5 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Regarding Israel

Reader comment on item: What Is Israel's Next Move In The New Middle East?

Submitted by +Bp Gabrielle Crofts OCC (Australia), Jun 5, 2011 at 16:05

Dear Dr Daniel Pipes,

I have been reading your articles & books since approximately 1990 (First heard of you during my Politics ,Phil and Sociol. Double major in Womens Studies degree at Murdoch University Australia) and I must thank you firstly for your in depth analysis and for the unnerving accuracy you have shown this past many years.

Indeed I have learned so much about not only history but Terrorism, Extremism, Islam, Politics and International Relations also from your writings. I thank you so sincerely for my learning in this area.

I wish to address the issues of Israel, and the misnomer called nakba day.

The Arab islamists are proven adept propagandists of the Infamous style of Gobbels Propaganda Minister of Adolf Hitler (Hitler once was reported to have said tell a lie so large, the bigger the better, that it will more likely be believed).

Israel is the sole nation I believe which was established by the purchase of land by Jews with consent of arab owners and islamist leaders at the time, for money. Israel was part of the carve up of the middle east by Sir Winston Churchill and other Eureopan leaders post -downfall of the Ottoman Empire defeat of WW1.

Indeed Syria, Egypt, Yemen, Saudi Arabia, Morocco,Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan all were given states after the defeat of the Ottomans by these europeans without any consideration to the multi- ethnicities and multi- religions of the land areas, these were just arbitrarily lines on a map, none of its leaders having had seen or spoken with the peoples of those areas as far as I am aware, before carving up of O ttoman Empire happened, To the victors came the spoils. Kings, Queens, Tyrants, one and all were all given titles and wealth, and at the time it was hoped would be friends in future fo the allies of the victors, not enemies.

Trans-Jordan was designated the Palestinian Homeland. Churchill by stroke of a pen reduced promised land promised to the Jews by 75 per cent.

Arab leaders such as nasser and Muslim Arab nations all warned arab muslims to leave Israel or face being massacred as the muslim arab nations intended to not leave a single Jewish person alive after they attacked. So, at the urging of their islamic leaders 600 000 or so rab muslims left the area of Israel they had gone to in search of work from arab nations, back ot the arab countries. Iraqs Jews were massacred and those who could escaped with barely more than what they were wearing. 800,000 Jews at least, were evicted from arab muslim nations without their wealth land and businesses, truthfully, all their assets of these evicted exiled Jews stolen by greedy genocidally bent arab muslims nations. The 600,000 muslim arabs who left Israel chose to do so, they were not forced to leave Israel. The were not refugees, but emigrees out of Israel lands. They alone chose to leave , because it was the arab muslim leaders who had told them to do so. None were thrown out, they chose to go and noone prevented them doing so. Those who stayed , noone forced them to leave either.

In the rush towards declaring a second Palestinian Homeland State ( TransJordan was declared the Palestinian Homeland State), it seems history is being deliberately forgotten or as I believe, historical revisionism has become rife amongst the lazy, hate filled anti semetic, intellectually bankrupt pseudo intellectual elites in left wing universities and media organisations to name but a few.

The salivation of the PLO PLA and HAMAS at the propaganda victories which has set the stage for the europeans and UN to declare a second palestinian Homeland by carving up a tiny miniscule land mass in comparison to the other arab muslim nations on Israels borders is obscene and deadliest intent clear.

That is, the annhilation of the only Jewish homeland self ruled by democratic government of Jews for Jews in the entire world. Muslim Arabs, at least 50 nations of muslim nations I know of, and yet not a single nation of muslims will allow integration for their islamic ummah brothers into other arab or islamic nations. What is it that keeps these muslim nations hell bent on the disempowerment of their bretheren of muslims, the so called Palestinians?. The answer's clear , the stealthy destruction of Israel by islamists..

Where is the recognition of the Jewish need for compensation for the lands and property and businesses stolen by arab muslim nations which threw the Jews out?.

Where is the restitution for the Jews of the massive reduction of what the Jews were promised by Churchill of 75 per cent of promised Jewish nation lands?.

I ask the world, why are the UN and europe and others so intent to reduce Israels borders to indefensible land areas. Why is the Palestinians after the sole Jewish capital Jerusalem, which was built by King David, thousands of years ago and never, ever, was a time in 5000 years of history when Jews did not live in Israel ( Judea and Judah , also Samaria etc) back 5000 years at least since the days of Abraham and the Jewish tribes.

There is no where else for the Jews to go on the face of this earth where they can be protected and kept safe from pogroms, anti semetic vile attacks, and hatred and discrimination.

It is Israel which is the last place of earth for the Jews promised to them by GOD himself which is at stake.

Not one single pasrt of this world except Israel will protect the Jews this has been proven over, and over ,again and again in the entire history. I call to the Prime Minister of Israel defend your Jewish people or you will all end up destroyed. there must never be a divided Israel or perish. The lives of 6 million innocent men women and children Jews whom were slaughtered in a planned genocide by Hitler and aided by Al Husseini and others are proof that the world cannot be entrusted with the Jews safety stability and security ever.

