43 readers online now

Latest Articles

 

ADVERTISEMENTS



Premium Links
by Wikio

Computers
Electronics
Communication
Appliances

Short term, immediate action
Reader comment on article: [Saudi Arabia:] Not Friend or Foe

Submitted by Ken McPherson (United States), Sep 28, 2002 at 02:42

Unfortunately, all alternative energy sources combined will only provide a small percentage of our energy needs, simply because of volume. Development of the necessary alternative infrastructure would increase our energy needs, as well.

If we must suffer constraint, then let's eliminate the threat that forces our need for constraint. These are some immediate, short term actions.

Embargo hostile oil producers.
Freeze their dollar assets to prevent a financial meltdown of the American dollar.
Then seize or eliminate their oil production capabilities.

Occupation has worked before to change centuries of entrenched militant culture. All the world dreams of, and will come to identify with, a liberator.

Profile, scrutinize and deport militant sympathizers from the West.
Investigate their American fundraising organizations.
Crush the financial base that funds Islamofacism.
Isolate and bankrupt the promoters and participants, most of whom are from upper-class Saudi and Muslim society. (Nazi and Japanese officers were denied the vote or holding of office after WWII.)

Ignore the outraged howls of illegitimate despots, ignorant puppets, and dithering academics. (What you gonna do, punk?)

Imperfect, humane capitalism- or perfectly inhumane sharia. Us or them.

Please try to avoid raising a new class of despots, like the Northern Alliance; maybe this time we could export semi-honest capitalism, instead of politicized corruption. Government spin-offs resemble the parent company, just as in any industry.

I agree, however, that the new McCarthyism would be hard to stop-- if we could avoid American sabotage of it. (Couch the above conditions in suitably anti-Western phrases, and the Left would probably rush to support it- "antiglobalism, anti- Big Oil", that sort of thing.)

Equally problematic is preventing our government's abuse of this power.
Modern government is another growth industry of utopian coercion- I guess cleaning up the domestic front would come after survival. Would the natural Western inclination of outrage at our (future) international errors bring on the needed reforms?

Will the Muslim abuse of Western laws- religious, welfare, immigration, and political- force us to discriminate? Would we transform into our enemies? Or would we simply be more realistic in our distinction between principle and policy?


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited, before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments.

Submit a comment on this article

Other reader comments on this article

Title By Date

Arab Deception [67 words]

Michael Cooke Dec 24, 2005 01:53

Time will bring change [329 words]

Donald Smith Aug 7, 2005 11:23

What A Game [254 words]

Abu Mustafa Jun 26, 2005 21:11

Open War is Upon Us and there is Nothing We can do to Stop It. [701 words]

Aaron Speer Apr 15, 2005 11:53

It is urgent to separate oil dependence from voluntary submission to dictators [207 words]

Joseph Constantin Feb 1, 2005 10:46

Head of the Snake [31 words]

Dave Jan 29, 2005 12:46

Fools [94 words]

Mike Nov 17, 2004 02:13

Oil Boycott? [48 words]

Clifford Ishii Oct 6, 2004 20:36

Oil Boycott? [22 words]

Clifford Ishii Sep 13, 2004 01:46

Very true insight to Saudi Arabia [14 words]

Michael Sullivan Jun 22, 2004 01:17

a saudi arabian ... [190 words]

may Jun 3, 2003 21:24

Surprising! [98 words]

Kashif May 7, 2003 06:31

Aran world has not delivered to itself or the outer world. [232 words]

Christopher Golitsyn May 1, 2003 18:03

Neither friend nor foe [86 words]

Elanjical Abraham Apr 15, 2003 06:48

Friends and USA [373 words]

Noor Mar 31, 2003 15:46

  for the peace of the world [26 words]

mbarek Jun 14, 2006 05:17

People.... Think twice [119 words]

Meedo Feb 1, 2003 01:08

Saudis could be friends as well. [142 words]

Fariba Heidari Jan 25, 2003 03:14

USA is the biggest terrorist country [30 words]

Ahmed Jan 16, 2003 02:50

Saudis did it. period [188 words]

C.E. Humphreys Dec 3, 2002 18:12

Anything but justice ? [404 words]

Khaled Nov 26, 2002 10:58

Saudi Arabia is no friend [55 words]

Jillian Sharon Nov 24, 2002 21:01

People don't understand our differences [85 words]

sultan Nov 24, 2002 06:13

Deadly Cocktail [126 words]

David Steinberg Nov 22, 2002 01:25

Persian Gulf oil import numbers [23 words]

Donovan Nov 9, 2002 00:52

A Prescription for Chaos.. [119 words]

George A Nov 4, 2002 17:03

Saudia Arabia - no friend of the US! [123 words]

Gary L Adler Nov 4, 2002 15:12

Culture Clash [317 words]

Tom Dykes Oct 7, 2002 19:06

⇒ Short term, immediate action [339 words]

Ken McPherson Sep 28, 2002 02:42

Astute Accuracy [244 words]

Vernon Sim Sep 25, 2002 02:09

The Demise of Arab Oil Imperialism [132 words]

Andrew Dubowyj Sep 18, 2002 05:37

Saudis: "A new disease to World" [74 words]

Joly Mathew Aug 29, 2002 21:39

The U.S. has no option other than total war [387 words]

