49 readers online now

102,159 comments by 26,997 readers

Go to Mobile Site

Quran, hadith and sharia law calls for death of apostates
Reader comment on item: Those Danish Cartoons and Me
in response to reader comment: Muslim Paranoia

Submitted by Usman Ali (United States), Feb 28, 2006 at 19:15

Mohammad: You are ignorant of quran hadith and sharia. I am a muslim living in Pakistan. We have sharia laws here in accordance with quran and sunna. In our country apostacy and blasphemy is punishable with death.

You make a fool of yourself if you make a wrong statement like you did. In this age of internet every one can find out what is in quran hadith and sira by pushing some buttons.
Here are some refernces for you :

Allah has said "Kill the renegades" (4.89)

Apostle has said:
Bukhari, Volume 4, Book 52, Number 260:
Narrated Ikrima:
Ali burnt some people alive (former muslims)., Prophet had said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' "
Ishaq:550 ". The reason that Allah's Messenger ordered Andullash Bin Sad slain was because he had become a Muslim and used to write down Qur'an Revelation. Then he apostatized (rejected islam) after becoming suspicious of some verses which prophet changed after his suggestions.

Ishaq:551 The Messenger ordered Miqyas' assassination because he became a renegade by rejecting Islam."

Bukhari, 5-59-632 Once Muadh paid a visit to Abu Musa and saw a chained man. Muadh asked, "What is this?" Abu Musa said, "(He was) a Jew who embraced Islam and has now turned apostate." Muadh said, "I will surely chop off his neck!"

Bukhari Volume 9, Book 83, Number 17:
Narrated 'Abdullah:
Allah's Apostle said, "The blood of a Muslim cannot be shed except in three cases: In Qisas for murder, a married person who commits illegal sexual intercourse and the one who reverts from Islam (apostate) and leaves the Muslims."

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

Search by Enter name or date
Search Forum Comments:

