All Madina chapters of Quran and Madina hadiths were added later

All Madina chapters of Quran and Madina hadiths were added later
Reader comment on item: More Converts to Terrorism
in response to reader comment: Enemies of our civilization

Submitted by Ali (United States), Dec 19, 2005 at 17:06

Mr Mueen : Do you belong to that sect of islam who believes that only the peaceful Mecca chapters and the good Mecca hadiths are original and all the violent Madina chapters of Quran callling for slaying infidels and sleeping with their captured women and Madina hadiths which say Mohammed killed infidels and distrubuted and slept with their women, are corrupt and added later? I have joined that sect myself.

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.

Reader comments (78) on this item

Title

Date

Let people decide. [219 words]

Yousuff Siddiqi

Dec 28, 2008 06:32

Hiding under Muslim Names [202 words]

Romana Manesceau

Nov 2, 2006 19:58

Philippines: Radical Muslim converts take centre stage [677 words]

Sophie

Dec 20, 2005 17:07

The use of the word "mohammedans"muhamedans" etc [125 words]

Ed Brophy

Dec 16, 2005 16:44

↔ why the word mohamedan changed to muslims [32 words]

Raayee

Dec 19, 2005 21:22

↔ Muslims [76 words]

Idris

Oct 3, 2007 07:43

So, why are more people converting to Islam in America? [87 words]

Raayee

Dec 15, 2005 19:11

↔ Response to Rayee [75 words]

Mu'een Ud Deen

Dec 16, 2005 05:40

↔ Reply to Raayee [222 words]

faqi hussain

Dec 16, 2005 11:56

↔ Reply to faqi hussain [250 words]

Raayee

Dec 19, 2005 21:56

↔ To Rayee, rumour of whites converting to Islam [257 words]

Ahmed

Dec 20, 2005 01:44

↔ Response to Raayee [512 words]

faqi hussain

Dec 20, 2005 14:01

↔ To Raayee [313 words]

Amira

Dec 21, 2005 13:56

↔ To Raayee, Most conversions take place in prisons [127 words]

Khan

Dec 21, 2005 18:23

↔ To Amira, apostacy and Islam [350 words]

Ashfaq A.

Dec 22, 2005 11:34

↔ Muslim is a Muslim [152 words]

sajid

Mar 7, 2006 04:04

↔ WHAT? [81 words]

Ehsaan Mesghali

Nov 28, 2006 23:17

↔ wanted to know why people converted to islam [23 words]

hameed

Jan 9, 2007 13:21

↔ shame on you Ms Amira [55 words]

fahad

Nov 6, 2007 10:23

↔ sajid what are you on about ? [72 words]

Nina Niazi

Nov 20, 2007 10:24

↔ i know why islam is rising so fast [95 words]

David

Feb 19, 2009 11:21

Germany sees rise in converts to Islam [7 words]

Sophie

Dec 14, 2005 06:40

Conversion of America, Islamist Master Plan [402 words]

N.K.

Dec 13, 2005 15:26

You are confronting the lies and deceptions of today [25 words]

Enaid Redom

Dec 12, 2005 16:41

Stop Poaching, and leave Christians and Jews alone [225 words]

Frederick J. Bainhauer III

Dec 11, 2005 12:54

↔ Frederick [62 words]

P.O.D.

Dec 14, 2005 05:32

↔ Please respect all the religions. [134 words]

asaassd

Dec 23, 2008 20:16

Sami al-Arian
[w/response] [47 words]

Anonymous

Dec 11, 2005 11:48

Enemies of our civilization [80 words]

Behrouz Azarnia

Dec 11, 2005 04:19

↔ Reply to Behrouz Azarnia [682 words]

Mu'een Ud Deen

Dec 15, 2005 07:15

↔ Questions to Mueen Ud Deen [410 words]

A.A.

Dec 15, 2005 17:07

↔ Reply to A.A [431 words]

Mu'een Ud Deen

Dec 16, 2005 05:35

↔ Reply to Mu'een Ud Deen = Helping the Religion [466 words]

Sophie

Dec 16, 2005 08:01

↔ Response to Mueen, Hadiths and Siras had witnesses [218 words]

A.A

Dec 19, 2005 12:59

↔ Response to Mueen Ud Deen [332 words]

Ex Muslim

Dec 19, 2005 13:16

↔ Mueen,Why didnt Allah drop finished scriptures ? [144 words]

Nazir

Dec 19, 2005 16:28

↔ ⇒ All Madina chapters of Quran and Madina hadiths were added later [70 words]

