80 words]LynnJun 6, 2006 15:3647176
You are so right! [87 words]Ephraiim (Froike)Mar 28, 2014 11:4947176

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)