Reader comments (225) on this item

Title By Date
Islam [396 words]Dr JJul 26, 2007 20:15
The muslims should worry about things other than cartoons ! [80 words]Phil GreendJun 5, 2007 19:02
Suicide bombings [242 words]Richard VidaurriApr 14, 2006 10:20
صورة الاسلام فى الغرب
[w/response] [44 words]
RashaMar 26, 2006 15:40
Where does it end? [194 words]Ariton MarkuMar 5, 2006 13:13
Ockham's razor applied to Ariton Marku's implied question [118 words]SullyMar 6, 2006 23:33
cant blame the danish [121 words]ahmad zafireMar 8, 2006 00:10
Speak up [47 words]Jon OlsonMar 9, 2006 09:46
jews,christian and muslims [72 words]ahmad zafireMar 15, 2006 14:03
Habel Habelim, etc. [37 words]Peter HerzMar 3, 2006 11:42
Comments on Peter's post [160 words]WafaMar 3, 2006 18:58
Cartoons, public interest, opinion of the majority (Muslim) [243 words]BarbaraMar 1, 2006 14:00
for Apostate, PDM and Muhamad Ali reader on classical Islam. [307 words]HARRAKFeb 28, 2006 22:23
Response to HARRAK, No thanks I will stick to original islamic scriptures [678 words]ApostateMar 1, 2006 16:19
To HARRAK, Apostate quoted a sahih hadith [326 words]Abdullah A.Mar 1, 2006 17:49
YOUR FATHER HURAYRA giving a lesson on how to intelectualize [366 words]HARRAKMar 2, 2006 19:36
Reponse to HARRAK, Huraira was not a bad guy at all [421 words]Abdullah A.Mar 3, 2006 13:57
here is why! [95 words]HARRAKMar 3, 2006 16:49
to Harrak - Solomon and David [99 words]SiddaMar 4, 2006 10:08
Ya noor ene Ya habibi ya Harrak [112 words]LamaMar 4, 2006 22:24
Good question for lama and Sida [38 words]HARRAKMar 5, 2006 01:15
Harrak - the prophets and Thomas Jefferson [471 words]SiddaMar 6, 2006 11:43
Harrak from lama [455 words]lamaMar 6, 2006 12:57
stoning in Islam / the addiction to alegory and the problem of misunderstanding Jesus [302 words]HarrakMar 7, 2006 11:07
Harrak, jumping from subject to another [357 words]LamaMar 7, 2006 21:59
Think before you type. [208 words]MJan 27, 2007 23:26
Really? [54 words]Mia RizwanJan 14, 2009 18:14
What is the solution then? [35 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 28, 2006 16:45
Octavio [398 words]DaisyFeb 28, 2006 18:03
the solution? [613 words]SiddaFeb 28, 2006 18:13
What needs to be done? [66 words]two_heroesMar 1, 2006 00:08
I wish i'd said that [80 words]PDMMar 1, 2006 01:50
Moderate Muslims?! [40 words]Octavio JohansonMar 1, 2006 02:48
For Sidda: assimilation of Muslims [89 words]Octavio JohansonMar 1, 2006 02:55
The problem and the solution [233 words]Octavio JohansonMar 1, 2006 04:01
Here is my solution [200 words]Muhammad aliMar 1, 2006 12:42
Octavio [379 words]DaisyMar 1, 2006 15:19
Moderate Muslim - An Oxymoron [48 words]JaladhiMar 1, 2006 15:51
Muhammad Ali [103 words]DaisyMar 1, 2006 16:12
The solution: europe just needs to make the hard choices [191 words]Richard Lion heartMar 1, 2006 16:14
Octavio - we can't get rid of militant Islam [169 words]SullyMar 1, 2006 16:59
Thanks, Richard [16 words]Octavio JohansonMar 1, 2006 19:04
Thank you all [244 words]Octavio JohansonMar 1, 2006 19:18
The solution [46 words]Muhammad aliMar 1, 2006 19:53
Accuracy Muhammad Ali [314 words]DaisyMar 2, 2006 17:05
To Octavio ....Hope arrives !!!!!!! [251 words]ForTheWestMar 2, 2006 18:41
Answer to Daisy. [133 words]Muhammed AliMar 8, 2006 03:42
A solution for the solution. [185 words]Dean MooreMar 21, 2006 09:12
Threat and Intimidation will Backfire [597 words]Aidan MaconachyFeb 28, 2006 15:48
Islam in the UK - Crimewatch FACTS! [54 words]Dinesh PatelMar 7, 2006 06:39
Exchange With Christopher Bollyn/Sam Brand [511 words]William Sumner ScottFeb 28, 2006 14:29
Signs of Despair [165 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 28, 2006 06:14
Muhammad ali, No unjust killing is allowed. ? [5 words]BarbaraFeb 28, 2006 02:54
Barbara [43 words]DaisyFeb 28, 2006 09:02
Ask the civilized. [92 words]Muahmmad AliFeb 28, 2006 11:02
Re: Muhammad [108 words]BFeb 28, 2006 12:57
Response to Barbara: Islam does not allow unjust killing [414 words]ApostateFeb 28, 2006 14:25