Ali

Dec 19, 2005 17:06

↔ islam is true ,west is falles side [142 words]

muhammed Ali(christ)

Feb 1, 2006 09:29

↔ mohammedans protest loudly at any perceived slight [11 words]

Arturo

Mar 27, 2006 17:26

There are of course mosques and mosques [66 words]

Ed Brophy

Dec 10, 2005 15:38

↔ nowhere it is a law [125 words]

saqib ahmed

Mar 2, 2007 12:07

Where islamists stem from? [84 words]

Ed Brophy

Dec 10, 2005 15:21

These instances reflects the true picture of Islam. [608 words]

Amitabh tripathi

Dec 10, 2005 10:57

↔ JESUS WAS MUSLIM [451 words]

saqib ahmed

Feb 23, 2007 15:58

↔ hmmmm? [117 words]

Dhimmi333

May 13, 2007 18:49

↔ Deceptive Secularism [536 words]

Mazhar Kaleem

Jun 21, 2009 10:26

Plan to take over USA by multiplying ,immigration and and conversions [217 words]

A. Ahmed

Dec 10, 2005 08:12

↔ A Ahmed/Cardinal Ruinis Advisory [112 words]

P.O.D.

Dec 14, 2005 05:48

Congress should investigate ideologies to qualify them as a religion [114 words]

N.K.

Dec 10, 2005 02:52

↔ which verse in the Muslim's book is a sign of hatred to other religions [204 words]

saqib ahmed

Feb 28, 2007 13:32

My Solution [58 words]

Reuben Horne

Dec 10, 2005 00:51

how about a lil tax scarecrow?! [170 words]

Donald O

Dec 9, 2005 22:34

Is Islam the problem - the Egyptian Elections raise serious questions [408 words]

Bubbaman

Dec 9, 2005 18:46

What else to do? [105 words]

Yoven

Dec 9, 2005 15:59

Targetting of U.S. prisons by islamic missions [68 words]

A.A.

Dec 9, 2005 11:58

Converts and their new "thing" [103 words]

Ed Brophy

Dec 8, 2005 14:08

Rachel Corrie? [45 words]

Shepard

Dec 8, 2005 13:45

converting to Islam [290 words]

Andy

Dec 8, 2005 13:14

Infiltrate [23 words]

Irving Wiseman

Dec 7, 2005 18:13

Don't Worry, Be Happy [93 words]

Aaron

Dec 7, 2005 18:10

In addition to the converts... [83 words]

J.S.

Dec 7, 2005 15:20

meanwhile [124 words]

David Borensztajn

Dec 7, 2005 14:14

Abdul Hamid is John Walker Lindh [92 words]

Mike Smith, M.A., of San Francisco

Dec 7, 2005 12:21

Converts to Islam [109 words]

Thomas Earl Cannady

Dec 7, 2005 12:17

↔ Converts [255 words]

Protegimus

Jul 12, 2007 15:08

Progress or spinning wheels [81 words]

David W. Lincoln

Dec 7, 2005 11:54

Jihadism in western converts [121 words]

Donald W. Bales

Dec 7, 2005 11:46

↔ Islam religion of Peace and Prosperity. [177 words]

Sajid

Mar 6, 2006 03:41

↔ O yea [79 words]

Muhammad

Sep 2, 2006 22:34

↔ Mohamedan [16 words]

faruqa

Jul 7, 2007 21:07

State of Mindset [346 words]

Yehoshua Zeller

Dec 7, 2005 11:15

Beltway Sniper Connection
[w/response] [48 words]

dds

Dec 7, 2005 10:24

converts to islam [217 words]

janet mills

Dec 7, 2005 10:01

↔ Re Janet Mills and Larry Shapiro [201 words]

dds

Dec 7, 2005 14:12

↔ is this an argument [71 words]

saqib ahmed

Mar 2, 2007 11:56

↔ how sad [228 words]

geenee

May 2, 2008 21:11

An addition to the list? [24 words]

A.J. Caschetta

Dec 7, 2005 09:29

Recruiters [26 words]

Larry Shapiro

Dec 7, 2005 08:53

Comment on this item

All Madina chapters of Quran and Madina hadiths were added later Reader comment on item: More Converts to Terrorismin response to reader comment: Enemies of our civilization

Reader comments (78) on this item

Comment on this item

All Madina chapters of Quran and Madina hadiths were added later
Reader comment on item: More Converts to Terrorism
in response to reader comment: Enemies of our civilization