69 million page views

A Rebuttal

Reader comment on item: The End of American Jewry's Golden Era
in response to reader comment: "Politically Correct" American fools.....

Submitted by A Thinker (Qatar), Jan 7, 2011 at 16:05

When I finished reading the first paragraph, I huffed a great sigh.

You see you should at least get some basic knowledge before you start hating someone/something. A basic knowledge you obviously lack, specifically towards Muslims.

Firstly, what gave you the faintest idea Muslims are war-mongering idiots and Islam is trying to screw the world over with wars? Am I correct in guessing that you summed all that up by 9/11, propaganda and maybe even CNN, or am I presuming too much effort on your end? "To each there own", you must have forgotten that saying because you seem very racist at the moment. If I were to think at your standard; I'd be calling Russia, The Mafia and while you seem to be so proud to be an American, which I bet you are, you don't seem to realise any action your country is doing globally. If you did, you wouldn't be so proud to be an American.

"Oh, Muslims are crazy, they all should die." isn't really what a proud American would say if they realised, that they stopped racial cleansing of Muslims in Bosnia and that you have the good ol mentally insane Arabs to thank for the number zero because superior-in-ever-way Europeans did not have a number equivalent to zero.

Basically, you're calling Muslims filth for having their own beliefs. You're saying that Muslims in America get every wish they have granted while they are in you great, nosy and arrogant country; have you ever thought, yes even thought, that those Muslims being insulted by you are also insulted daily by people similar to you? Bigots like you go around hating religions and think you are superior in every way because you are an American. You are the people that start wars, you are the same people that started the Nazi genocide of the Jews and today, you are the people spreading hate and welcoming Muslim Genocide.

If what you're saying is that Christianity is a religion of love, you aren't a very good Christian. But I won't say that Christianity is a religion of hate because I'm not like you, I know, at least faintly, of what I'm talking about and I know not to stereotype people. But then again, I "ain't" American am I?

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (52) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Jews in Denial of the Dark Days coming: Attracted to two scoundrels: 1) Obama & 2) Madoff [66 words]james burkeMay 26, 2009 08:24156167
Listen to those who have gone before us... [370 words]Veronique CarewFeb 18, 2008 01:54120435
Jew v. Jew [282 words]Jeff BurkeFeb 1, 2007 09:1075391
America HAS to be the World's Policeman [523 words]Dr RJPJul 1, 2006 12:4648665
america doesnt HAVE to be the worlds policeman [140 words]r.o.Apr 16, 2009 18:3948665
Militant religions [79 words]Gary NewmanSep 18, 2005 09:1925997
"Politically Correct" American fools..... [205 words]Vicki MorganSep 7, 2005 10:4225556
"Politically Correct" American fools [148 words]OlieJan 25, 2007 16:4425556
A Rebuttal [380 words]A ThinkerJan 7, 2011 16:0525556
The existence of "moderate" Muslims [75 words]Avigdor Ben-DovSep 7, 2005 02:0325544
response to Avi the Zionist [66 words]Abdulfattah BudayrNov 22, 2009 09:5525544
Reader's Observation [94 words]MordechaiAug 12, 2005 13:3524601
Defend It or lose it-Your heritage [89 words]SanmiFeb 16, 2005 15:1220399
Wake up America...When? [148 words]Chris ShivnerFeb 15, 2005 23:1920374
Americans won't allow an Islamic State in US [75 words]Kevin LoudonFeb 15, 2005 22:2520373
Islam [5 words]DadJul 20, 2006 14:1420373
Americans and the world converting to Islam. [118 words]LulwaNov 25, 2009 05:1320373
Good Article [14 words]StaceyFeb 15, 2005 14:2920364
My concerns are confirmed [186 words]Anne LeonardiMay 15, 2004 22:2915236
agree with you [89 words]Helen GordonMay 15, 2004 12:2815229
Face the truth - not the teachings.. [101 words]Anatoly GoldbergMay 10, 2004 15:2915105
Face the truth - not the teachings.. [98 words]Anatoly GoldbergMay 10, 2004 15:2715104
The end of American Jewry? [90 words]Elaine NugentMay 10, 2004 11:3615102
Excellent [87 words]SPMay 7, 2004 03:5015075
Militant Islam and jehadis+ [59 words]S.C.PandaMay 5, 2004 06:0715056
scary but true [84 words]yuval BrandstetterMay 4, 2004 13:0615033
detail mistake [13 words]ron thompsonMay 3, 2004 17:4915024
The End of American Jewry's Golden Era-Daniel Pipes Comments [82 words]NormanMay 3, 2004 15:0015023
The Koran vs The Bible [24 words]Alan TrombettaMay 3, 2004 11:3315021
notrelated to this article [1615 words]bob buckMay 3, 2004 09:3315018
Homegrown terrorism in the US will become reality unless .... [126 words]C FreedMay 3, 2004 00:4215015
Religion vs Religion or Religion vs Secularity? [531 words]A.Hamilton MencherMay 2, 2004 22:0515013
curious [117 words]AlinaJan 10, 2011 08:4515013
makes one think [169 words]yvette martinMay 2, 2004 16:5015011
Excellent!! [100 words]Darwin BarrettMay 2, 2004 16:3515009
Thailand: Killing other people is God's will in Islamic religion? [227 words]PraornMay 2, 2004 08:3215005
How can I help?? [148 words]cindy connerMay 2, 2004 08:2515004
As The Islamist Trogan Horse Grows [87 words]Major Peter St, Jean USAF retMay 2, 2004 07:1315002
Winston Churchill and the Fall of France [302 words]Uzi Amit-KohnMay 2, 2004 06:5215001
3"We await the verdict of honest men " [3623 words]Daniel WyboApr 2, 2006 11:2715001
Can we take off the Union Jacked glasses for a minute... [843 words]ArmyDickedNov 25, 2012 03:5915001
Michael C. Goncalves [394 words]ArmyDickedJan 30, 2013 05:5515001
Finally someone has assimilated Pipes concepts [79 words]Shimon PerlmutterMay 2, 2004 06:5015000
Food for Thought [454 words]Peter J. HerzMay 2, 2004 05:2914999
It is painfull to face reality. [66 words]Esther ElbazMay 1, 2004 21:3814995
The same in Europe [76 words]annemarie cherletApr 30, 2004 04:1614955
Islamist vs. Jew [91 words]Timothy B. RobertsApr 29, 2004 00:1114941
Islamic Canada [18 words]L. McClainApr 28, 2004 16:2314927
will pass this on - but the date? [35 words]roshApr 27, 2004 14:5214893
appeasement and censorship in Europe [940 words]marc jorisApr 27, 2004 09:3714880
ANOTHER wake up call [38 words]RichierichApr 27, 2004 09:0114879
It could be worse [338 words]Kenneth BesigApr 27, 2004 06:4614878

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)