Civilized [413 words]DaisyFeb 28, 2006 17:20
To Mohammed Ali, where do you get your info? [465 words]NazirFeb 28, 2006 18:18
Poor ignorant Mr. Ali [47 words]PDMFeb 28, 2006 18:29
Official Iraqi deaths [56 words]TimothyFeb 28, 2006 19:27
Iraqi Death Toll - Lancet Medical Journal [187 words]SiddaMar 1, 2006 09:45
Inaccurate Translation [87 words]kalamazadNov 18, 2006 18:55
You've got to understand [104 words]The Honest GuyFeb 27, 2006 17:20
Make me laugh [120 words]TimothyFeb 27, 2006 19:00
Response to Honest Guy [196 words]faqiFeb 27, 2006 19:36
The fact still remains... [30 words]SFeb 27, 2006 23:05
To honest guy: About Muhammad [152 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 27, 2006 23:47
To faqi [20 words]AGFeb 28, 2006 06:27
Please cite references! [32 words]PDMFeb 28, 2006 12:03
To Honest Guy, those so called renegades are true followers of the faith [346 words]AhmedFeb 28, 2006 16:18
AG [91 words]DaisyFeb 28, 2006 16:34
Further response to Honest guy [189 words]jakmanMar 1, 2006 15:09
ANTI-SEMITISM and Harrak [155 words]ForTheWestFeb 27, 2006 16:03
Anti-Semitism [101 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 28, 2006 14:10
Hypocrisy of indignation ! [90 words]L RajFeb 27, 2006 08:04
To L.Raj.... drawings of mohammed [13 words]nFeb 28, 2006 22:55
Well, get on your horse Mr. Ali! [116 words]PDMFeb 26, 2006 17:21
Islam is different from other religions [120 words]HackFeb 27, 2006 11:58
Indeed - what is the answer? [55 words]PDMFeb 28, 2006 11:58
lies spread demeaning Daniel Pipes [88 words]A.B.Feb 26, 2006 12:34
arabs and nazi folks are yo yo [92 words]cheik yanFeb 25, 2006 21:57
Dear cheik yan [136 words]PDMFeb 26, 2006 17:14
Muslims Conspiracy in Cricket [76 words]Dinesh PatelFeb 25, 2006 19:30
Danes apologize to all muslims of the world [136 words]JonFeb 25, 2006 17:37
To Jon [294 words]Obied khanFeb 26, 2006 01:25
Correction to Danes apologize to all muslims of the world [158 words]Obied khanFeb 26, 2006 01:35
We are sorry....... [11 words]SFeb 26, 2006 22:44
To, Obied Khan, Danes are sorry [142 words]JonFeb 27, 2006 00:22
Why is it............ [21 words]TimothyFeb 27, 2006 13:19
Why! here is the answer [33 words]HARRAKFeb 27, 2006 18:14
What ?!?! [73 words]TimothyFeb 27, 2006 19:07
Christianity and border control [53 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 28, 2006 02:21
Feeble Reply - Harrak [146 words]Another InfidelFeb 28, 2006 03:41
to Octavio [391 words]SiddaFeb 28, 2006 10:12
War in your dreams, USA terrorism activities and the legal responsibility [346 words]HARRAKFeb 28, 2006 11:51
Don't pout Obied khan [195 words]Precious OneFeb 28, 2006 16:00
Because we have let them! [149 words]Precious OneFeb 28, 2006 19:34
to Precious One [376 words]SiddaMar 1, 2006 10:18
Message to Sidda [346 words]Precious OneMar 2, 2006 14:18
Message to Another Infidel [24 words]Precious OneMar 2, 2006 18:20
Hitler Had His Conspiracy Theories About Jews [160 words]Joe LeviFeb 25, 2006 12:53
Zero tolerance for people who deny the Holocaust.. [56 words]Robert MooneyFeb 25, 2006 11:38
To Robert [218 words]Dinesh PatelFeb 26, 2006 15:45
We already lost the war [196 words]Claude FredjFeb 25, 2006 11:02
To Claude Fredj [61 words]AsmaFeb 25, 2006 20:53
Reply to Asma [160 words]TimothyFeb 27, 2006 18:50
Blame it on the INFIDELS [126 words]Claude FredjFeb 28, 2006 10:36
If all of this.... [40 words]SFeb 25, 2006 05:42
waste of time [180 words]Derrick ConleyFeb 25, 2006 03:57
the McGuffin [85 words]Charles FortnerFeb 24, 2006 16:40
Desensitizing Muslims [231 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 24, 2006 12:45
Dr Jamshid and the bitter pill that works wonders in the world of Gynecology [309 words]HARRAKFeb 26, 2006 13:06
HARRAK [171 words]DaisyFeb 27, 2006 11:45
WHAT !!! [219 words]TimothyFeb 27, 2006 13:11
Daizy and Timothy [210 words]HARRAKFeb 27, 2006 18:09
Q. for Timothy [74 words]DaisyFeb 27, 2006 23:06
Answer to Daisy [156 words]TimothyFeb 28, 2006 10:23
