69 million page views

Hating & Criticizing America Are Not The Same

Reader comment on item: Hating America's Success

Submitted by Keith Markman (United States), Oct 17, 2004 at 22:17

In fairness, I have not read, "Hating America: A History." However, one needs to take more care in differentiating between those who hate the U.S., and those who have legitimate criticisms, but do not wish us ill, or believe there are many positives that provide a counterweight to the negatives. The difference can sometimes be gleaned from the tone of the writer, but not always.
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (48) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Read John Perkin's Book: "Confessions of an Economic Hit Man" then you'll understand why we're hated [100 words]marcos VillaDec 11, 2006 18:2369144
Yes, but... [96 words]Ay-ay-asher-ay-ayFeb 21, 2006 18:1336867
to Pavel A: The Empire of the Sun vs the Empire of Opium [175 words]C.B. KoOct 30, 2005 08:4527512
therefore... [39 words]gopalanMar 4, 2010 11:3427512
Envy or Disillusion ? [386 words]C..B. KoOct 30, 2005 08:0627511
Hate and Fear? [58 words]MorganOct 31, 2004 12:3018047
Hatred, criticism and dissent [142 words]Bill KeaneOct 26, 2004 00:3917929
A Vigorous Vocal Minority [130 words]Bill FinlayOct 20, 2004 10:1717816
America... as always. [135 words]Don HOct 19, 2004 22:3517809
Hating & Criticizing America Are Not The Same [65 words]Keith MarkmanOct 17, 2004 22:1717792
Envy+Fist=Hatred: A French Primer [111 words]Kevin MOct 16, 2004 11:4817785
hating america's success [71 words]ionutJul 25, 2006 09:1817785
To Alexander M Smith [50 words]Thomas J. CassidyOct 15, 2004 21:1217776
1Ignoble reasons [79 words]Rasha Rasul-TausOct 15, 2004 20:5617774
Well ... I do not agree [135 words]Marcus RometschOct 15, 2004 07:1017761
What cost? [87 words]Pavel A.Oct 15, 2004 02:4417760
Ashamed of Success [559 words]Smith KinneyOct 13, 2004 15:4217635
A successful America?????? [3001 words]David LammermeierOct 22, 2006 22:0617635
What's the point? [171 words]Lisa WOct 13, 2004 15:1317633
We Want to Be Loved [114 words]PatOct 13, 2004 14:3217632
To Alain Jean-Mairet, Hearty thanks to you! [126 words]HollyOct 13, 2004 12:0217631
Live in it, but live to criticize it? [146 words]Joe ClarkOct 13, 2004 11:1217630
Rare acclaim for America [86 words]Edward ClineOct 13, 2004 10:4317629
Our radical idea [169 words]StephenOct 13, 2004 09:1117627
America and Europe [74 words]David DoltiesOct 13, 2004 08:5017626
USA exists.Thank you God! [175 words]Marcos BerensteinOct 12, 2004 23:4317618
America: The World Power [172 words]AlexOct 12, 2004 23:3317617
Hating America?, try Israel. [80 words]Sol EndeOct 12, 2004 23:0717616
Hate is the key word [77 words]Berg PearlOct 12, 2004 17:1617610
The Old Europeans [280 words]ArthurOct 12, 2004 17:0717609
No! [45 words]OctavioDec 12, 2006 13:3817609
Pot, kettle, black [113 words]MontyOct 12, 2004 16:5917608
They can hate us as long as they fear us too [49 words]JaneOct 12, 2004 16:5017607
Beware [193 words]YovenOct 12, 2004 16:4317606
Other World Candidates Miss Key US Component [137 words]James PashOct 12, 2004 15:2717601
their envy? or our hubris? [183 words]Mohammed Hesus ChangOct 12, 2004 14:3317600
YES! [141 words]Alexander M SmithOct 12, 2004 14:0617599
At what cost? [67 words]Peter DemmaOct 12, 2004 14:0017598
The Two Anti's [120 words]Diane KriegerOct 12, 2004 13:3817596
Hating America [129 words]Roger Gracia-MarencoOct 12, 2004 13:2617595
Thank You [136 words]Alain Jean-MairetOct 12, 2004 12:4317593
Envy [68 words]Jaime EisenOct 12, 2004 12:3217592
Self Hate [129 words]Margaret DoddererOct 12, 2004 11:0417589
the Great Satan: temptor towards a better future. [120 words]John BergOct 12, 2004 10:3717588
Analogy [84 words]R. BeckerOct 12, 2004 09:5717587
America, the land of the free........ [167 words]Kim SegarOct 12, 2004 09:3617586
What else would you expect? [169 words]William EakinsOct 12, 2004 08:4217585
Another phrase [28 words]TashanOct 12, 2004 07:5617584

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)