Vincent Racaniello Aug 25, 2002 23:20

Saudi Arabia vs. Iraq [183 words]

Patrick Griffiths Aug 20, 2002 23:49

House of Cards [604 words]

Paul Green Aug 12, 2002 21:03

Indict, extradite, and use civil courts [146 words]

Austin Moseley Aug 9, 2002 14:16

Take back what is ours [27 words]

John Pusinsky Aug 6, 2002 20:11

Boycott Middle East Oil [173 words]

John M Jul 31, 2002 20:53

Friend or Foe [118 words]

Sig Zeitlin Jun 26, 2002 20:58

US Policy has Allowed This Situation to Develop [605 words]

William J. Sturm May 19, 2002 19:01

Consider energy policy with security [138 words]

R.L.Clair May 19, 2002 17:01

Not Rivals: The Saudis attacked the US [253 words]

Richard Stone May 17, 2002 20:41

I agree with you but... [100 words]

Sindibad Aladin May 17, 2002 15:15

ibn Saud Mafia [126 words]

Frank Blazey May 17, 2002 14:35

A Constant Threat of Terror [213 words]

Jamie Musikant May 17, 2002 02:16

Saudis Betrayed by Inane US policy of 'Engagement' [256 words]

Bill Bryan May 16, 2002 18:44

The Foremost American Haters [300 words]

Arvind Sundaramurthy May 16, 2002 05:20

The Arab world's economics dictate their actions [288 words]

Jaime Eisen May 16, 2002 01:36

Why Only Saudis? [79 words]

Arthur Hutchinson May 15, 2002 23:34

Saudis - friend or foe? [216 words]

Susan Blake May 15, 2002 22:37

Let's Rid Ourselves of Saudi Oil [148 words]

Steven Litvintchouk May 15, 2002 22:34

Friend to Whom? [124 words]

Ben Franklin May 15, 2002 21:24

End World Dependence on Arab Oil [140 words]

Ariel Liebman May 15, 2002 20:01

The Coming War Against Saudi Arabia [944 words]

Michael Lopez-Calderon May 15, 2002 17:39

  Proud Atheist Supports War against S.A. [155 words]

Dr. John Michael Nahay Jul 15, 2007 06:50

The Original Muslims [57 words]

Alexios Ash May 15, 2002 17:35

World War III Has Begun But Nobody Wants To Admit It [141 words]

Scott Fleming May 15, 2002 17:08

Daniel, you're right again! [106 words]

Steven Hoop May 15, 2002 13:05

SAUDI ARABIA, THE ENEMY [224 words]

Ilene H. Richman May 15, 2002 12:56

Clearly a foe [50 words]

Brent Waters May 15, 2002 12:23

Economic impact [55 words]

Bob Irving May 15, 2002 11:30

Saudis are Mortal Enemies [114 words]

Spyros Alvonellos May 15, 2002 07:24

Lucas J. Meyer - Extraordinary Inflation? [51 words]

Bob May 15, 2002 06:57

Wrong country? [309 words]

anonymous May 14, 2002 23:43

More foe than rival [482 words]

Barry Shmookler May 14, 2002 23:42

Nuwabians [157 words]

E. N. Amrani May 14, 2002 22:20

  nuwabian [39 words]

x Mar 13, 2006 00:58

  the root (Africa),Egypt and History [48 words]

Anthony Devine Jan 26, 2007 14:41

Saudis: Not Rivals -- Enemies! [71 words]

Steve Herman May 14, 2002 21:11

Wake up, Americans to the Saudi danger! [178 words]

Motty Perel May 14, 2002 19:44

US-Saudi relationship based on technology transfer [44 words]

Mark Durie May 14, 2002 18:48

The Fear of Saudi Competition [575 words]

B Shniper May 14, 2002 17:37

Clearly a Foe [63 words]

Adam Browser May 14, 2002 15:55

Make the Saudis Need the US [216 words]

Samy Mikhail May 14, 2002 15:29

Saudi Treachery [90 words]

Burton Sehler May 14, 2002 15:19

The Saudi Threat [222 words]

R. Crockett May 14, 2002 14:42

The Saudis as Rivals [30 words]

Ken Besig May 14, 2002 14:08

A Little Economics [183 words]

Lucas J. Meyer May 14, 2002 13:56

Saudi Arabia is an enemy [209 words]

Ken Shofner May 14, 2002 13:51

  Late reply to General Shofner [11 words]

Lengthy P Mar 18, 2008 22:35

More proof of Western folly [100 words]

Bill Brent May 14, 2002 13:48

Wahabi arrests in Georgia [108 words]

TPutnam May 14, 2002 13:23

Excellent Analysis [10 words]

Allan Grafman May 14, 2002 13:12

Why Not Foe Only? [55 words]

Dick Militelo May 14, 2002 12:57

Certainly no friend [145 words]

Francis W. Thornton May 14, 2002 12:32

Daniel you have excelled again. [26 words]

Denis Bieber May 14, 2002 12:22

Comment on [Saudi Arabia:] Not Friend or Foe

Name
Email Address (optional)

Email me if someone replies to my comment
Title of Comments
Comments:

Mark my comment as a response to Short term, immediate action by reader Ken McPherson

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited, before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments.

Click here to see the 25 most recent outstanding comments.

ADVERTISEMENTS