explaining the term Vandalogist for the weak in history [77 words]HARRAKFeb 28, 2006 12:02
Vandalogist [163 words]DaisyFeb 28, 2006 18:22
Ah, broken English is the explanation [31 words]TimothyFeb 28, 2006 19:50
Answer for Timothy and Daizy on y words that are not in the dictionary with the proverb for both, enjoy! [215 words]HARRAKFeb 28, 2006 22:42
HARRAK's Proverb [109 words]DaisyMar 1, 2006 15:00
Good pint Daisy! keep up! [22 words]HARRAKMar 1, 2006 16:08
Lies [110 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 24, 2006 05:47
Octavio Johanson and complex the other [350 words]HARRAKFeb 24, 2006 20:17
Poor Harrak! [8 words]PDMFeb 26, 2006 00:03
Poor Octavia [76 words]Muhammed aliFeb 27, 2006 09:11
100 million smokers can't be wrong! [11 words]PDMFeb 28, 2006 12:05
Arguing with Muslims [56 words]Octavio JohansonMar 4, 2006 08:30
Universal Constants [92 words]ShoshFeb 23, 2006 18:45
Narrow minded! [63 words]Another InfidelFeb 24, 2006 15:56
Low quality reasoning [101 words]Muhammed aliFeb 27, 2006 19:50
Low quality versus Muslim quality? [127 words]Another InfidelFeb 28, 2006 04:52
Vatican to Muslims: Practice what you preach [2 words]SophieFeb 23, 2006 18:27
Thank you Sophie [26 words]LisaFeb 24, 2006 16:31
Reply to Lisa [105 words]SophieFeb 25, 2006 20:28
Conspiracy theorists living in parallel universe [57 words]Ben van de PolderFeb 23, 2006 16:40
A thought on conspiracy theories... [126 words]two_heroesFeb 23, 2006 13:51
Difficult [85 words]Sameer JordanFeb 23, 2006 05:01
conspiracy theories [236 words]sycophantFeb 23, 2006 03:52
Response to "Piped Off" [318 words]Merry WhitneyFeb 23, 2006 21:24
Misrepresentation and False Information [105 words]Aidan MaconachyFeb 23, 2006 00:11
Strange Group [115 words]Muhammed aliFeb 22, 2006 22:38
Mohammed Ali and his theory. [319 words]NicholasFeb 23, 2006 01:24
Muhammad Ali [88 words]DaisyFeb 23, 2006 15:11
THE LET GO theory is what happened in 911 [254 words]HARRAKFeb 23, 2006 19:49
Muhammad Ali reveals why It's no surprise that Muslims hate Jews [81 words]sullyFeb 24, 2006 00:49
Anti-Semitism- the real face of it.. [161 words]HARRAKFeb 25, 2006 12:38
Anti-semitism and Harrak's childhood [238 words]ForTheWestFeb 25, 2006 21:51
Strange Group [47 words]Muhammed aliFeb 26, 2006 14:31
for the west and the childhood pain [197 words]HARRAKFeb 26, 2006 23:39
No to the conspiracy theory yes to the let go theory [152 words]HARRAKFeb 27, 2006 00:04
Harrak's anti-semitic theory [75 words]NicholasFeb 27, 2006 09:50
Degree [111 words]JohnFeb 22, 2006 18:16
Muslim Paranoia [197 words]JaladhiFeb 22, 2006 17:14
To Jaladhi [39 words]Dinesh PatelFeb 26, 2006 15:49
Our religion is open to any one. [161 words]Muhammed aliFeb 27, 2006 10:22
To Ali: Apostasy in Islam [211 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 27, 2006 23:35
To Ali: The Usual Lies [29 words]JaladhiFeb 28, 2006 10:14
⇒ Quran, hadith and sharia law calls for death of apostates [264 words]Usman AliFeb 28, 2006 19:15
Can't be right [40 words]ShumanJun 21, 2007 01:27
facts, lies, spin, propoganda [183 words]AndyFeb 22, 2006 13:15
The Danish Cartoons and Daniel Pipes [82 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 22, 2006 12:51
True in parts, but not the whole [70 words]David W. LincolnFeb 22, 2006 11:31
Conspiracy Rebuttal [53 words]Mark RothFeb 22, 2006 09:32
EXACTLY !!!!! [65 words]TimothyFeb 25, 2006 12:57
Harrak and anti-semitism [88 words]Jeremy MattilFeb 25, 2006 22:08
NO Antisemitism here ...... [101 words]Aisha RehmanFeb 26, 2006 00:59
The real Daniel Pipes [289 words]Theodore MoranFeb 22, 2006 09:16
Cowardly Muslim Leaders Bully Small Countries: Israel, Denmark [154 words]Jeff BurkeFeb 22, 2006 06:58
Cartoons and Lunacy of Perception [191 words]Howard R GrayFeb 22, 2006 02:38
hit the nail on the head [172 words]yuval brandstetter MDFeb 23, 2006 17:26
My response sent to Mr. Bollyn [90 words]William Sumner ScottFeb 22, 2006 02:19
"wickedness prevails not over Wisdom" [84 words]Ahmed Youssif, MDFeb 22, 2006 01:13