Israel must take harsh steps, Israel must defend the entire borders it won legally in a defensive war in 1967. Those who attacked Israel without cause must not be rewarded by giving lands back captured by the victors.

God Bless Israel forever

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (89) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
5Regarding Israel [1066 words]+Bp Gabrielle Crofts OCCJun 5, 2011 16:05186005
defending Murdoch's legacy [138 words]y Brandstetter MDJun 9, 2011 08:38186005
4God's War on Terrorism [116 words]Lynn SchamanMay 28, 2011 14:59185674
The Cube [152 words]Adam NeiraMay 16, 2011 08:50185270
3Problems of 2 state Palestine. [345 words]D BursteinMay 21, 2011 13:18185270
1Amen Mr. Neira [82 words]Seamus Dafydd Dives MacNemiMay 22, 2011 19:35185270
McDonalds Damascus: not [40 words]Rea1ityCheckMay 11, 2011 23:08185118
Israel, look out [33 words]PEMay 9, 2011 00:06185040
dear PE [100 words]realistMay 12, 2011 15:29185040
Israels next move? Wouldn't you like to know! [164 words]Seamus Dafydd Dives MacNemiMay 24, 2011 01:11185040
They Cannot Know What They Do Not Understand [269 words]M. ToveyOct 3, 2011 17:52185040
a future that goes where? [155 words]Jules PostenMay 5, 2011 19:15184928
2Peace in our time? [132 words]Abraham IrwinMay 5, 2011 10:12184913
Patriotism versus Islam [185 words]Jon, a Brit from EurolandMay 6, 2011 03:23184913
14IF THREATENED, ISRAEL SHOULD JUST BE READY TO BOMB ITS ENEMY BACK TO WHERE IT BELONGS---STONE AGE!!! [826 words]Nur el Masih Ben HaqMay 4, 2011 16:09184866
1Shards of Custiss Lemay [224 words]Jon, a Brit from EurolandMay 5, 2011 05:09184866
Absolutely correct, Mr. Ben Haq [184 words]DEBORAH THE JUDGEMay 6, 2011 11:27184866
Technology Abolished the Stone Age - But the Obstacle Facing Israel Does Appear Monolithic [47 words]M. ToveyMay 6, 2011 16:50184866
I Support the Democratization of the Arabo-Islamic World [174 words]Nur el Masih Ben HaqMay 6, 2011 19:10184866
2Allah Moon-God [104 words]realistMay 12, 2011 15:41184866
2help for realist [192 words]DEBORAH THE JUDGEMay 13, 2011 09:31184866
Deborah is RIGHT, 'Allah' is originally a reference to pagan deity [119 words]Nur el Masih Ben HaqMay 13, 2011 19:41184866
BIBLICAL SONS(S) OF GOD Vs Mr. realist's MISCONCEPTION [744 words]Nur el Masih Ben HaqMay 13, 2011 20:38184866
What is wrong in being a pagan diety? [80 words]PrashantMay 14, 2011 01:16184866
2Totally correct [255 words]AngelMay 16, 2011 03:37184866
37'Allah,' Is Not the God of the Bible [5886 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Brutus BalanMay 23, 2011 00:12184866
BRUTUS BALAN is right but.... [230 words]Nur el Masih Ben HaqMay 26, 2011 12:14184866
1In agreement with Brutus [82 words]+Bp Gabrielle Crofts OCCJun 6, 2011 07:41184866
The narrative Bible and the erratic Quran [491 words]Brutus BalanOct 11, 2011 01:00184866
Creation days: numbered not named [352 words]Brutus BalanDec 8, 2011 23:56184866
1Brutus Balan is right..... [27 words]Jim BowDec 13, 2011 00:20184866
Allah means God in Arabic. The Christians have a right to the word. [48 words]Daniel AquinoApr 20, 2013 13:56184866
1Do explain please! [26 words]Brutus BalanApr 23, 2013 04:13184866
1They say "Allah" just means "God," but... [40 words]RKaeOct 14, 2013 10:16184866
1So many mistakes. [308 words]SharbanoOct 14, 2013 14:20184866
2Some Islamic governments disagree with you [96 words]saraOct 16, 2013 15:59184866
Appropriateness of this article [210 words]Nick LimOct 19, 2013 00:43184866
Let's see if it is inappropriate and undefying? [209 words]Brutus BalanOct 21, 2013 01:36184866
From 'gut' to 'God' [92 words]Brutus BalanOct 21, 2013 01:49184866
5The word Allah is a loan word from Syriac Alaha also Allaha [372 words]dhimmi no moreOct 26, 2013 07:43184866
Allah and God [170 words]Av MoidenOct 26, 2013 14:29184866
Odd [129 words]VijayOct 27, 2013 07:28184866
Not odd, if the issue is God [408 words]Brutus BalanOct 29, 2013 01:40184866
1Christianity use Allah before Islam so it was Islam who mock identity of "Loving" Allah to become "T3rror" Allah. [304 words]VicenteOct 30, 2013 05:11184866
Why stay out? [151 words]VijayNov 5, 2013 07:34184866
Stay Out and Muse Elsewhere [297 words]Brutus BalanNov 5, 2013 21:48184866
not appropriate [97 words]VijayNov 8, 2013 13:02184866
Move on, shall we? [136 words]Brutus BalanNov 8, 2013 20:51184866
1Is the Qur'an a plagiarism of the Bible [232 words]Awang Matasan AlliJun 26, 2014 23:36184866
1Our dear Awang tells us that Muhammad was illiterate which very well explains why the Qur'an is such a confused and confusing book [391 words]dhimmi no moreJun 28, 2014 09:58184866
1The Qur'an is a corrupted and edited book! Oh my evidence? read and enjoy [755 words]dhimmi no moreJun 28, 2014 10:28184866
1The illiterate and his book [183 words]dhimmi no moreJun 30, 2014 06:31184866
1See I told you that slience is golden! The eye of the needle and camels and plagiarism [233 words]dhimmi no moreJun 30, 2014 08:59184866
2Allah is the same God of the Bible, [225 words]John DanielsDec 19, 2014 15:30184866
Our dear JD is quoting a corrupted book to prove a point [647 words]dhimmi no moreDec 20, 2014 09:50184866
1Our dear JD the so called "scholar" [360 words]dhimmi no moreDec 21, 2014 12:11184866
allah ... [77 words]steveMay 27, 2015 20:44184866
1Allah the moon god [33 words]paz rodriguezMar 18, 2016 14:49184866
Wrong. [170 words]DIOct 7, 2016 22:31184866
1Most interviews of Middle East experts in the MOMENT are extremely disturbing [88 words]Phil MondMay 3, 2011 22:09184831
Shoot for a B+ [191 words]Jay1May 3, 2011 19:35184829
1Be Careful What You Wish For! [93 words]Barry BlackMay 3, 2011 17:14184821
1Non-violence [46 words]Frank LukeMay 3, 2011 16:51184819
Israel Needs to Move in Only One Direction [808 words]M. ToveyMay 3, 2011 16:06184818
A rapidly changing universe [85 words]Abraham IrwinMay 5, 2011 10:26184818
Only the Temporary Changes; Beyond the Reach of Time Nothing Changes [668 words]M. ToveyMay 6, 2011 15:16184818
2Deciciveness and Determination [257 words]yonatan silvermanMay 3, 2011 14:51184816
Not complelety against it but you aren't facing the problems that will bring... [166 words]Abu NudnikMay 5, 2011 12:05184816
3The CHICKEN and EGG Question Remains, if anything More Urgent Than Ever [873 words]Ron ThompsonMay 3, 2011 14:42184815
1A troubling issue, if we overestimate them [96 words]saraMay 3, 2011 17:40184815
I fear you're right -- the Palestinians may well break the PR code by ofbserving "People Power" around them [84 words]Charles MartelMay 3, 2011 14:27184814
Would General Assembly Resolution Be De-Legitmizing Of Israel...?? [207 words]Sheldon TyberMay 3, 2011 13:54184812
Palestinian Frustration [90 words]TarekMay 3, 2011 13:29184811
Frustrations of a Self-Induced Nature - Why the World Should be Wary of the New Muslim Revolution [154 words]M. ToveyMay 4, 2011 18:23184811
1The Actions of Muslims In Tahrer Square and in Egypt Make Me Ashamed of Being Born Into Islam [119 words]Noor KhanMay 19, 2011 02:05184811
Who are the "REAL" Palestinians? [23 words]Seamus Dafydd Dives MacNemiMay 24, 2011 01:47184811
On being born Muslim [174 words]Seamus Dafydd Dives MacNemiMay 25, 2011 14:44184811
Worst terrorism during 1950-1966, nothing to do with 1967 'occupation'. [83 words]ajnnMay 26, 2011 18:44184811
1What Is Israel's Next Move In The New Middle East? [26 words]steven lMay 3, 2011 13:23184810
What Is Israel's Next Move In The New Middle East? [52 words]steven lMay 3, 2011 13:07184809
2THE NEXT MOVE- SHOULD IT BE AN ISRAELI ONE OR A PALESTINIAN ONE? [270 words]JACQUES HADIDAMay 3, 2011 12:33184808
1Hope is not enough [387 words]yonatan silvermanMay 3, 2011 12:17184807
Hope IS Enough When Faith is Its Source [521 words]M. ToveyMay 5, 2011 13:49184807
1Non violence [283 words]Jon, a Brit from EurolandMay 3, 2011 11:39184805
1Arab uprisings, democracy, and Israel [98 words]Jonathan UsherMay 3, 2011 11:23184804
Gaza-Egypt sounds not bad if Egypt wants it but... [50 words]Abu NudnikMay 5, 2011 12:17184804
It's nothing to do with democracy [34 words]LeonMay 3, 2011 11:07184803
1Deligitimization? [9 words]Melvin A. FechterMay 3, 2011 11:04184802
Don't miss even a vague opportunity [113 words]Ira KasperMay 3, 2011 10:49184801

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Regarding Israel by +Bp Gabrielle Crofts OCC

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)