Dr. Pipes is himself the victim here --- of Leftist denial [133 words]TechnomericanFeb 22, 2006 00:30
Not, alas, atypical of Muslim thinking [101 words]Charles R.L. PowerFeb 21, 2006 23:00
Anti Muslim [240 words]faqi hussainFeb 21, 2006 20:52
Ah, those wacky Muslims. what will they think of next? [565 words]MaximusFeb 21, 2006 20:33
No Clash of Civilizations? [35 words]Darwin BarrettFeb 21, 2006 19:28
Clash of Barbarians with Civilized World [17 words]JaladhiFeb 22, 2006 15:01
Apprehension is too mild a word [82 words]M. K. SmedstadFeb 21, 2006 18:31
What ails mankind? [120 words]G.BisvasFeb 22, 2006 14:01
Understanding "conspiracies" [79 words]Merry WhitneyFeb 21, 2006 16:56
Other nefarious deeds of Dr. Pipes ... [34 words]Victor PurintonFeb 21, 2006 16:41
Ms. Rice [33 words]Ferdinand GajewskiFeb 21, 2006 16:23
Good Point Dr. Pipes [68 words]Obied KhanFeb 21, 2006 15:59
"Good Point," but Obied Khan left out a key phrase... [110 words]Merry WhitneyFeb 21, 2006 21:11
M. Whitney/Obied K. [320 words]DaisyFeb 21, 2006 22:32
Yet another perfect example of Islamic deception [50 words]Logan BerryFeb 22, 2006 08:35
Obied Khan [82 words]Mike RosenbergFeb 22, 2006 13:04
Believing in unbelievable conspiracy theories [149 words]NazFeb 22, 2006 16:01
I have proved my point to all of you [161 words]Obied KhanFeb 22, 2006 16:39
misquoting [165 words]ryanFeb 22, 2006 20:58
Obied Khan, you did not prove anything [137 words]BorisFeb 22, 2006 21:11
Response to Obied Khan, "I have proved my point..." [79 words]Merry WhitneyFeb 22, 2006 23:19
Obied Khan [165 words]DaisyFeb 22, 2006 23:33
Obeid, preach to the choir [214 words]SiddaFeb 23, 2006 10:29
Sidda [74 words]DaisyFeb 23, 2006 14:49
Obied Khan: Muslim apologists are the ones misquoting quranic ayas [415 words]John MFeb 23, 2006 17:09
Quranic verse is clear. [126 words]Muhammad aliFeb 27, 2006 10:47
Response to Mohammed Ali [623 words]John M.Feb 28, 2006 13:18
Mohammad Ali, Islam prohibits killing of innocent muslims only, non muslims are considered guilty for denying islam [301 words]HishamFeb 28, 2006 18:38
Question to Mohammad, Is not killing of apostates and blasphemers unjust killing?. [54 words]A.AFeb 28, 2006 18:50
Mohammad, Is asassinating one's critics unjust killing and violation of Quran [27 words]A.A.Feb 28, 2006 18:56
danish cartoons [223 words]mariam( muslim)Jul 26, 2006 11:45
Quoting Hadiths are dangerous without knowing their validity. [564 words]Chris G.Jun 19, 2007 13:34
Chris G. [76 words]ASJun 19, 2007 14:18
You fail to understand... or I fail to communicate. [503 words]Chris G.Jun 19, 2007 16:02
Chris G the social scientist [61 words]ASJun 20, 2007 14:57
My apologies [439 words]Chris G.Jun 21, 2007 11:35
to Chris G, and Dhimmitude [366 words]ASJun 22, 2007 01:30
wow [181 words]Chris G.Jun 22, 2007 17:45
to Chris G [302 words]ASJun 24, 2007 05:59
to AS [681 words]Chris G.Jun 25, 2007 10:29
to Chris G on the gravity of the situation [818 words]ASJun 26, 2007 16:01
So we should kill'em all if they don't convert to Christ? Sounds like Islamic extremism to me. [1691 words]Chris G.Jun 27, 2007 01:37
to Chris G and his propoganda [148 words]ASJun 28, 2007 04:06
Propaganda? [1197 words]Chris G.Jun 30, 2007 12:28
to Chris G [752 words]ASJul 1, 2007 17:17
ASsumptions are dangerous when you use them as facts. [1731 words]Chris G.Jul 3, 2007 12:37
to Chris G [976 words]ASJul 5, 2007 04:05
Ah, good now we get to the meat of things... [2302 words]Chris G.`Jul 7, 2007 19:26
to Chris G on those Hindus [20 words]ASJul 12, 2007 12:58
Um...ok [396 words]Chris G.`Jul 14, 2007 10:25

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See the 25 most recent outstanding comments.

ADVERTISEMENTS

Premium Links by Wikio

Computers
Electronics
Communication
Appliances

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials written by Daniel Pipes on this site © 1976-2010 Daniel Pipes. Email: MeqMef@aol.com

You can help support Daniel Pipes' important work by making a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.